batwatch's Batman, Incorporated #5 - Asylum review

Batman, Inc. #5

Asylum

To see this review with images, click here.

Batman Incorporated has been a good series that seems to become better with every new twist, but at times, it seems to get a little lost in its own mythology. Morrison does not slow the pace of his story to brief the uninformed reader. Despite this arguable failing, Batman Inc.’s last issue delivered an amazingly action packed issue which both stalwart Morrison fans and relative noobs could appreciate. Unveiling several surprises, last issue showed us that Jason Todd had been working as a spy among Leviathan, and it was revealed that Damian plays an even bigger role in Talia’s plans than he or fans ever expected. Does this issue answer readers’ burning questions, or are fans left scratching their heads?

In this issue, Batman reveals that Damian will doom the world. After this, we get an extended look at the future of Gotham where future Batman, Damian, manages to escape a hoard of Joker zombies. It turns out that future Gotham is overrun by these Joker monstrosities, and Barbara Gordon, Damian, and the few uninfected citizens of Gotham are holed up in the remnants of Arkham Asylum as they search for a cure to the plague.

Bigger and Better

With every review, I do a brief summary of the first half of the issue, but as you can see above, I cannot even manage to do keep it short on this issue. Batman Inc. #6 is very dense and draws on years of Morrison’s previously established work along with other Batman lore. I consider myself fairly well versed in Batman comics, but Morrison left me scratching my heads on some things.

That being said, this issue is amazing. The post-apocalyptic theme seems to be in vogue these days, and Morrison paints as terrifying a vision of the future as the best of today’s’ doomsayer prophets. Morrison’s vision of the future is clearly not something he just threw together; he manages to connect lots of little details that speak to a much larger world. Little tidbits such as the name of Damian’s cats, Barbara Gordon’s altered physique and personality, Batman’s future enemies, and the occupancy of the oval office answer many questions that fans did not even know they should be asking, and yet the story still manages to sow plenty of seeds for future speculation.

I would not have believed it possible for Morrison to make this series even grander in scale, but that is exactly what he has accomplished.

Damian the Heretic

I have floated this theory a few times, but I have never made a big issue about it, and I think it time to discuss if further. I wonder if The Heretic might be Damian from the future. We know that Damian is the central character of this story already, and we know Batman fears that Damian will grow up to be a somewhat corrupt Batman and a tool of Talia. Perhaps that is because Bruce has already encountered future Damian in the present.

I have no idea how the time travel element would occur, and I could be completely off base, but there are aspects of the story which support this. The Heretic is wearing a version of the Bat costume. The Heretic refers to himself as Talia’s son at the beginning of Batman Inc. #4. Future Damian seems to be speaking to Talia at the end of his arc in this issue. Could it be that this is Talia from the past come to reap the seeds she sewed in the past? Perhaps she took him to the past with her and convinced him that the only way he could prevent the apocalyptic future was to work against Batman?

It is all speculation, but I think it bears consideration.

Squinchy Face

I have often complained that artist Chris Burnham makes characters’ faces look odd. This issue is no exception. Adult Damian looks a little strange but not too bad. Barbara looks like she has been ran over by a truck, but that can be explained as years of rough living. However, I cannot explain away young Damian’s face. His facial features are all squished together as if somebody photoshopped his face and shrunk it by twenty percent while keeping the size of his head the same. It looks bad.

Other than that, the issue is quite the visual treat, but the face thing is beginning to become annoying.

I Admit My Ignorance

I am a tad embarrassed to admit my ignorance on some issues, and I am looking for feedback. I know there are previous issues that featured glimpses into this possible future, and I have read summaries of them, but I am still left with some questions.

1. Why are two Batmen, Bruce and Dick by appearances, featured on page three?

2. Is the boy Damian rescues supposed to be Terry McGinnis?

3. Is the image of Damian standing over Batman’s body featured in one of the previous issues, and if so, what is the story that goes with it?

4. If Bruce only dreamed of this future, how does he know it is real?

Conclusion 9/10

Despite my confusion and the awkward looking faces, Batman Inc. #5 still manages to be tremendously satisfying. Up until this point, I have actually been a little skeptical of Morrison’s greatness, but this issue has made a great case for the quality of his work.

For more news, reviews, and commentary for the entire Bat Family, check out BatWatch.net.

6 Comments
Posted by Sharkey

Good review!

To answer your questions;

1 - Those are Damian's trophies of Batmen past. The very same panel is used in Batman v1 #666 (it's the "Batcave" as it were)

2 - Possibly, although that has happened before in Batman v1 #700.

3 - Again same panel as one in #666, but Robin costume altered to New 52 one.

Not too sure on 4 myself!

Posted by bennyq

Who was in the Oval office? I didn't recognise him. But was that Bruce as his advisor? It it s I'd say he should've looked older..

Posted by Cooped

His advisor was Dr Hurt, implying he finally wins.

Re: 4. At the end of Return of Bruce Wayne, Bruce is bonded to an Archivist robot at Vanishing Point, the end of time...So for a brief period he could theoretically have known everything in history...Thus he gained glimpses at the future.

Also: 2. I think the baby is a girl

Posted by BatWatch

@Sharkey said:

Good review!

To answer your questions;

1 - Those are Damian's trophies of Batmen past. The very same panel is used in Batman v1 #666 (it's the "Batcave" as it were)

2 - Possibly, although that has happened before in Batman v1 #700.

3 - Again same panel as one in #666, but Robin costume altered to New 52 one.

Not too sure on 4 myself!

Thank you very much.

1. I'm going to have to get that issue. I am very interested now.

2. Yeah, I heard that Terry was in one of those future issues, but I did not know the specifics.

3. Interesting.

4. Cooped has some thoughts on that.

@bennyq said:

Who was in the Oval office? I didn't recognise him. But was that Bruce as his advisor? It it s I'd say he should've looked older..

Doctor Hurt. I do not know too much about him myself, but I think he was introduced in the modern age by Morrison a few years ago. I know he was in The Black Glove and The Return of Bruce Wayne.

Dr. Hurt

@Cooped said:

His advisor was Dr Hurt, implying he finally wins.

Re: 4. At the end of Return of Bruce Wayne, Bruce is bonded to an Archivist robot at Vanishing Point, the end of time...So for a brief period he could theoretically have known everything in history...Thus he gained glimpses at the future.

Also: 2. I think the baby is a girl

4. Didn't Bruce say he had a dream of the future though in Batman Inc. #5?

2. Yeah, I guess it is.

Thanks for the thoughts.

For more news, reviews, and commentary for the entire Bat Family, check out BatWatch.net.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

Hurt pretended to be Bruce's dad back from the grave and was heavily involved in trying to kill him in Batman R.I.P.

Posted by BatWatch

@johnkmccubbin91 said:

Hurt pretended to be Bruce's dad back from the grave and was heavily involved in trying to kill him in Batman R.I.P.

Thanks, I read a lot of R.I.P...enough to see that he was pretending to be Thomas Wayne but not enough to see who he really was. I think I am going to have to make it a priority to read some of Morrison's past Batman work.

Other reviews for Batman, Incorporated #5 - Asylum

    Damian's Reign 0

    I have been enjoying this series and it has been much better than the first Batman, Incorporated series. I have enjoyed how this series has explained more about Leviathan, and how due to Talia al Ghul leading Leviathan, her son Damian Wayne has been more involved in the series.PlotThis issue shows what the world will be like if Damian becomes Batman, and how he will destroy Gotham City. In this story Damian, now Batman, with the help of Barbara Gordon (who's once again wheelchair bound) attempt ...

    7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.