@DarkChris: At some point (and it pains me to say this) the official line from both Miller and DC is/was that All Star Batman is the same Batman from TDKR and TDKSA.
Not only that but Batman Year One is also supposed to be the same universe... the Millerverse if you will.
I'm not joking, you can look this up.
Now obviously this is something they decided to try and convince us of long after these books were published.
Tbh, if that is the same Bruce Wayne in all 4 books, the man really does have MPD.
I mean at a stretch I could maybe, kinda accept that All Star Bats is the same guy as Dark Knight Bats (but only if I'm feeling generous).
But to try and tell us that Year One Bats is the same guy we see in All Star... well, that's just insulting.
Anyway, despite all this I don't think many fans accept it or even care.
Not many DC writers accept it or care either I suspect (OP, that's a hint).
For me Year One is canon and the canon Robin intro is Dark Victory, All Star is just a (rather poor) Elseworlds story about a psychotic Batman and TDK is Sin City's John Hartigan in a Batman suit... "Lucky old man... Lucky." >.>
Miller was great once... but he's burnt out now imo and should just stay away from the comic book industry (and film industry actually, have you seen the Spirit?).
I'm sure he's made enough money to retire comfortably and spend the rest of his days drawing "hot chix".
Anyway, I believe that the reason All Star ground to a halt is because Jim Lee couldn't stand working with the misogynistic, sex obssessed Miller any longer... Have you ever read the script sheets for All Star? It's worth it just to see Frank's drooling description of Vicki Vale.
Lmao.
Anyway, on topic, OP don't worry about it, All Star will never be finished, it bombed too hard and is almost universally reviled by fans and critics alike.
Aside from the aforementioned vague connection to TDK there are no arcs or lines that continue the story, it's dead in the water and will probably remain so forever.
Just stick an Elseworlds tag on it and move on.
Log in to comment