Forever Evil: Arkham War #1

Posted by k4tzm4n (35230 posts) - - Show Bio

The Good

ARKHAM WAR's premise had me absolutely stoked when it was first announced. I love me some Batman villains (who doesn't?), and out of all of them, Bane is without question my favorite. So, the concept of Bane essentially going to war with the other big bads in what remains of Gotham is beyond exciting. Sadly, Scarecrow and Bane's Villains Month issues left me disappointed (which were meant as teases for the event), delivering what were ultimately okay but forgettable reads. Naturally, this left me with a bit of hesitation going into the premiere issue of this story but thankfully, Peter J. Tomasi has kicked things off with a bang. As a big Bane fan, I'm honestly super pleased.

While Bane's initial takeover goes mostly as expected, it hardly feels as generic as it should because what unfolds is superbly badass. If you've been craving more of Bane in action, there's some seriously crowd-pleasing stuff to be found within this issue. Yes, a vast majority of this chapter is fairly predictable, however, Tomasi throws a major variable into the picture which is sure to be very interesting upon being fleshed out. It's just another piece on the board which is sure to make things notably thrilling as the conflict escalates.

Scot Eaton (pencils) and Andrew Dalhouse (colors) create a fine looking issue which is packed with more than a handful of praiseworthy images. Their work on Bane is most definitely worth admiring. As Tomasi shows off the villain's strategic mind, this duo makes it more than clear he's a physically formidable threat as well and is sporting a truly fearsome stature. It's also impressive just how many panels reveal scenes of chaos among various characters and there's never a standout lack of detail upon glancing through it. Even though there's three inkers, there isn't an especially noticeable or jarring change of quality during the experience.

The Bad

Bane's forces assaulting districts which belong to interesting characters are glossed over in one panel each, failing to really give me the true impact of the madness which is unfolding. Despite such an explosive cover and plot premise, the scale so far isn't feeling quite as grand as it could. Hopefully Tomasi will be able to juggle this huge roster of individuals well and give each at least a decent amount of the spotlight as the storyline progresses. An unexpected character receives a fair amount of attention this time around (which will hopefully serve a greater purpose) and it'll be interesting to see how much space is allotted to the others.

Minor gripe: Scarecrow's appearance is somewhat inconsistent and, truth be told, his role feels rather minuscule in this issue. Unlike his solo issue, he hardly comes off as a character who has what it takes to lead -- or at the very least, manipulate -- a true challenge against Bane's forces. To be fair, though, this issue seemed to primarily focus on Bane and is apparently only in the very early stages of Crane's plan. At any rate, it's clear this issue is all about letting the reader know why Bane's such a large threat. Hopefully the next issue will give Scarecrow a similar treatment because right now it's tough to believe this will be a war instead of a total slaughter.

The Verdict

Bane's actions may not feel like a large-scale war yet (despite some great panels of battles), but the pressure is certainly building and this was a good way to kick things off. This issue almost comes off as a love letter to Bane, showcasing why he's indeed a threat who has what it takes to rule Gotham now that Batman isn't around. Toss in an intriguing factor and some solid artwork and you bet ARKHAM WAR has me curious to see what is thrown our way next.

And yes, you don't really need to read the previous Villains Month issues (Bane/Scarecrow) to get a proper hold of what's going on. This is totally a serviceable jumping on spot for the story and rightfully so.

Staff
#1 Posted by BR_Havoc (1161 posts) - - Show Bio

I am really getting sick of Talons. They need to stop relying on them so much.

#2 Posted by thaalsinestro (13 posts) - - Show Bio

I'm happy to hear this book turned out pretty good, I added this along with A.R.G.U.S. and Rogue's Rebellion to my pull list the same time I added Forever Evil but I wasn't sure if I should have... Alteast I know 1 of the 3 is going to be a decent read so far.

#3 Posted by HollowPrince65 (143 posts) - - Show Bio

@br_havoc: This is mainly for Talon. I doubt you'll really be seeing much of them in Batman or anything.

#4 Edited by Shallbecomeabattoo (355 posts) - - Show Bio

Sounds great! I love me some Bane. Time to get Tom Hardy's voice in my head again.

#6 Posted by timelord (462 posts) - - Show Bio

It was fine for a set up issue. I hope it does pick up the pace a bit.

#7 Posted by Wilbertus (293 posts) - - Show Bio

This issue almost comes off as a love letter to Bane

Now that's an interesting way to describe it!

Truth be told, I picked it up but haven't gotten a chance to sit down and read it (Batman #24 had my priority!) Nonetheless, from what I glanced over, I felt the same way as the review characterizes. However, I can hardly express ho excited I am for the whole story to unfold and I always love the big "can you name them all?" kind of art, as on the cover for this issue. I hope Scarecrow will gain more prominence over the course of the war and I am confident he will. You might prefer Bane, but I am with team Crane!

#8 Posted by cobra88king8 (324 posts) - - Show Bio

Kind of surprised that Pyg has such a prominent role in this issue. I understand they needed a rogue to fall under the bus for Bane's first assault but I think the impact would be more prominent if Bane took out a more iconic rogue

#9 Posted by Darklexeus (39 posts) - - Show Bio

Wait, didn't the whole taking over the city thing happen before in No Man's Land? I may just check this book out to see how it is if I happen to find a comic book store that sells it. But hopefully I won't wind up being disappointed.

#10 Posted by Marionettegeist (1912 posts) - - Show Bio

Kind of surprised that Pyg has such a prominent role in this issue. I understand they needed a rogue to fall under the bus for Bane's first assault but I think the impact would be more prominent if Bane took out a more iconic rogue

Probably but, I don't think it was supposed to have that much impact. Bane just wanted someone to inform the others that he's taking over. Plus it was kind of nice seeing Pyg again.

#11 Edited by saoakden (968 posts) - - Show Bio

Man I want to read this. If it has Bane in it, I'm sold.

#12 Posted by jwalser3 (4479 posts) - - Show Bio

Great issue! I felt that the distract battles were done okay, kinda like how a movie will show flashes of battle taking place.

Plus the art was great!

#13 Posted by Protoflash (98 posts) - - Show Bio

I thought this was an awesome issue! I felt as though professor pyg's shall we say "Experiments" were a little over the top but it was pretty good. But this had me asking the same question I ask myself on a daily basis as a comic reader: "Why does anyone live in gotham. Like, ever?" Just because there was this massive myriad of s*** going down and it seems a little unbelievable that anyone would want to live in gotham these days. Also I feel like they could've touched more on what happened to nightwing, but still a good book.

#14 Posted by Dark_Guyver (2081 posts) - - Show Bio

@protoflash: Actually, Bruce Wayne gives a speech in Batman 24 about why people choose to remain in Gotham.

#15 Posted by CrazyScarecrow (1019 posts) - - Show Bio
#16 Edited by Eivion (73 posts) - - Show Bio

Wait, didn't the whole taking over the city thing happen before in No Man's Land? I may just check this book out to see how it is if I happen to find a comic book store that sells it. But hopefully I won't wind up being disappointed.

Its a good first issue. It seems to take aspects of No Man's Land and Knightfall.

#17 Posted by kaiklown (63 posts) - - Show Bio

@br_havoc: But they are one of the few good things about new52 Bats

#18 Posted by Veshark (8560 posts) - - Show Bio

I really love the premise and the idea...plus the solicit for #3 has Bane fighting Croc in HTH! I'll probably wait to get this in trade.

#19 Edited by Saren (24401 posts) - - Show Bio

Penguin would have been far more logical an opponent for Bane than Scarecrow. When's the last time Crane actually led anything? I still don't understand why the Society went to him to be their Gotham representative.

Moderator Online
#20 Edited by Veshark (8560 posts) - - Show Bio

@citizenbane said:

Penguin would have been far more logical an opponent for Bane than Scarecrow. When's the last time Crane actually led anything? I still don't understand why the Society went to him to be their Gotham representative.

I read in a Tomasi interview that the idea behind it was the crazy lunatics from Arkham on one side vs. the hardcore killers of Blackgate on the other. I guess Penguin doesn't fit the crazy bill as well as Crane?

#21 Posted by mcbean (288 posts) - - Show Bio

Has potential

#22 Posted by BR_Havoc (1161 posts) - - Show Bio
#23 Edited by Protoflash (98 posts) - - Show Bio

@dark_guyver: I know. But still, that was BEFORE people went and tainted the water supply and blew up the banks and stuff. Like, if bane started fighting killer croc down the street from me, i'd get the HELL out

#25 Posted by War Killer (19520 posts) - - Show Bio

I like the idea of the villains dividing Gotham up among each other, while Bane tries to take it all for himself. I'm excited for this and find the concept of the villains fighting for control of the city when Batman is taken out of the picture. All I know is that I'm rooting for Bane's army and seeing the Talons being brought into the mix, I'm looking forward to seeing where this storyline goes.

#26 Posted by TDK_1997 (13739 posts) - - Show Bio

I liked the first issue a lot but as you said k4tz Scarecrow didn't felt like the leader type.I don't think that Bane is going to have any problems at all with crushing Crane and his men.

#27 Edited by Dark_Guyver (2081 posts) - - Show Bio

@protoflash: oh yea! I'm with you, I'd be out of there too!

#28 Posted by detective38 (139 posts) - - Show Bio

If your looking for a deep intellectual look into the inner workings of batmans greatest villians then this series will probably not be for you but if your looking said villians to beat the living guano out of each other for 6 issues then pick up this series

#29 Posted by BigCimmerian (7597 posts) - - Show Bio

I thought this was an awesome issue! I felt as though professor pyg's shall we say "Experiments" were a little over the top but it was pretty good. But this had me asking the same question I ask myself on a daily basis as a comic reader: "Why does anyone live in gotham. Like, ever?" Just because there was this massive myriad of s*** going down and it seems a little unbelievable that anyone would want to live in gotham these days. Also I feel like they could've touched more on what happened to nightwing, but still a good book.

It's one of the biggest mysteries in my life lol. They have Court of Owls attacks, Talia's Leviathan, Bane's army, Atlantis drowned half of the city lol, Wrath killed half of GCPD, Joker did the same as Wrath, every month they suffer Arkham and Blackgate massive breakouts, not to mention other psychos, criminals, street thugs and gangsters. It looks like 1000's of people die every day in Gotham, and things I mentioned happened only in New 52 lol.

#30 Posted by MonkeyToe (386 posts) - - Show Bio

I agree with the issues you point out, Greg, but for me they keep me from enjoying this issue as much as I want to. The idea is awesome and I want to see more, but this issue doesn't make me feel like Bane is wise enough to win this war or to really be that major of a threat. But his opposition doesn't seem that much smarter! This should be building up to an epic battle. Instead it left me scratching my head. I only gave it 3 stars, mostly for concept.

#31 Posted by BigCimmerian (7597 posts) - - Show Bio

I agree with the issues you point out, Greg, but for me they keep me from enjoying this issue as much as I want to. The idea is awesome and I want to see more, but this issue doesn't make me feel like Bane is wise enough to win this war or to really be that major of a threat. But his opposition doesn't seem that much smarter! This should be building up to an epic battle. Instead it left me scratching my head. I only gave it 3 stars, mostly for concept.

I think he's already the ruler of Gotham, they will now try to take away Gotham from him.

#32 Posted by MonkeyToe (386 posts) - - Show Bio

@monkeytoe said:

I agree with the issues you point out, Greg, but for me they keep me from enjoying this issue as much as I want to. The idea is awesome and I want to see more, but this issue doesn't make me feel like Bane is wise enough to win this war or to really be that major of a threat. But his opposition doesn't seem that much smarter! This should be building up to an epic battle. Instead it left me scratching my head. I only gave it 3 stars, mostly for concept.

I think he's already the ruler of Gotham, they will now try to take away Gotham from him.

That's not what I got from the book. Point 1.) Gordon says "Gotham's been split between a dozen homicidal Arkham escapees." Point 2.) Even Bane says, "What Arkham and its mad idiots thought it controlled is now mine."

So I don't see how you come to the conclusion that he is already the ruler.

#33 Posted by BigCimmerian (7597 posts) - - Show Bio

@bigcimmerian said:

@monkeytoe said:

I agree with the issues you point out, Greg, but for me they keep me from enjoying this issue as much as I want to. The idea is awesome and I want to see more, but this issue doesn't make me feel like Bane is wise enough to win this war or to really be that major of a threat. But his opposition doesn't seem that much smarter! This should be building up to an epic battle. Instead it left me scratching my head. I only gave it 3 stars, mostly for concept.

I think he's already the ruler of Gotham, they will now try to take away Gotham from him.

That's not what I got from the book. Point 1.) Gordon says "Gotham's been split between a dozen homicidal Arkham escapees." Point 2.) Even Bane says, "What Arkham and its mad idiots thought it controlled is now mine."

So I don't see how you come to the conclusion that he is already the ruler.

I meant that he became ruler after the end of issue. Arkham psychos controlled it and now they lost it all to Bane.

#34 Posted by MonkeyToe (386 posts) - - Show Bio

@bigcimmerian:

That would be less a war and more a rebellion really and if it were true it would make me like the issue even less. The whole point of the series is to be a war for who controls Gotham in the wake of Forever Evil, plus there was all that stuff about the Penguin getting ready for Bane's attack. If that issue summed up Bane 'taking control' I will be severely disappointed.

#35 Posted by andrewwann7 (21 posts) - - Show Bio
#36 Posted by Jake Fury (17928 posts) - - Show Bio

Finally got this and I wasn't disappointed. Loved seeing Professor Pyg get such a starring role in the 1st issue.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.