It depends on what you're into.
If you like noire-type stories with a grounded and detective direction, go with DC. Detective Comics is a pure detective story and a slow but solid pace. You discover things as Batman does. There's no inner monologue, which is a breath of fresh air, there's no heavy internal struggle and metaphors, these are more straight forward stories. so far there's no elaborate super-villain world conquering scheme. Here Batman fights drug dealers, slavers and deals with issues such as domestic violence. There's also a lot of focus on Harvey Bullock, so if you're a fan of him, this may be for you. The next story will be about the anti-hero Anarchy. The art fits the tone of the story, it follows a noire and gritty type tone.
Snyder's Batman on the other hand is usually more grandiose, and heavy on exposition and internal struggle. Also, Snyder's stories tend to be more "wordy", and there's a lot of dialogue. The stories usually start off with a grounded build-up, almost in a similar way to DC, but then a major twist takes place and the pace quickens, and the story overall becomes much bigger, and some might call it an epic type story, where Batman fights something that threatens the entire city. Continuity wise, since this is the main Batman title, it will impact the Batman world, possibly even the entire DC-verse, more than Detective. The next story-line Endgame seems to also deal with a city-wide threat, and may feature the return of the Joker and maybe even the Justice League. Snyder has said that this is the biggest story-line they've done so far, which is saying a lot if you've seen what they've done before (Court of Owls and Zero Year were pretty big). Capullo's art is cartoonish but very expressive and the colored palette is very varied in comparison with Buccelatto's darker and more restricted colors.
The above comments are pretty biased and seem to show each user's personal preference than an objective point of view. I tried to show you what each book offers without my personal input and see what you personally prefer. But both are strong books though.
Log in to comment