Dark Avengers # 8 - Utopia, Chapter 5

is a comic book published by Marvel Publishing & released on 10 / / 2009

User Rating - 20 votes, 4.2 avg.

Plot Summary

Norman's X-Men, as led by Emma and Namor, are the face of mutant law and order! The X-Men look played out of position as Osborn's dark reign falls over California-- but Scott Summers isn't done yet. The X-Men strike at Norman, at H.A.M.M.E.R., at his fraud X-Men and his sham Avengers all at once! This is the book where, at long last, the Marvel Universe starts to fight back-- and it sets the stage for next month’s unbelievable conclusion in UNCANNY X-MEN/DARK AVENGERS - EXODUS

Creators

Add a creator credit to this issue
  •  
    Alan Fine
    production

  • Cory Petit
    letterer


  • Dean White
    colorer

  • Luke Ross
    penciler, inker


  •  

  • Matt Fraction
    writer


  •  
    Rick Magyar
    inker


  • Tom Brevoort
    editor


  • Characters


    Teams

    Add a team credit to this issue

    Locations

    Add a location credit to this issue

    Concepts

    Add a concept credit to this issue
    We don't have any concepts attached to this issue. Help us fill it in!

    Objects

    Add an object credit to this issue
    We don't have any objects attached to this issue. Help us fill it in!

    Story Arc

    Add a story arc credit to this issue

    User Reviews
    Best issue by far!
    Reviewed by hero vs. villian on Sept. 22, 2009.
    hero vs. villian has written 3 reviews. His/her last review was for .
    2 out of 3 users recommend his reviews.

    1 out of 1 user found this review helpful.

    Well since I do not enjoy any Dark Avengers book mainly cause Bendis has done what I hope he could have done on it, Matt Fraction who is an amazing writer has pulled it off for me, an issue of Dark Avengers that I can say I love! The dialouge (after the Dark X-Men are fighting the old looking Sentinels) is really good. Fraction writes Osborn perfectly, and pulls off the fact that Dark Reign in the Marvel U is coming to an end. Luke Ross' pencils are terrific. 
    I love how he also writes Osborn weaking down. For those of you who read Invincible Iron Man, you know what I mean, how Osborn is showing that he cannot hold the power that has been given to him since S#@%$ Invasion, oh I'm sorry I meant Secret Invasion. Anywasy X-Men fans worth your money, Dark Avengers fans worth your money, especially since Emma Frost and Namor show who's side they are really on!



    Cyclops; mutant Messiah!
    Reviewed by MatthewHex on Sept. 8, 2009.
    MatthewHex has written 61 reviews. His/her last review was for Part 1 of 6.
    5 out of 6 users recommend his reviews.

    Cyclops as the new mutant Messiah! A bit hypocritical really, as at the end of this issue the X-Men raise their ‘Utopia’ island from the sea and declare they want mutants to be separate from humans on the main land, but isn’t that what Magneto did with Asteroid M and what the X-Men are meant to fight against? Anyway, I loved this issue, the best of the cross over so far. Emma and Namor show their true colors to Osborn, which will lead into the big fight finale one-shot between the Dark Avengers and X-Men. It was played well, and rocked. Fraction did a really good job on this issue. All I want to know is what happened to Beast? He sort of disappeared in the middle of the issue, I hope we find out in the next chapter, he looked so sad with   his little cat eyes.       

     
    Like my review? (Or even if you don’t!) Then please check out my blogs at: http://hexsfifthcolumn.blogspot.com/ & http://acomicbookblog.com/category/comic-book-blog/marvel-blog/    


     



    Wandering to an Ending
    Reviewed by themaskedhero on Sept. 5, 2009.
    themaskedhero has written 84 reviews. His/her last review was for Heart of Darkness.
    2 out of 2 users recommend his reviews.

    I'll be honest, I read this the day it came out and was at a complete loss as to what to say about it or even what happened in the issue. Luke Ross is back & I feel like instead of giving us a copycat artist they could have given us someone who could make this book easy to follow. And while I feel that this story is leaps and bounds ahead of "Messiah War," I'm beginning to question where this is all supposed to go. I realize we've changed how mutants live, but why step into the Dark Avengers? I guess all that has described how I feel about the writing, which Fraction could have done better.

    We open in Las Vegas catching up with Danni Moonstar & Hela from the last issue as Danni is asking for a bit of help in regards to SOMETHING that must have gone over my head, but I can only hope it plays off in New Mutants, which I picked up all of the current run in one swoop & loved.

    We move to the Dark X-Men capturing a verse-spouting Trask and continue into a sequence displaying all the different ways these X-Men are doing everything right over the course of a week, which makes me feel more satisfied because it shows that the event as a whole happened over an extended amount of time, unlike Secret Invasion which happen in a span of time one might eat lunch in. Cyclops and his X-Men watch from the couch as everything unfolds, which I found rather boring.

    Moving back to the Hammer bas, we begin to see cracks in the Dark X-Men's armor as they witness the effects the Omega Machine has on the captured mutants and we get a real idea of who has moral compasses. It was right around here I began to question Marvel's choice of artists in Luke Ross, because this stuff looks really off from anything I'm used to, like Emma in her diamond form, yuck! We get some Dark Avengers, I know what you're thinking, "In the book named after them? No way!" And then we transition to the Science Team! Okay, maybe my X-Men lore is off or something because the Science Team was acting like we should know what the hell their doing & I keep staring at pages wonder what the big deal was.

    Beast gets depowered-ish. X-Force shows up & looks like crap (could Choi have just done the panels they were in or something?). Omega powers up. The Dark X-Men go to fight X-Force. Pixie does some teleporting of people "home". There, you don't need to read about 4 pages.

    We get a big reveal that mutant kind has moved out to their own private island, which the Science Team lifted off the ocean floor, entitled 'Utopia' and Osborn calls the Dark Avengers to do his dirty work, end book.

    Now I realize my last few paragraphs are kind of vague & that important pieces of plot and dialogue were skimmed over, but this is not to blame the writing on this one, the art is really a joke here, no lie. I can't get through this book, I have trouble understanding what is going on in panels and it's not like the art is messy or anything, it's just not using the panels to their full effect. This crossover is not a let down, it's going places, but even with the same writer across the board (which might have saved Messiah War if Yost had writing duties on both books), Utopia seems to be going in different directions in different books and I question if the Dark Avengers series even needed to play in this sandbox. Marvel, just pull an "Amazing Spider-Man" & put out Uncanny twice a month for the event!


    Don't buy this if you don't want to apart of the entire Utopia event.




    See all issues Next Issue » « Previous Issue
    Url:
    HTML:
    BBCode:
    Added by: Providence
    Date Added: Aug. 26, 2009
    Url:
    HTML:
    BBCode:
    Added by: James Proudstar
    Date Added: Sept. 2, 2009
    Url:
    HTML:
    BBCode:
    Added by: James Proudstar
    Date Added: Sept. 2, 2009


    Providence
    123 points

    soba
    5 points

    Darksbane
    3 points

    byzantine
    3 points

    James Proudstar
    2 points


    You are in Edit Mode. Make sure to save your work at the end!!
    • Submissions can take 24 hours to be moderated.
    • Please leave a comment to explain why you're making this change.
    Save Changes Cancel