silkcuts's Batwoman #0 - Beyond A Shadow review

    Avatar image for silkcuts
    • Score:
    • silkcuts wrote this review on .
    • 12 out of 12 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • silkcuts has written a total of 726 reviews. The last one was for
    • This review received 7 comments

    The Magic of Batwoman is back.

    For those who are familiar with my reviews, I praised the arcs in Detective Comics featuring Batwoman.  The major chunk of her story that was written by Greg Rucka was collected in Batwoman: Elegy.  My review for that Deluxe Hardcover can be found Here.

     Page 1
     Page 1
    The Premise: This comic is that hiatus area, in which Batwoman looked like Greg Rucka was going to take her to new heights with Alice.  Greg Rucka would end up leaving DC Comics when Batwoman lost her ongoing tale in Detective Comics.  While Batwoman was in Limbo again, J.H. Williams III, who was the main artist on Batwoman, decided to carry one but making sure to respect Rucka's plot points and notes.
     Page 2-3 title.  The Top half art by Williams, the bottom half Reeder Hadly.
     Page 2-3 title.  The Top half art by Williams, the bottom half Reeder Hadly.
    The Team and why they will work well: Along for the ride are three new members to the creative team co-scribe W. Haden Blackman (Starwars) and the Madame Xanadau artist team of Amy Reeder Hadley (Penciler) and Richard Friend (Inker).  The Colorer Dave Stewart returns which is nice, since he makes the art pop and Letterer Todd Klein as well, who may just be the world's best letter. This comic visually is great with the dual styles weaving between each other.  J.H. Williams constructs the actual Batwoman scenes which are fluid, while Amy Reeder pencils out the Kate Kane pages.  This gives the book a night and day effect that works.  During the day, Kate looks like a normal woman and Batman is determined to prove she is Batwoman.  At Night, Batwoman is tested. Tested by The Religion of Crime and by Batman to see if she is Kate. 
     Standard layout for J.H. Williams from his work on Batwoman
     Standard layout for J.H. Williams from his work on Batwoman
    Basic concepts will be carried on in the upcoming Batwoman ongoing series, which is set for February. Such concepts are Batwoman verses the Religion of Crime.  This personal war she has on the Religion of Crime really builds up from the events in 52, The Question: The Five Books of Blood and Batwoman: Elegy.   
     
    Day and Night
    Day and Night
    Batwoman is evolving so quickly since her return to the DCU in 52.  Greg Rucka has done well to establish her as her own hero, in her own right.  Without Rucka, Williams has taken responsibility to make sure Kate grows and prosper.  This is part of the reason in which I am happy that Batwoman did not fall into limbo. Her character is a fresh take on the fight against crime.  With Batman Inc. now launched It is obvious that Bruce is recruiting and Batwoman's future has to be addressed since us fans will ask and want to know.  I am glad this book does not carry the Batman Inc stamp.  It seems that the Batman mythos now is pulled in three directions, (1) the primary direction in which is Grant Morrison's, (2) the more reader friendly Paul Dini direction and now (3) Batwoman.  It is very likely that Rucka left DC Comics because Batwoman was miss handled.  Her plans were likely minimal when DC Comics decided to take Detective away from Rucka, to focus on another set of Batman stories in an over saturated market of Batman stories.  That would enrage me to leave DC Comics as well, especially since the fan reaction for Batwoman was so strong.  With Williams and Blackman co-writing there is better chances they were more willing to work within the Batman mandates.  This comics is truly fit for the number zero, because it is not quite Rucka's Batwoman and it gives this new creative team enough set up for any new people to jump in come no or February.
     
    The Issue itself is only 16 pages of story and 4 preview pages, which is 20 pages of content for $3.  DC Comics is going in a 20 page content format, so this is what we should be expecting from the future. I loved the original run on Detective Comics and loved this issue.  I was very happy with the investment.

    Cheers
     - Silkcuts

    Other reviews for Batwoman #0 - Beyond A Shadow

      Just plain BEAUTIFUL 0

      After reading Batman & Robin #17 this week, I was left with a bad taste in my mouth with the Batman family. I am glad to say that this particular issue was so much better. JH WIlliams is pulling double duty with art and writing. While he does have to split hiw workload, this issue does not disappoint in any way. I love what Rucka laid down for Kate Kane in Elegy, but what took the cake was the artwork and the layout of each and every page. It's no different here. Pencils combine with ink and...

      12 out of 12 found this review helpful.

      If you never heard of Batwoman pick this up 0

      Cover The cover is great art and it is just Batwoman Classic. Story Batman tracks Batwoman to see if she is a good hero. Batman thinks that Batwoman is Kate Kane. He spies on both of them. Kate visits a grave probably of a loved one. Kate is on the outs with her father but her father is trying to make their relationship better. Batman sees how she fights and she is doing everything right. Batman thinks she is a good hero but, wants to have a discussion about her future. Best Part The best part ...

      11 out of 11 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.