zur_en_arrh's Detective Comics #3 - Cold Blood review

    Avatar image for zur_en_arrh

    Emphasis on "Detective"

    Easily the most misunderstood of the new 52's bat books, detective comics returns to the more isolated, shorter story arcs that have little to no effect on going continuity. I think the main reason this title is getting left behind critically is because people simply don't know what to do with it. A new villain, a much different take on the joker, and a loner batman, goes a long way to convince this reviewer that even if the story is supposed to take place in "present day" continuity it reads much better as a early batman story.

    That little note out of the way, there is no reason one can't enjoy this story for what it is, a noir-ish murder mystery with no messy continuity threads to worry about. For myself, on the heels of years of complex and intricate batman arcs it felt like a nice break and my oh my, its a beautiful diversion as Tony Daniel has outdone himself on the art. Expressive and colorful, the art for this book is a moody feast for the eyes and drives home a excellent mystery tale featuring one of the most creative batman villains featured in recent years.

    Issue #3 builds the story toward a climax, the true motivation of the menacing doll maker hinted at, as well as the involvement in the murderous joker. While issue #1 was setup, and #2 focused on playboy bruce, Cold Blood gives us the detective work and showdowns one always looks forward to in a good batman yarn, and few have looked better.

    I love the batman mythos, but sometimes its nice to see him work alone, not having to share the spotlight with other heroes, or play father-figure to any number of hopeful students. Tony Daniel is giving us old fashioned Batman mysteries, and so far he's done a damn fine job.

    Other reviews for Detective Comics #3 - Cold Blood

      A Tony Daniel Arc That Falls Apart Quicker Than Normal 0

      The Good: The designs for Dollmaker and his cronies is pretty awesome. There's a good sense of variety in them, in both form and function.Olivia's becoming a REALLY intriguing character.The 'shock' ending of this issue balances out a lot of elements to be the best end of the 3 issues thus far. 1 was REALLY shocking, but gets weird when you think about it. 2 was shocking, but a little flat due to the repetition; and 1 and 2 both fell flat with the lack of repercussions. 3 is shocking enough, and ...

      4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

      Newest Doll To Be 0

      In terms of what to expect out of Detective Comics, this issue basically has it all.  The torture porn themed story might not be the strongest vehicle for the first story arc out of the gates from the new 52, but there is a little bit of everything which makes a Detective Comics good in this issue.  There is a some crossing and double crossing, some action with the GCPD and perhaps most importantly some actual detecting.  With so many Batman titles on the market now it is nice to finally see one...

      5 out of 6 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.