the_mighty_monarch's Deathstroke #10 - Return to Starpoint review


Seriously, I'd like to know how Rob Liefeld keeps getting work in the industry. I'm sorry but his artwork is just god awful. Just look at the cover for me will you? Look carefully at how disjointed Deathstroke's shoulders are. Look how square that gun is. Look at the legs that make no sense. Look at how BORING THE DESIGN IS.

See, this is another problem I've recently realized with Liefeld, ESPECIALLY on Deathstroke. You know how some artists tend to be stuck in a bygone era? Dan Jurgens at times, George Perez at times, Norm Rapmund for sure on Batman Beyond;.... these are not great examples. There's some artists who were good back in the day because of the tone, but no longer really draw comics because the style is just outdated. That's Liefeld in a nutshell. I mean, certainly there's a nice wide variety of styles these days, some good some bad, but most comics I read give me some sense of an atmosphere. Liefeld's.... really doesn't. No, I take that back, when reading Deathstroke I DO get caught up in an atmosphere, and I'm not just saying "A terrible atmosphere huh huh huh," No, I'm talking an actual specific one. I feel like I'm playing a bad PC game from the 90's. The so-so games of my childhood, graphically limited, yet STILL too lazy to bother. There's an overwhelming sense that nothing is 'real,' even within its own world. Nothing is trying to create a world, it's just set pieces in a hauntingly empty desert. Many games back in the day had that feel, but plenty managed to creatively get past that, and some half-assed games even today manage to screw up that badly. But they at least have decent graphics; while Deathstroke is still 90's graphics, the first attempts at 3D not going well.

And if that wasn't bad enough, Liefeld isn't even CONSISTENT. Does he just not have an editor or something? Who the hell looks over his work and doesn't point out how many times Deathstroke's shoulder.... things.... change structure IN A SINGLE PAGE? How do you sit down to draw something and change the structure WHEN YOU HAVE A REFERENCE RIGHT THERE ON THE SAME PAGE?

And Lobo's hair is impossible and stupid looking, action sequences are dull, facial expressions are atrociously limited.... sigh.

But wait, does Liefeld write as bad as he draws!? Yes. The depressing answer is yes. Lobo now bears a weird resemblance to Wolverine. He's got the angry snarky attitude without a trace of the fun over-the-top-bastard that Lobo is. His facial features even bear a fleeting resemblance. Where he separates from Wolverine, and separates further from Lobo, is his sudden desire to destroy and then rule Planet Earth. Nowhere do I see the intergalactic money-loving fast-and-loose 'main man.' Instead I see..... Mongul, just about. So Lobo is Wolverine and Mongul rolled into one. Terrific.

And Deathstroke.... "I normally outthink most of my opponents, using their weakness against them. In Karlak's case, I have little to go on. He's all rage and fury. Sometimes my only alternative is to battle brute strength with brute strength." REALLY LIEFELD? REALLY? You point out that Deathstroke is a tactician, only to have him outright ignore that because 'he's got nothing to go on' because his opponent is 'all rage and fury?' NO. NO WAY IN GODDAMN HELL LIEFELD. Opponents full of rage and fury have PLENTY of weaknesses to rely on to use to outsmart them, that's why there's that term known as 'BLIND RAGE.' This dude's barely LISTENING to you, there's SO MANY THINGS you can do to use that rage against him. But no, we have to have a brute strength fight. BRILLIANT. NO REALLY. And the whole ensuing fight is a mishmash of jumbled nonsense, where various characters jump in and out for various reasons and in the end I barely understand anything about the flow of the fight. And why is Deathstroke DEALING with these impulsive kids? Last arc he straight up murdered a bunch as soon as he could because he was insulting by having to work with them.

In Conclusion: 1/5


Posted by Bloodwolfassassin

I've said this before about this title on other people's reviews, but it bears repeating. Here is my theory about how .... this happened.

Once upon a time there was a young up and coming comic book artist named Rob Liefeld. Rob's Dream was to be the writer and Artist for his favorite DC comics character, Deathstroke. However, for some reason, in all likelihood a very good one, DC executives thought that this was a very bad idea. Later, Rob, still harboring a grudge, created Deadpool as either a parody of Deathstroke or possibly a serious manifestation of how Rob Liefeld perceived Deathstroke. In any case, Deadpool, thanks in no small part to the skillful writing of Fabian Nicieza, eventually evolved past his unfortunate Liefeldian origins and became a likable and endearing character. However, at the time, DC was none too pleased with the competition creating a character that depicted one of their most serious characters as a joke. Not one to be outdone by their rival company, DC struck back at Marvel with the creation of Lobo, who at the time was meant to be a parody of one of Marvel's flagship characters, Wolverine. Fortunately, like Deadpool, Lobo eventually evolved into a more well rounded and enjoyable character. However, Rob, probably having learned of the impetus for Lobo's conception likely grew to hate the character as it's very creation was meant as a personal insult to him, or at least that's how he saw it. Rob's first attempt to destroy Lobo, the same damn thing he tried with Deathstroke, the creation of a character called Bloodwulf. Fortunately, this failed miserably. Partially because Rob didn't really get that Lobo was already meant to be a parody, and parody cannot itself be parodied, lest one create a parodyox (Trade Mark Bloodwolf, which incidentally is a name I've been using since before I knew that the Liefeld character existed), Partially because the character was so terrible that he simply could not be marketed, but mostly because the character brought to light the fact that, along with not being able to write or draw, Rob cannot spell. Finally, years later, Rob somehow still had enough clout to keep getting work in the comic book industry, and when DC decided to reboot all of its titles, Rob was finally offered a job. When the original run on the rebooted Deathstroke was not doing well, DC decided that they needed a new creative team. Even though it was against their better Judgement, DC decided to give Rob a call. After untying Kyle Higgins and Joe Bennett and threatening them both at gunpoint that their dead if they go to the cops (knowing Rob it was a very large and impractical Gun with several Pouches and exactly one shoulder pad), Rob accepted the assignment. Now that Rob finally has his dream Job, first order of business, Lobo must die, and who better to take him out than Rob's favorite character, Deathstroke. The problem here is that Rob does not comprehend how these characters are supposed to be written, not helped by the fact that his mind never really left the 90's. What will result from this will be a clusterf*ck that will make The Clone Saga look like Watchmen by Comparison. In the end, both of these beloved characters shall meet their untimely destruction in a massive explosion of sketchy, inconsistent artwork, horrid dialogue, musculature that cannot exist in nature, impractical weapons, unnecessary pouches and exactly one shoulder pad.

Posted by Mediumflyer7

I know right? In the first few pages look at Zealot. Cape. No cape. Cape. No cape. Cape (and so on)

Other reviews for Deathstroke #10 - Return to Starpoint

    The Main Man's Back, bless the 90s 0

    I don't care what other people sayI'm just overfilled with joy to see the Main Man making his debut in the New 52.And who should be more appropriate to re-introduce THE ultimate 90s anti-hero, than the man who has coined and championed the concept itself back in it's glory days, Rob Liefeld himself. Not to mention guest-starring another 90s icon, Zealot.In this issue we finally get to see more of the Last Czarnian. He may not be as funny as we remember him, but it's still him. Destroying an enti...

    0 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.