silkcuts's DC Comics Presents - Batman: Dark City, Dark Knight #1 - Dark Knight, Dark City review

  • Score:
  • silkcuts wrote this review on .
  • 7 out of 7 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • silkcuts has written a total of 726 reviews. The last one was for

"The Hangman" in the Dark Knight in this Dark City

Finally Peter Milligan's Batman stories get some love.  Both wonderfully selected stories to be collected in this "100-page spectacular".  This reprint collection makes a nice mature pick-up read for those who like the darker and more adult Batman stories, while I must stress this is recommended reading material to understand Grant Morrison's Batman run, since both men are friends and it is likely Morrison read these stories when researching, you can see some of the influence of Milligan's run on Morrison's run.

Dark Knight, Dark City 1| 2| 3|
This three issue arc is Peter Milligan's best Batman story.  It is dark, it is scary, it is a mature take on Batman in a smart way.  Peter Milligan has done his research into the Occult and introduces aspects of the Occult into Batman.  This concepts would later be adapted again by Grant Morrison in his current run on Batman.  The three issues alone are worth the admission price and then there is a bonus story in Identity Crisis.  If you pay attention in the first chapter of Dark Knight, Dark City you can see John Constantine on page 8, the 7th panel, we see the Batmobile race around the corner and the Green Suited (Crisis on Infinite Earths) John is hit with a rush of air, 

Identity Crisis:
The idea of Bruce Wayne battling his duel identity is not a new idea, In Batman #112 "Am I Really Batman?" Bruce Wayne goes face to face with himself.  Peter Milligan being obsessed (in a good way) with the idea of dueling identities goes for his take on a similar idea.

When I first read this years ago the take seemed so fresh.   I've recently read Batman #112, then reread this comic and the first half was not as mind blowing as I remembered.  The end was as good as I remembered and it was a treat to see how talented Peter Milligan was back in 1991.

The Search of Swamp Thing Preview:
There is a four page preview of The Search of Swamp Thing in this reprint.  I personally was not amused, I would think that Jonathan Vankin (Who was once an editor for Vertigo) would know John Constantine better.  I felt the dialogue was weak, making Brain Azzarello still the best American writer for John.  The story does focus on Swamp Thing, but its weird having "Classic" John as the lead, when classic John was the "in the shadows manipulator".  Another problem I had with this preview is that the wasted space could of been all the covers of the Batman book, meaning twp of the Mike Mignola covers are lost to history.

Overall
I was looking forward to this collection, even if I had these comics in singles.  By having it reprinted I now have a loner copy in this one and it also means other people can now see how good Peter Milligan is even from work from so long ago.

Cheers
- Silkcuts

4 Comments
Posted by Dark Noldor

I like Millilgan a lot, he´s a hell of a creative writer, unfortunally Dwyer´s style doesn´t rub me in a good way so I pass this presents - I´ve never heard of this Vankin dude, so I definitely will pass the sequel of BD and wait till it´s published here in Brazil.
Peace

Posted by Silkcuts
@Dark Noldor: You mentioned you didn't like Dywer and not a big fan or Morrison's Batman, so it is safe you stayed away from this reprint.  Identity crisis was Tom Mandrake, but that doesn't matter since it is only one issue of the reprint.

The Vankin preview is nothing special.

Man Brazil is stacked with talent.
Posted by Liberty

I love the shout out to John C. btw I can't see your wall paper and I want to read it.  =]

Posted by Silkcuts
@Liberty:

Other reviews for DC Comics Presents - Batman: Dark City, Dark Knight #1 - Dark Knight, Dark City

    The Strangest Riddler Story 0

    Anyone who can see my profile picture knows I am a fan of the Riddler. I love his crimes, his technique, and his very Only the first of many... character. When I bought the individual issues that are contained in this volume set, I thought: "cool, a three parter staring batman and the Riddler! what more could you ask for?" Well, for starters the Riddler. needless to say this was not what I expected it to be like.The Riddler is so out of character in these issues! its annoying. I have no idea w...

    4 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.