savagedragon's Batman: The Black Mirror #1 - HC review


I got this book in hardcover on christmas day and i was Very very pleased. SO on to the the review.

The Good:

This book did a brilliant job of capturing Gotham City and the horrors it has hidden inside. Scott Snyder's writing is captivating and his run on detective comics really proved he can combine suspense and action to tell a dark moody batman tale no matter what the venue or villain. The Black Mirror is in my opinion the culmination of his run on detective comics and together with Jock and Francavilla's art this book is a must read. So what does this book do great? Each "case" within the book is page turner. The mood it sets and it's theme of darkness and creeping sense of doom within Gotham is great, its gritty but also aesthetically pleasant. Jocks renditions of backgrounds are nice and his faces and body language are spot on. The Colors are one of the biggest stars of the book and with its uses of reds and purples blew me away. I've read many batman novels and comics but few capture the darkness and evil that lurks in the Batman's city. Dick Grayson and Jim Gordon are the main characters and this is their tale, their personal story of loss and triumph. In the Absence of Bruce Wayne Dick has assumed the cape and cowl of the city's dark knight. I loved how Snyder can show us the different mentalities between Bruce and Dick without hitting us over the head with it. Overall this book doesnt need crazy bad guys with awesome powers, it doesnt need the Galaxy at risk, or reality itself to make the reader care. It tells a brilliant story confined within Gotham. A story of Murder, Hope, Denial and a dark heart. But most of all this book is about if people are just bad eggs, and if they are....are they in the wrong? I loved this book. Read it!

The Bad:

Not much bad here, sometimes it got a bit confusing with Jim/ James Gordons flashbaack interactions and when it would fast forward back to the present. Also the Last few panels left me a little underwhelmed but the lead up to the end was fantastic.

The Verdict:

I loved it and have read it a couple times each time noticing something different on a certain panels or appreciating a set of dialogue more. What i mean is this book has staying power: its a classic. Scott Snyder and his team are awesome and everyone who likes the Dark Knight, Gotham city, Dick Grayson or BADASS things in general should read this book!


Other reviews for Batman: The Black Mirror #1 - HC

    A Bruce-less Gotham. 0

    I was halfway apprehensive when I began to read this novel because I wasn't sure if it could live up to the incredible New 52 Batman I'd recently read, and I have to say my doubts were immediately put to rest. Snyder was able to meet or even exceed his massively popular run on the New 52 Batman. This is mandatory read for Batfans and non-Batfans alike.THE GOODThe fact that Snyder is able to keep your interest in multiple arcs, all of which contain virtually no Bruce Wayne, is a feat in itself. W...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Gotham Moments 0

    I'd definitely give this 4.5 stars like under the older system, if I could - I'm not quite at the point of rounding it up to 5, though. This is a pretty impressive story, don't get me wrong. Snyder did a fine job crafting this dark and intimidating story. His fine attention to detail was quite impressive, especially in an age of somewhat less-than-impressive comic writing (perhaps more in that other company), such as the black pins on the Graysons' map and the black pin-like pupils of James,...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.