Catwoman: Guardian of Gotham #1
Catwoman: Guardian of Gotham » Catwoman: Guardian of Gotham #1 - Part 1: Guardian of Gotham released by DC Comics on October 1999.
Short summary describing this issue.
-
5 (0) 4 (0) 3 (0) 2 (2) 1 (0) 1.8 starsAverage score of 3 user reviews
-
What on alternate Earth IS this? 1
I'll tell you what it is; a jumbled mess of a comic, with utterly horrendous "plot" and art that, whilst competent, is often distracting in its overwhelming desire to titillate for no readily apparent reason. Doug Moench makes many mistakes here, that unfortunately he would repeat in his other Elseworlds stinker " Act Of God" - bad characterisation, cheesy dialogue, horrendous pacing and plot holes you could navigate the Batmobile, Batboat and Batplane through. I have no prob...
3 out of 3 found this review helpful. -
Not to be taken seriously 1
Catwoman: Guardian of Selina Kyle is a millionaire playgirl who resides in Kyle Manner. She secretly fights crime in as the Catwoman being driven to take revenge on the criminal element after witnessing the death of her parents as a small girl. The Batman is a mysterious new comer who goes on a murderous crime spree as no one in has ever seen. The book is visually stunning and the colors are rich. The story is purposely over the top as is most Elseworlds Comics. If you ...
2 out of 2 found this review helpful. -
Confused? 0
Yeah, I know, watching Catwoman protecting the streets of Gotham as the big honcho is rather strange, but as SandGnat-Man said before me, it is not a comic to be taken seriously. It didn't make much sense at all, which was the point, I'suppose. But the way they made Batman was outrageous, all too smiley and lunatic. If he is suppose to be Selina in this alternate Earth, then why isn't he anything like her? If you don't question any of this, the book is alright. I kinda like Catwoman being all he...
1 out of 2 found this review helpful.
Log in to comment