Elle sits in her father's office as he hands her her first Company assignment— monitoring Claire Bennet. Elle brushes the assignment off as pointless, but Bob reminds her Claire and her blood could become a great asset to the Company, like Linderman and Arthur Petrelli.

On Day 17 of her assignment, Elle sits behind Claire in social studies class in school. She talks about her hatred for Claire and draws a picture of her electrocuting Claire. During a stake-out at the Bennets' house, Elle watches Noah and Sandra through a window. Elle hears a growl next to her and turns to see Mr. Muggles, who starts barking at her. Elle tries to shoo him away, but he continues barking. She decides to shock him and begins charging up, but unfortunately for her, the sprinklers turn on and she electrocutes herself.

Out of the shadows, Eden tells Elle she read her file and found out water shorts out and reverse her ability. Eden proceeds to beat Elle down, saying if Elle doesn't use her ability, then she won't use hers. Noah comes outside to stop Eden and tells Elle to stop spying on them— watching over Claire is his job. Elle gets up and walks away, saying once Claire manifests her ability and gets handed over to the Company, she will be as nice to Claire as Eden was to Elle. At school the next day, Elle watches as Claire and Zach talk in the hallway.

Elle watches Claire and Zach talk outside school, but backs off after receiving a disapproving look from Noah. Later, Elle spies on Zach and Claire from afar, just missing Claire's sixth test of her ability at the abandoned refinery. She notices the two watching a tape and devises a plan to get it.

Elle walks up to Zach's home and knocks on the front door. Zach answers and she tells him her name's Cindy— she's in his fourth period English class and he was going to let her copy his notes. Elle ignores Zach's statement that he doesn't remember any of that, and after realizing flirting with him is futile, creates a ball of electricity to threaten him. Before she can use it, however, Noah and the Haitian step in and Noah pistol whips Elle, knocking her out. The Haitian proceeds to erase Elle's memory of Zach and the tape.

On Day 27 of her assignment, Elle sits in social studies class and ponders what other, more important things she can be doing. Elle reminds herself her dad said if Claire doesn't manifest an ability by next week, the assignment is canceled. Elle is grateful for that, because Homecoming is next week and Elle would have to shoot herself if she had to attend.

After Matt Neuenberg is booed off-stage at his school talent show, Elle tells Matt she can take him to a place where he'll be safe from the outside world. To diminish his distrust, Elle electrocutes the stage and sets it on fire and leads him out. At the Company's facility, Elle watches aside her father as Matt is tested on by a man and the Haitian. Matt screams Elle's name in pain, causing Elle to show pain as well. She brings a cake to Matt in his cell and lights the candles. Matt asks her why she didn't protected him like she promised, but she says by bringing him here, she already has. She tells him they're not that different and they both want the same thing, then gives him an electric kiss on the cheek.

Elle stands behind Matt Neuenberg in the Company computer room. She checks on his progress and gives him a playful zap to his nose to lighten the mood. She leaves for a moment to get donuts for the two of them, and on her return, is asked by Matt who would send files from Bhutan. Elle wonders who would do anything in Bhutan, then calls her father per request of Matt to find out if he knows anything. After she calls him, she drops the phone in a panic and pushes Matt out of the way. She pulls out a pair of goggles from a device and hastily puts them on Matt, telling him she needs to delete all the information in the mainframe and also needs Matt to store all the information in his mind before she can do so. After promising Matt it'll be painless, Elle hits a button on the device to begin the information storage into Matt's brain.

Matt manages to memorize all the information, and Elle uses her powers to destroy the machine, possibly killing Hana and Drucker. Bob praises Neuenberg for his work, but ignores Elle. Later, Elle tries to take Matt out, just him, her and a bodyguard, but they actually try to take the information from his mind. The process kills Matt, and Elle is left looking distraught over his dead body.

Later, she works with Thompson Jr. to recruit a girl named Donna who has the ability to see long range distances. Donna was then tipped off by a anonymous person named "evsdropr" that he was being followed. Donna then shoots Thompson Jr. then Elle told Donna that he would be fine and Elle recruits Donna into the Comany.

Elle was then later sent to capture Sylar by her father. Sylar escaped from her and Bob was not happy about it. He was disappointed and wouldn't forgive Elle. After a while, Elle then realised that the Company has a whole "buffet of powers in level 5" and thinks that he will come to the Company to take this powers but Sylar was closer than she thinks, she sees her father's head opened up without the brain and quickly realises that Sylar was in the building. She quickly storms to level 5 and asks for the help of Noah Bennet. Noah Bennet helps her but Sylar was too fast. He throws Elle with his teleknesis and she was hurt quite bad. She then tries to use her ability but Sylar pinned her to the gorund with his teleknesis and he starts to cut the top of Elle's head open. Elle starts screaming and she causes a electrical out burst releasing the villains. Angela then tells Elle that she has no use in the Company anymore and Angela tells her to get a new life.

Elle is now in London and she has somehow lost control of her ability. Daphne tires to recruit Elle for the Pinehearst company in the London subways but Elle declined and thought that the thing she doesn't need in her life is another company. Elle then tries to find HRG for help about her ability and she first finds Claude Rains. She asks Claude Rains where HRG was but he wouldn't help her. Claude then runs away but Elle loses control over her ability in the rain and her ability shocks herself and Claude. Later, two people named Lee and Abigail helps Claude up and Claude tells them to help and take Elle in too. After that, Elle wakes up and talks to Claude about his father and Claude persuades Elle to forgive Bob. Later, Elle goes to the bathhouse and relaxes in the hot tub but she loses control over her ability and shocks Abigail, she gets angry and she kicks Elle, just at that moment, Lee comes in and tells Elle that she should leave... with no places to go, Elle goes to the Bennet's house to find HRG and then she shocks Lyle.
 
When Claire comes back home with her mum, the lights in the house all malfunctioned. Claire tries to find what the problem is and she finds a unconcious Lyle lying on the ground, Lyle tells her that Elle is back. Claire finds Elle and she attempts to throw her out of the house but Elle refuses. Lyle then pours a bucket of water all over her making her electricute herself.

Elle electricutes herself...

Claire helps Elle

When Hiro takes his spirit walk, he discovers that 18 months prior to the events of Heroes, Elle and HRG were assigned to study Gabriel Gray, prior to his becoming Sylar. After Elle saves him from a suicide attempt, she befriends him in order to gain his trust. Gabriel fights his hunger when he develops feelings for Elle, and Elle herself develops feelings for him in return. Unfortunately, she is forced to go along with the plan and Gabriel kills a man she set up to meet him. Gabriel gets mad at her and tells her to leave.

Back in the present, Elle was placed in a room chained to the wall, having a rather shaky reunion with Sylar. She makes constant attempts to kill him to avenger her father. She eventually loses her will to live and asks Sylar to kill her. However, having now renounced his former ways, Sylar frees her from her bondages. After the two have a heart-to-heart, Sylar forgives her for manipulating him and convinces her to forgive herself. Afterwards, her powers are no longer out of control as Sylar has absorbed her extra energy, now able to gain powers without killing.

After Elle forgives Sylar for her father's deaths, Elle shows Sylar how to properly use her powers. During then, they begin to develop feelings for each other again.