cerial442's FF #1 - Parts of a Hole review

The Understudies

Let me start by saying I liked this. I'm saying that because when this was announced, I was very against this book. I thought the concept sounded dumb, the team looked lame, and it was going to be a waste.

I read Fantastic Four, and did for most of Hickman's run. I never really bought FF outside of three issues. I was able to follow Fantastic Four just fine. I like Fraction as well. His run on Iron Man is probably the best in my opinion. I love what he is doing on Hawkeye. I liked Defenders for what it was, and I hated his stuff on Thor. I thought Thor was confusing and hard to follow. I was reluctant to try this.

So after reading the first issue of the Fantastic Four (and digging it), I decided Tuesday I would get at least the first issue. Well now I'll be getting issue 2.

This is a setup issue and if you are reading Fantastic Four you don't have to read this. Sure the woman who will be be Ms Thing is in Fantastic Four, but again this issue isn't a part 2 of anything.

Basically the Fantastic Four are going away from this universe for 4 minutes. Since Reed is a believer in Murphy's Law he asks the rest of the team to find a temporary replacement. That's what this issue is. Setup of the characters, and the Fantastic Four picking their replacements. The best sequence was The Thing and She Hulk. Also they didn't really stray too far away from the original FF book. All of those characters are still there, and we get a good introduction to them if you have never read FF before. You'll know all you need to know about Dragon Man in one panel.

The art in the issue is done by Mike Allred. You either love it or you hate it. I like it. I'm glad they aren't using the same artist for this and Fantastic Four, it sets both apart.

So if you were like me and you were against this book, give it a chance. It was fun. It makes a good side piece to Fantastic Four. If you read both books, they match up really well. The beauty of it, I believe you could read one or the other and not be lost.

I wanted to hate this book so much, but I can't. Check it out. Not the oddest book I've read this week either, that honor goes to Chew.


Other reviews for FF #1 - Parts of a Hole

    The Superior Companion 0

    Just like it's counterpart, this first issue of FF is pretty much all setup. It's funny though, because even though this issue is MORE setup and LESS action than Fantastic Four #1, I think I enjoyed this issue MORE.Mike Allred's artwork is a very interesting counterpart of Mark Bagley's. Bagley has a lot of nice details, rich layers of coloring and ink while Allred's artwork is a lot more simplistic and free. I'm not going to say either one is better, they each serve their purposes. Bagley as a ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    FF #1 Review 0

    Marvel has tried really hard in the past decade to get new readers on board with their material. They started the Ultimate comics line for that sole purpose and they didn't stop there. They did the Point One Initiative (which technically is still going) and now we're at Marvel NOW!, a line-wide relaunch of most of the major titles. Some of these relaunches have been very effective, others not so much. What makes the successful ones good and the bad ones tank? Well, I know the answer to one of th...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.