Poll Bat Girls vs Bat Boys?!? Who wins? (54 votes)
So who do you guys think would win? I was going to put Batman in as a third option, but he would win hands down :-P.
Character » Batman appears in 23627 issues.
So who do you guys think would win? I was going to put Batman in as a third option, but he would win hands down :-P.
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- You mean after Shiva killed her? Is this a rhetorical question?
- If you didn't know, Shiva is superior to all of the "bat boys".
@banestrokelobogrundybatarrow said:
Bat boys also who's spoiler
Dan Didio just got really happy with that comment. Spoiler is Stephanie Brown...second to most wanted to return after the Flash, I mean Wally West :-P.
And if you want You could totally put outsiders into this equation as well!
so that would make it
Nightwing
Alfred
Red Robin
Red Hood
Robin
Creeper
Black Lightning
Geo-Force
Metamorpho
Atomic Knight
Faust
Technocrat
Wylde
Eradicator
Arsenal
Shift
Shazam (Freddy Freeman)
Green Arrow
Owlman
Freight Train
Olympian
Nightrunner
El Gaucho
The Hood
Dark Rnger
Batwing
Bat-Mite
Azrael
Orpheus
Harold Allnut
Knight
Remac
is that everybody? that would be pretty hard to beat
@avenging_x_bolt: Haha I didn't really think when I posted that comment. Are there really that many guy outsiders compared to females? that is sad...
@batshrine: Voted for the girls but definitely would be a great fight. What versions are these? Pre52? New52?
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- You mean after Shiva killed her? Is this a rhetorical question?
- If you didn't know, Shiva is superior to all of the "bat boys".
You didn't actually read the story did you?
@pokeysteve: Well I am honestly thinking Pre52 simply because not all the girls exist anymore...
@batshrine: Voted for the girls but definitely would be a great fight. What versions are these? Pre52? New52?
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- You mean after Shiva killed her? Is this a rhetorical question?
- If you didn't know, Shiva is superior to all of the "bat boys".
You didn't actually read the story did you?
- Yes, because Shiva definitely didn't put her in a lazarus pit.
- Try again.
The team with Damian wins!
This. Anyway some of those boys are very aggressive and don't mind using lethal force against anyone so I'd say Batboys win.
@pokeysteve: Well I am honestly thinking Pre52 simply because not all the girls exist anymore...
That makes sense.
@batshrine: Voted for the girls but definitely would be a great fight. What versions are these? Pre52? New52?
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- You mean after Shiva killed her? Is this a rhetorical question?
- If you didn't know, Shiva is superior to all of the "bat boys".
You didn't actually read the story did you?
- Yes, because Shiva definitely didn't put her in a lazarus pit.
- Try again.
Umm.....you're right. She definitely did NOT put her in a Lazarus pit. Not my point either. You didn't read the story.
The team with Damian wins!
This. Anyway some of those boys are very aggressive and don't mind using lethal force against anyone so I'd say Batboys win.
lol my only response is Huntress. And lets be honest we know non of them will actually use lethal force.
@danhimself: Azreal
@danhimself: Its not a one on one match. Nightwing and Red Robin are one of the leaders and tacticians in DCU and Batwing, Azrael are heavily armored with weapons and protection and Red hood uses guns.
@pokeysteve: Well I am honestly thinking Pre52 simply because not all the girls exist anymore...
That makes sense.
@batshrine: Voted for the girls but definitely would be a great fight. What versions are these? Pre52? New52?
- The men obviously unless of course you include Shiva and Talia with the girls. If Shiva and Talia (who could easily manhandle your set of girls as far as i'm concerned) were included then, i think they would have a decent chance.
Why say Shiva, when I included Cassandra who defeated Shiva?
- You mean after Shiva killed her? Is this a rhetorical question?
- If you didn't know, Shiva is superior to all of the "bat boys".
You didn't actually read the story did you?
- Yes, because Shiva definitely didn't put her in a lazarus pit.
- Try again.
Umm.....you're right. She definitely did NOT put her in a Lazarus pit. Not my point either. You didn't read the story.
- Oh, yes, Shiva definitely didn't revive her in a way that wasn't revealed to the reader.
- Would you like to try again?
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
- Yes, you are ignorantly telling me what i did or did not read. That definitely makes complete sense.( obvious sarcasm).
- Yes, the circumstances being that she got her ass handed to her.
-DId you enjoy Shiva "stomping" Cass? I'm sure Shiva did.
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
- Yes, you are ignorantly telling me what i did or did not read. That definitely makes complete sense.( obvious sarcasm).
- Yes, the circumstances being that she got her ass handed to her.
-DId you enjoy Shiva "stomping" Cass? I'm sure Shiva did.
I'm ignoring you posting scans from a story you obviously know nothing about so why don't you just stop. I can explain what was going on if you want.
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
- Yes, you are ignorantly telling me what i did or did not read. That definitely makes complete sense.( obvious sarcasm).
- Yes, the circumstances being that she got her ass handed to her.
-DId you enjoy Shiva "stomping" Cass? I'm sure Shiva did.
I'm ignoring you posting scans from a story you obviously know nothing about so why don't you just stop. I can explain what was going on if you want.
- Yes, you definitely know what i do and do not know about even though i've read the issue.
- Am i supposed to care that she allegedly wanted to die? She was manhandled regardless.
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
- Yes, you are ignorantly telling me what i did or did not read. That definitely makes complete sense.( obvious sarcasm).
- Yes, the circumstances being that she got her ass handed to her.
-DId you enjoy Shiva "stomping" Cass? I'm sure Shiva did.
I'm ignoring you posting scans from a story you obviously know nothing about so why don't you just stop. I can explain what was going on if you want.
- Yes, you definitely know what i do and do not know about even though i've read the issue.
- Am i supposed to care that she allegedly wanted to die? She was manhandled regardless.
1) I don't care if you care or not. It's on panel.
2) There is no "allegedly" here. Like I said, it's on panel and is a fact of that story. When she fought seriously, afterwards, she beat her.
You're either in denial about how good Cass is or you just really love Shiva. Which is it?
Lol you didn't read the story. There were circumstances behind Cass losing. Post all the scans you want.
- Yes, you are ignorantly telling me what i did or did not read. That definitely makes complete sense.( obvious sarcasm).
- Yes, the circumstances being that she got her ass handed to her.
-DId you enjoy Shiva "stomping" Cass? I'm sure Shiva did.
I'm ignoring you posting scans from a story you obviously know nothing about so why don't you just stop. I can explain what was going on if you want.
- Yes, you definitely know what i do and do not know about even though i've read the issue.
- Am i supposed to care that she allegedly wanted to die? She was manhandled regardless.
1) I don't care if you care or not. It's on panel.
2) There is no "allegedly" here. Like I said, it's on panel and is a fact of that story. When she fought seriously, afterwards, she beat her.
You're either in denial about how good Cass is or you just really love Shiva. Which is it?
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
Many characters can dodge bullets, that doesn't make them invincible.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
- They aren't the same thing in your opinion. However, by your definition, neither of them was fighting seriously as they both "wanted to die". That is unless you are conceding the fact that your definition is purely subjective.
- Regardless, this argument of either one of them "not fighting seriously" seems quite subjective regardless. However, i'm sure that you will continue to attempt to assert your opinion as a fact nonetheless.
- Nobody can "take her"? False.
- You might think Cassandra is god however, you'll need to try again.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
- They aren't the same thing in your opinion. However, by your definition, neither of them was fighting seriously as they both "wanted to die". That is unless you are conceding the fact that your definition is purely subjective.
- Regardless, this argument of either one of them "not fighting seriously" seems quite subjective regardless. However, i'm sure that you will continue to attempt to assert your opinion as a fact nonetheless.
It wasn't my opinion. It's fact. Those are not the same circumstances. I explained it pretty flat out. You're just stubborn.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
- They aren't the same thing in your opinion. However, by your definition, neither of them was fighting seriously as they both "wanted to die". That is unless you are conceding the fact that your definition is purely subjective.
- Regardless, this argument of either one of them "not fighting seriously" seems quite subjective regardless. However, i'm sure that you will continue to attempt to assert your opinion as a fact nonetheless.
It wasn't my opinion. It's fact. Those are not the same circumstances. I explained it pretty flat out. You're just stubborn.
- Cassandra wanting to die = Cassandra holding back and Shiva wanting to die =/= Shiva holding back are your opinions sir.
- You're simply ignorant of the difference between a fact and an opinion. Get over it.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
- They aren't the same thing in your opinion. However, by your definition, neither of them was fighting seriously as they both "wanted to die". That is unless you are conceding the fact that your definition is purely subjective.
- Regardless, this argument of either one of them "not fighting seriously" seems quite subjective regardless. However, i'm sure that you will continue to attempt to assert your opinion as a fact nonetheless.
It wasn't my opinion. It's fact. Those are not the same circumstances. I explained it pretty flat out. You're just stubborn.
- Cassandra wanting to die = Cassandra holding back and Shiva wanting to die =/= Shiva holding back are your opinions sir.
- You're simply ignorant of the difference between a fact and an opinion. Get over it.
You seem ignorant to the fact that not everything is black and white. Maybe think it through some more.
- By this logic, Shiva "wasn't fighting seriously" from the start as Shiva wanting to die was on the panel as well.
- Thus, Shiva killed her when even though Shiva "wasn't serious"(using your apparent definition) regardless. Oh, and it's on the panel.
Not the same thing. Cass wanted to die as penance because she felt guilty. Shiva wants to find someone who is better than her in H2H. They wouldn't be better than her if she let them win. That answers your first line and the second one I don't understand. Your point is lost among the condescension.
- They aren't the same thing in your opinion. However, by your definition, neither of them was fighting seriously as they both "wanted to die". That is unless you are conceding the fact that your definition is purely subjective.
- Regardless, this argument of either one of them "not fighting seriously" seems quite subjective regardless. However, i'm sure that you will continue to attempt to assert your opinion as a fact nonetheless.
It wasn't my opinion. It's fact. Those are not the same circumstances. I explained it pretty flat out. You're just stubborn.
- Cassandra wanting to die = Cassandra holding back and Shiva wanting to die =/= Shiva holding back are your opinions sir.
- You're simply ignorant of the difference between a fact and an opinion. Get over it.
You seem ignorant to the fact that not everything is black and white. Maybe think it through some more.
- Again, you seem ignorant of the the difference between a fact and an opinion. Maybe you should look it up.
You seem ignorant to the fact that not everything is black and white. Maybe think it through some more.
- Again, you seem ignorant of the the difference between a fact and an opinion. Maybe you should look it up.
A fact is something you can prove. I can prove their reasons for wanting to die are different. It's not really my problem if you aren't able/willing to accept/understand it.
You seem ignorant to the fact that not everything is black and white. Maybe think it through some more.
- Again, you seem ignorant of the the difference between a fact and an opinion. Maybe you should look it up.
A fact is something you can prove. I can prove their reasons for wanting to die are different. It's not really my problem if you aren't able/willing to accept/understand it.
- Again, you seem ignorant of what i was referring to.
- You cannot prove that Cassandra was holding back and Shiva wasn't, when your reason for saying such is subjectively claiming that one reason for wanting to die equates to holding back, and the other does not. Hence, it's subjective and not a fact. It's not my problem if you are unable to comprehend this either.
Please Log In to post.
This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:
Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.
Log in to comment