frozen's Dredd review

  • Score:
  • frozen wrote this review on .
  • 4 out of 5 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • frozen has written a total of 2 reviews. The last one was for Iron Man 3

Great way to reboot the franchise!

I'll start by saying that I've had the privilege of watching this movie early. I went in with high expectations and came out very pleased with the overall result. I'll start by saying that the film is completely different from the 1995 version, which is a good thing. If you actually liked the 1995 version (I've never came across anyone who liked it), then this isn't the movie for you. But if you're a fan of the comics or just want some good fun, this is the movie for you. I also won't reveal any spoilers in this review:

Let's start with Karl Urban's Judge Dredd, and how it compares to Stallone's:

Well, Urban really did impress me. He is what Judge Dredd is like in the comics, he just nailed the role. What impressed me more, is that he never even took his helmet off throughout the entire film so using facial expressions was impossible. His version of Dredd isn't a hero, he's an enforcer. He is the law, throughout the film he reminded me of Clint Eastwood. That's what he was aiming for, his voice wasn't as smooth as Eastwood's, it was rougher and more realistic. His Dredd was a drastic change from Stallone's, Stallone's Dredd wasn't Dredd. Stallone's Dredd was a hero, something which Dredd is not. This is a Dredd that puts justice above everything, Mega City One is filled with corruption. It's like Gotham City, but much, much worse. That's why Dredd is completely fine with killing, he has to kill. This is a Dredd that puts on his gear and he knows that he's in for a beating, but he goes out and does his job. Urban's version obviously isn't completely sane, he's a flawed human being. We never really get the answer to who is Judge Dredd, but as it's been said. Justice has no soul. Comparing Urban's look to Stallone's, Stallone's was closer to the comics but he looked like a circus act. Urban's version is a guy that puts on his gear and get's ready for a bad day, a more gritty and realistic version. This version of Dredd is extremely enjoyable, tough and has the overall package. Stallone has been put to shame.

Moving onto the plot and action:

Well, the plot revolves Dredd and a trainee's efforts to take down a gang that deals the reality-altering drug, SLO-MO. The film does use the effects of slow motion, it turns the gritty, horrible world of Mega-City One into something beautiful. You know what they say, persevering the moment. It does exactly that, it gives the audience the impression and feel of the drug. The film is only 90-95 minutes long but it's a roller-coaster ride. It's a shorter version of The Avengers, minus the characters. If you're going in to this and expecting something like The Dark Knight, don't watch this. This is just some good action-packed fun, it does what it's supposed to - reboot the franchise.

Moving onto the themes:

This film is violent. Very, very violent. Hence the 18 certificate rating, it has blood splashing everywhere, people's faces being ripped apart, etc. That's what the film get's around, that's the tone it takes. Mega-City One is a trash heap, the new world is filled with crime and violence, if you think Gotham is bad, you haven't seen the last of it. The world Dredd lives in, what he has to do deal with, it's awful. Dredd has to do what he does, that isn't hard to get at.

But this is exactly like the comic, Dredd is The Punisher with authority.

And lastly, the supporting characters:

I have to say, Olivia Thirlby and Lena Headey didn't cut it for me. I don't know why, but they were just there. Dredd made the movie, they were likable. Both of them, but I can't say much because they were under-developed. But, the sheer awesomeness of Dredd and the tone this film took, it really did nail it. So my final verdict?


6 Comments Refresh
Posted by GodOfMischief

I really enjoyed this review, one question though, if they are going with the realistic approach does that mean no Dark Judges etc?

Posted by Deranged Midget

Interesting, I was still going to see the film regardless but I'm glad there's a positive review.

Nice review mate.

Posted by Inverno

Nice review, man. I am really glad its loyal to the source material and you got to see it before everybody else.

Now I am very curious to see how violent this movie is (not a gore hound though) because most action flick these days are chopped together in order to squeeze through PG-13, or when they are R-rated they look very cheesy. Besides, I want to see what the movie snobs on Rotten Tomatoes love about it so much.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@CaioTrubat: I'd say it's about as violent as Punisher War Zone if not even more violent

Posted by Inverno

@johnkmccubbin91 said:

@CaioTrubat: I'd say it's about as violent as Punisher War Zone if not even more violent

Well that sucks because I haven't seen Punisher War Zone yet so I have no idea how. But I sure check it out.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@CaioTrubat: Basically a lot of gun fighting in it.

Other reviews for Dredd

    Dredd-fully Mindless, but Judgment is it’s Good Entertainment 0

    This movie is not going to win Oscars but it is a perfectly excellent mindless action movie that is based on the immensely popular Judge Dredd comic strip from the 2000 AD British anthology comic series. Unlike the previous 1995 film starring Sylvester Stallone, Dredd is a much more faithful adaptation to the series although they did away with some trivial cosmetics to the uniforms to make it more workable and so they didn’t stab themselves while walking.Taking place in a post-apocalyptic ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    It's time to be Judged. 0

    I had a great night at the movies. I got to see a Dredd for free thanks to a friend from college who is an assistant manager at a Regal Cinemas nearby and I got to see a great film. First before I go on to my review of the film I need to tell you two things. First I'm not as big of a hater of Stallone's Dredd as others. I believe I gave the film 2.5 stars if I remember correctly. Stallone was not good as Dredd unless you use his acting performance as comedy. Armand Assante who I think is a real...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.