thalastdragon's Captain America #611 - The Trial of Captain America, Part One review

Your past can catch up with you


Publisher:   Marvel Comics 
Writer:   Ed Brubaker 
Artist:   Daniel Acuña 
Letterer:   Joe Caramagn 
Cover Artist:   Marko Djurdjevic 
Cover Price:   $3.99 
Release Date:   10-27-10

Captain #611 begins the “Trial of Captain America Part 1.”   During the previous arc “No Escape,” the current shield wielder’s past as former Soviet assassin, Winter Soldier, was released to the media by Baron Zemo.

The majority of this issue consists of the dialogue detailing Bucky’s past.  One set involves Steve Rogers, Tony Stark, Black Widow, Hawkeye, and Mockingbird.   The other involves Steve Rogers and the President of the .   Brubaker intertwines both of these very well.   While Steve is giving the President details on Bucky’s crimes, we also see a few panels showing some of his crimes.   The Avengers conversation is focused around Hawkeye’s anger at this situation because he felt that he should’ve known and that they should’ve been prepared for this.   Black Widow presents a very good point when she asks a couple of questions involving second chances and redemption.   In doing this, she acknowledges that everyone in that room has made errors in their pasts but they have moved beyond them.  

This issue isn’t all talk, however.   There is a nice brief action sequence with Captain breaking up a Neo-Nazi skinhead rally in a warehouse.   Brubaker presents some good internal monologue with Cap knowing that regardless of what is happening, he still has a job to do.

Acuña’s work throughout the issue is good, but it’s the facial expressions, body language, and the mood of the characters that truly stand out.   An example is how he captures Hawkeyes frustration in coming to terms with what’s happened during his talk with the Avengers and also his earlier confrontation with the media.

The titling of this arc and its cover don’t leave much to the imagination, because you can predict what’s going to happen.   But it’s the execution that matters and it definitely does its job as the opening part of what could be a really great story that could actually mean something for the characters.   I am eagerly awaiting the next chapter and recommend it to others.

Rating:   4 out of 5 stars    

0 Comments

Other reviews for Captain America #611 - The Trial of Captain America, Part One

    Moralities 0

    Bucky Barnes now is cornered by the media and the US Government after that Zemo revealed that he was the Winter Soldier. The greatest thing about Brubaker´s narrative isn´t the amazing dialogues, neither the harmonizing captions of Bucky´s thoughts, but the true power behind this epic tale lies in the fact that Brubaker combines the real social factors of power with the political forces that thrives and driven our society: the way he combines the media, the government and the Avengers into the s...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Trial of Cap... part 1 0

    First off, I didn't really like the transition to the new artist in this issue.  I felt the art left a lot to be desired and really drew away from my good experience with this issue.  The characters seem featureless, the attention to detail is not there, there seldom seemed to be any background in the panels... I'm just disappointed. Okay, that being said... I like this first part of the story.  The way Hawkeye reacts when he hears the news about Bucky and how he confronts the others, classic go...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.