personally i think he looks good for cap, much better then  Channing Tatum by a long shoot.

Both lame choices. 

who @CosmicSpiral:  what actor  do you think  would suit cap best.

I'm very concerned

Yes. I'm pretty scared at the moment. But hopefully he will prove us all wrong and end up doing an amazing job.

I'm skepical about it too, but if he can do serious roles like The street kings, and the losers (whch is coming soon) I think he can full it off with the right execution. Besides, he's in his last 20's and he's played a superhero character from the same company. Better than some douche bag right.

He doesn't look the part.

I think he'll do fine, he wouldn't have been my first pick, but I don't have to make those decisions. After all he gets consistent work as an actor and when was the last time a horrible actor kept getting work.. that wasn't a smoking hot woman?
 
FYI: and I am not talking about movies that go straight to DVD.

he'll be fine. with more training, he'll be able to do all the action that captain america can. if not, then at least a stunt double will help