Batman: Holy Terror review

Posted by Mistermorriss (32 posts) - - Show Bio

I was very excited to have picked this up on the great comicbook retail internet giant known as Ebay. Where would we collectors be without it, eh? Anyway, for those of you don't know, Batman: Holy Terror is the first DC one-shot with the Elseworlds logo on the cover. And for those of you unfamiliar with Elseworlds, just think Superheroes in alternate settings, universes, garb etc.

Batman: Holy Terror takes place in some Cromwellian dystopia where the Machiavellian elite rule with an iron fist. Bruce Wayne is a priest who is told by Gordon, who himself is an Inquisitor, (nobody, Spanish Inquisition, you know the drill) tells Bruce that the powers-that-be ordered the execution of his parents due to them helping vagrants and miscreants on the sly. Not good.

Bruce is soon upset enough to be Batman and starts an investigation into who precisely is responsible for his parents’ downfall. However, and here’s the however, on his travels he uncovers some kind of underground prison laboratory housing a couple of familiar names and faces that I won’t spoil here. In his attempts to free the inmates Batman comes across the man responsible for everything and to be honest, it is here where the story goes somewhat awry.

The initial premise into uncovered the presumably multi-layered political minefield that enveloped Gotham in this fantastically detailed universe was the beginning of, not only an interesting take on the city itself, but the makings of a damn good detective story. The decision to go all biologically fantastical on us and thus remove the reader from this vividly-imagined, distant-yet-highly-believable other world was, in my opinion, a mistake.

Although I’ve praised it indirectly, hats must go off to Alan Brennert for the historical imaginings, and my undying resect and gratitude goes to my favourite Batman artist of all time, Norm Breyfogle. The movement he conveys in fight scenes have always been unparalleled, and his use of black is menacing and simply down right cool.

For collectors it’s a must have (but then again isn’t everything?) and for the casual reader it’s worth picking up.

2.5/5

#1 Posted by Imagine_Man15 (1801 posts) - - Show Bio

Nice review. I've always meant to read Holy Terror, but never actually got around to doing it. From what I've heard, I've always gotten the impression that I would love the setting, but the story itself might be a bit lackluster. Your review pretty much confirms this, but has gotten me intrigued enough by the setting alone to pick it up.

#2 Posted by Mistermorriss (32 posts) - - Show Bio

Thanks for the comment. It's definitely worth getting, it just could have been so much more is all.

I wouldn't judge the 2.5/5 too harshly either. I just think a 5/5 is along the lines of Batman Year One or Dark Knight Returns. So in comparison, 2.5 is a good, solid, score.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.