blurred_view's Demon Knights #4 - Merlin Watches the Storm review

    Avatar image for blurred_view

    Watches the Storm, Huh? I Don't Get the Reference. Too Clever.

    The creative new origin of Shining Knight is revealed in this issue as the character sinks into a vision with Merlin, the architect of how she came to be. Demon Knights' connection to Stormwatch comes to be revealed as well.

    As big of a fan as I was of Grant Morrison's Seven Soldiers project, I have no problem at all with Paul Cornell modifying Shining Knight's origin to suit this story. Going with Morrison's wildly different and complicate take on Arthurian lore would have been a mistake in the New 52. This new origin, with Merlin and the Grail, is a much cleaner origin that readers really shouldn't have any trouble grasping. Another thing I like about it is how Cornell bypasses the matter of how living for centuries would dampen Ystin's youthfulness. The idea that she tends to sleep for long periods of time works well for that and adds another great fantasy element to her character.

    What turns out to be the connection to Stormwatch proves to be something much better than I expected it to be. As much as I enjoy Demon Knights, I really dislike Stormwatch. The idea of anything from that book invading this one really did not appeal to me. What Cornell comes up with here really seems to work, though. There are some minor nitpicks with it that I can see, but none are important or really affect this book. It will be interesting to see how well DC sticks with it too. Neither DC or Marvel really have a good track record when it comes to be consistent in portraying King Arthur's role in their histories.

    It is a good thing Cornell does such a strong job on these two parts of the issue, though. Because otherwise, this book would have some big problems brewing. The story doesn't feel like it is actually moving at all. It feels like the plot is in the same place that it was at the first of Demon Knights' first issue. How long is it going to take for this book to get out of this village?

    There is also a weird reference to Camelot falling 9,000 years ago now instead of four hundred. I am hoping this is just the result of Merlin not being a very reliable narrator when it comes to the passage of time.

    Mike Choi does a good job helping out with the art in this issue. His style doesn't clash with Diogenes Neves in any way that comes off as distracting.

    Demon Knights continues to be a great new book in DC's lineup, but it really needs to pick up the pace on its story. The new origin of Shining Knight manages to carry the book this time, but the cast is eventually going to need to start actually doing something. This will hopefully begin to happen next issue.

    Other reviews for Demon Knights #4 - Merlin Watches the Storm

      Shining Knight and the Holy Grail 0

      The Good: The cover is very nice, Mike Choi has a good simplistic approach to cvoer design that works better than Tony Daniel's increasingly crowded and complex covers. Not that Daniel's covers were bad. But there's such an effective use of empty space on the cover that makes it a powerful image. This issue shows you exactly what a good time to use two artists is. It works it in a way that although it's obvious there's two artists, not only is there a perfectly valid reason, but the styles compl...

      6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

      And now for something completely different 0

      We start where the last issue left off, with the sinister uh... guy with mustache having decapitated a little girl and using it to taunt the village the horde is about to attack. Shining Knight is pissed as all hell and looks ready to start kicking ass and chewing gum (and gum hasn't been invented yet). But just as she's about to go berserk she passes out and things get all trippy. She finds herself in this void that is described as "all of time and space" by none other than Merlin. Little trivi...

      4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.