Jean Claude Van Damme

John Cena

Chris Evans

Dolph Lundgren

Brad Pitt

No, No, Yes, No, Maybe.

JCVD is French-Belgian. Automatic disqualifier.

John Cena is a WWE quality actor. 'Nuff said.

Dolph Lundgren: also not American, too old, and heavy accented.

Being muscular doesn't instantly make someone a fit if they're a weak actor... You do realize that the movie has already been made? Chris Evans did fine.

@KnightRise said:

JCVD is French-Belgian. Automatic disqualifier.

John Cena is a WWE quality actor. 'Nuff said.

Dolph Lundgren: also not American, too old, and heavy accented.

Being muscular doesn't instantly make someone a fit if they're a weak actor... You do realize that the movie has already been made? Chris Evans did fine.

@Gambit1024 said:

No, No, Yes, No, Maybe.

Pretty much.

@KnightRise said:

JCVD is French-Belgian. Automatic disqualifier.

John Cena is a WWE quality actor. 'Nuff said.

Dolph Lundgren: also not American, too old, and heavy accented.

Being muscular doesn't instantly make someone a fit if they're a weak actor... You do realize that the movie has already been made? Chris Evans did fine.

Van Damme is a martial artist and great fighter, and would have made ​​a better performance that Evans

@Wonder_Captain said:

@KnightRise said:

JCVD is French-Belgian. Automatic disqualifier.

John Cena is a WWE quality actor. 'Nuff said.

Dolph Lundgren: also not American, too old, and heavy accented.

Being muscular doesn't instantly make someone a fit if they're a weak actor... You do realize that the movie has already been made? Chris Evans did fine.

Van Damme is a martial artist and would have made ​​a better performance that Evans.

Because a 1940s Brooklyn kid with a few weeks of military service would be well-versed in east Asian martial arts and bicep flexing......Sure, the fight scenes would've been pretty, the rest of the film would've tanked. JCVD is old as dirt, too.

Chris Evans is perfectly fine. The only other actor in that list that could probably pull Cap off is Brad Pitt.

Out of the five, only two are actors, and of those two, one already is Captain America, and he did an outstanding job.

Seriously though, if Van Damme where younger (mid 20s -mid 30s) he could be a good Gambit.

@KnightRise said:

@Wonder_Captain said:

@KnightRise said:

JCVD is French-Belgian. Automatic disqualifier.

John Cena is a WWE quality actor. 'Nuff said.

Dolph Lundgren: also not American, too old, and heavy accented.

Being muscular doesn't instantly make someone a fit if they're a weak actor... You do realize that the movie has already been made? Chris Evans did fine.

Van Damme is a martial artist and would have made ​​a better performance that Evans.

Because a 1940s Brooklyn kid with a few weeks of military service would be well-versed in east Asian martial arts and bicep flexing......Sure, the fight scenes would've been pretty, the rest of the film would've tanked. JCVD is old as dirt, too.

This

@tg1982 said:

Out of the five, only two are actors, and of those two, one already is Captain America, and he did an outstanding job.

Seriously though, if Van Damme where younger (mid 20s -mid 30s) he could be a good Gambit.

I can actually picture this.

Chris Evans was okay but not great, but I don't think anyone else in the list would be any better. Plus as for a foreigner playing Cap, who cares. As long as they can hide their accent and captures the character then I will support it.

I think you just picked those guys for their looks and not there acting ability.

@tg1982 said:

Out of the five, only two are actors, and of those two, one already is Captain America, and he did an outstanding job.

Seriously though, if Van Damme where younger (mid 20s -mid 30s) he could be a good Gambit.

Gambit ???

The fight between Red Skull vs Cap-Van Damme would have been interesting,

showing a variety of techniques and spectacular kicks

...

Chris Evans IS Captain America