the_cyan_lantern's Batman, Incorporated #3 - The Hanged Man review

This Put The "Detective" in Batman

***DC had postponed this issue due to certain events. My local comic shop still sold this issue whether they were aware of the postpone or not***

The Good.

Common knowledge tells us that Batman is "The Great Detective", unfortunately, DC either forgot to add that in their books or forgot how to make it good. It seems Grant may have seen that since The New 52 and went for it. And with the return of Matches Malone, that felt even more true. This books feels like a crime novel where there is snooping and a mysterious plot yet to be solved. That's what separates this series from the "Bat Books" and gives you an appreciation for such. It drives you reading and FINALLY answers the big question from issue #1. And if you think you loved Bat Cow, you're going to love the last page. 'NOUGH SAID.

And the art continues to be superior. When the first volume gave certain issues to multiple artist it didn't bug me, but after having a constant Chris Burnham, we don't need other artist on this series. Always consistent and always great!

The Bad.

Yes, the rumor has been that this book was deemed insensitive as it may be true. I'm not the judge of people's personal feelings. It doesn't help that we keep mentioning Colorado too, but DC was right in releasing it later. The book had a cold open, BUT IT WAS NOT GRANT'S FAULT. Issue was written before the incident and it goes with the story and plot. Negativity should not come from this, you may only just cause more harm. Read if you're willing to remember and move on.



  • Enjoy that we get some detective work
  • Enjoy the wonderful art
  • Enjoy the ending as much as I did

- The Cyan Lantern

Posted by JonesDeini

The "controversial" part of this issue didn't ring off any alarms from me, but I get why others could be offended by it. Either way they made the right PR move.

Posted by Webjaker

I loved this issue. The fact that there are guns in a Batman comic that was produced well before a tragedy that also involved guns and batman ...

I loved that they brought back old characters and even recently introduced ones. Moosic to my ears :)

Loved seeing Dick and Damien in this issue - No Spoilers, but LOVED their roles!

Other reviews for Batman, Incorporated #3 - The Hanged Man

    Got a Match? 0

    This series has been a huge improvement on the previous Batman Incorporated run and this is is showing that it isn't running out of ideas any time soon. It was certainly worth the wait (after it was postponed due to material that may be insensitive after the Colorado shootings). Great art from Burnham again also and Morrison this series is showing us the same level he showed when he did the ongoing Batman series and Batman and Robin (prior New 52).This issue issue is about a character named Matc...

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.