The reason you're hearing mixed reviews about Dark Knight is because of the change in the creative team. At the beginning, it sucked... it was easily the worst bat-book around. But then, I believe around Issue 10, Greg Hurwitz took over, and suddenly the series became great. Hurwitz turned the book on its head, turning into, arguably, the darkest of all the bat-books and adding a real creep factor to the atmosphere.
Batman and Robin started strong... the first arc was great, but then the whole "Terminus/War of the Robins" arc was a letdown. If things don't pick up again in the next issue, I'm dropping the series.
Nightwing is great, definitely the best bat-book to not feature Batman (regularly). Batwoman was amazing when it started, but since then has really lost steam. Batgirl... I personally like it, but I don't like that they un-crippled Barbara Gordon, it just seems like taking a step backwards in character development. Batwing is very good for the most part, though a couple issues fall flat, but the great ones make up for it.
Oh, and Batman Incorporated... personally, I don't like it at all, but I know a lot of people who do. Its certainly different from the rest, its just a bit too cheesy for my tastes.
Log in to comment