If this is Marvel's choice then I'll trust them. After nailing Iron Man and Hulk, I don't think they'd mess up Captain America.

Meh

this is a rumor and he is not captain america. as a captain america fan i can say this is a horrible pick.
GO BACK TO TRYING TO GET A PUSH SEQUEL CHRIS.

Kinda seems like a jester, bafoon in all his movies not my first choice but not a horrible choice, Hope he can pull it off IF he gets the part..... Kinda was hoping for that UNKNOWN actor they were once talking about!

Interesting...

I still cannot get off Chris Pine playing Captain America, but this it to me the best guy to play Captain America out of the three choices. Lets get this movie going.

he has a hot package, but i dunno if he can fill Cap's jockies ;P

He was probably the best things to come out of the FF films but im not sure if thats something to be happy about.

it's better than Jim Halpert

LAME

Chris Evans in spandex again makes me a very very happy girl. xD

My Money's on Channing Tatum

Thank God! He's definitely the best of the three.

He isn't the perfect choice, 
but I also think he is a much better choice than the rest of his competitors.

"

If this is Marvel's choice then I'll trust them. After nailing Iron Man and Hulk, I don't think they'd mess up Captain America.

"

I think I just threw up in my mouth a little.

If the filmmakers of Captain America ask you to portray the titular character, all you say is yes.

Chris Evans won't turn down work.

He looks the part

Will it be better than push? I friggin' hope so.

if Evans gets the ROle it would be SOOO Whack... not the Movie... but it would still be whack
 
i was ok with Ryan being DP... even tho he was Hannibal King... cuz.. i mean its Hannibal King...
but when he accepted the role as GL i was annoyed now Chris Evans will be Cap/Loser/and Torch.... WHACK...
and u kno what
Robert Downey JR should Play as ANT-MAN...
and Ryan Reynolds should play Flash... and His Sidekick Kid Flash should be Chris Evans
and Wesley SNipes should be Black Panther...
Christian Bale should be the next Superman
then Ryan Reynolds should be HAwkeye  
Brandon Routh should be Visions
Scarlet Witch should be Scarlett Johansson 
and Tobey McGuire should be Quicksilver

Not bad, not outstanding. Was hoping they would go for a complete unknown or someone younger but I just want them to make this movie already. Evans always has a certain "cocky attitude" in almost all the movies I have seen him in.

I'm still voting for Ian Somerhalder.

no, not Chris 
 
not him, but just pick someone already

Man, I hate Channing Tatum.

I just hate how they offer all comic book roles to a small select group of actors.  If they ever wanted to do a Cap America/ Fantastic Four crossover movie or any movie in which the characters would come across one another, what then?  I mean casting Ryan Reynolds as Deadpool AND Green Lantern is one thing (considering they're from two separate universes) but one actor playing two Marvel roles at the same time doesn't sit well w/ me for some reason.

Is it that hard to find talented actors ?

GODD***IT!!!
 
Why does all the news about this film have to suck?

to young looking and sounding

i think Chris Pine is a better fit 

They didn't even pick him yet. he was only offered the role.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  
 guess im not gunna b enjoying this flick in the theatre...  CHRIS EVANS as CAP???  are u kidding me???

Evans was also in Push.

I could get into it. He did play a pretty serious role in Cellular.

If it's him or Channing Tatum...I'll die a little inside 

" Man, I hate Channing Tatum. "

He could be really good as Cap, and after seeing him in Sunshine as the guy who got things done and made the decisions others didn't want to make... I have faith in his ability. He's a much better choice than the other two. Haha.

I prefer him as Bucky myself.