@papinacho: Yeah, I was actually thinking about that. You don't want to design the group to go too far, as Namor found out when he made his Cabal. They were pretty much psychopaths and went the opposite direction, only exploring the moral less/easy routes (even going overboard such as chastising an alternate Xavier for causing his "children" to die). In a way, you need to balance out the group, choosing those who will consider all options, while still maintaining a sense of morality.

@tearofthedragon: Vandal Savage is actually the creator of the Illuminati, was the first thing I thought when I saw this thread and am suprised you are the only one to bring him up.

@raktus: Me too. I can't think of anyone better with his personality and vast experience.

I know you said no JL members but whatever.

1: Batman - money intelligence and a natural born leader (not saying he's gonna lead the group but can if needed)

2: Constantine/Dr. Fate - for the magical side

3: Mr. Terrific - genious level intellect

4: Mr. Miracle - due to his connection to the new gods

5: Black Adam - he will do what is necessary to protect his people

6: Martian MH - he's a powerhouse and can also be the voice of reason for the group

7: John Stewart - due to his background as a marine and having connections to the GL Corps

8: Booster Gold - due to his time travel abilities

Also I think it would be really cool if they had these secret meetings at the Tower Of Fate.