johnkmccubbin91's Batman, Incorporated #12 - Fatherless review

Man or Bat?

This has easily been one of my favourite series in the New 52, and this series has been a vast improvement over the previous Batman, Incorporated series. It has however had a few down points over the series, but overall it has been amazing, and looks to be the perfect way to end Grant Morrison's fantastic run on the character.


Batman now souped-up with Man-Bat formula takes the fight to Leviathan, and mainly The Heretic.


This was a fantastic issue, and one of the best in the series so far. Although last issue was interesting it was nice to see Grant Morrison's story back in the limelight, and with the way issue 10 ended I was desperate to find out what happened next, and I wasn't disappointed. Morrison did a phenomenal job of showing Batman's rage, and fury, with the emotional Batman getting straight down to business. The action was also perfectly written, and due to Morrison getting straight into the action, it was exciting all the way through. The dialogue was also brilliant, and although there weren't many detailed discussions, it had perfect fighting dialogue. Morrison also did a great job of showing what the other character's were up to, as well as add yet more mystery, setting up next issues finale perfectly.

Chris Burnham returns to arts on this issue, and although he did a decent job writing the filler story in last issue, he's much more suited as an artist. The detail in Burnham's art is simply amazing, and his rough, and gritty style really suits the series, and especially this issue. The best part of Burnham's art in this issue was naturally the action sequences, which were simply outstanding, and although Morrison's script was perfect during the fight, it was Burnham's art that made it extraordinary, making the fight that much more exciting, and dramatic. the layout of Burnham's art was also superb, especially in the more mysterious sequences, adding ton's of suspense. Burnham also did a fantastic job of showing the character's emotions, and although Batman was the best example of this, the rest was also brilliant.

I've already talked a bit about the action, but felt that I'd go into a little more detail seems this was my favourite part of the issue. I will however avoid spoilers though, so don't worry about that. What was best about the action in this fight was that it had lot's of impact, and tone to it, giving a brilliant atmosphere. It also had plenty of emotion in it, on both sides, as you could see the rage, and determination for revenge in Batman's eyes, as well as a desire for victory from Heretic, to win his mother, Talia al Ghul's approval. It did however have to be good, as with it taking up most of the issue it would have really hurt the issue if this wasn't the case, but thankfully it wasn't.

Talking of Talia, she didn't really make much of an appearance, appearing at the start, as well as another couple of times for brief periods. Without going into details, as to avoid spoilers, the time she did appear was however brilliant, and very dramatic, as well as shocking. Another character who slightly shocked me in this issue was Knight (Beryl Hutchinson), who really showed her emotions towards Heretic over the former Knight's (Cyril Sheldrake) death, which added yet more drama to the issue, as well as more emotion.

Besides the fight the thing that interested me most in this issue had to be the mysterious woman who offered to help Batman Inc. Now I love mysteries, and with this story, as well as the series coming to an end what a better time. Both Morrison, and Burnham handled the mystery perfectly, showing the profile of the woman, without actually revealing her identity, which was smart. It also makes me question whether this is a person who has already featured in the series. It does appear however that Nightwing (Dick Grayson) knows the woman, recognising the voice, so this would indicate that she has a connection to Batman at least, if not Talia as well.

Final Verdict

This was a brilliant issue, and one of the best in the series so far. It had brilliant action, amazing dialogue, and some emotional sequences. It also had a hint of mystery, and sets up next issues finale perfectly. Due to all this I'd highly recommend this issue, as well as the series, which has been brilliant, and one of the best Batman stories in a while.

Rating: 5/5

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

I've decided to shorten my reviews down slightly. Could you please leave a comment to say whether you prefer this, or the more detailed versions?

Posted by broo1232

I think the strange woman is probably Kathy Kane as Dick's the only one who would know she was.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Could be. Would be appropriate considering Talia was dressed similar to her at the end of the issue.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Also what do you think of the shortened format, is it better than the more detailed version, or should I go back to more detail?

Posted by broo1232

@johnkmccubbin91: That was my thinking as well. Its working well at the minute I'll need a few more reviews to judge it properly (of course in your own time), but its coming along well.

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Thanks. Was just wanting feedback as I was told that they were a bit long, and I was thinking that myself. I will be reviewing Iron Man later or tomorrow. I will however be reviewing TPB in more detail, especially the one I started working on prior to this that I'm finishing the now.

Posted by broo1232

@johnkmccubbin91: I can understand that the whole point of my new format was to cut it down a bit, but your doing well :) Look forward to your reviews.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Posted by broo1232
Posted by Cyclops4President

I LOVE the shorter versions of your reviews. Expertly done. Saying that, my last few reviews have gone on the long side. I really like your format and review style. very well done. And for you to rate this issue 5/5, I know it must be good.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@cyclops4president: Thanks, I was feeling my reviews were just that bit too long and when you said it reassured that so I thought it'd be the best time to try doing it a bit shorter, and I much prefer it this way. Your reviews have been getting longer, but I also feel better, as although they were already good, they just feel a little bit better now. As for this issue it had the perfect combo of action and emotion, and I really enjoyed it.

Other reviews for Batman, Incorporated #12 - Fatherless

    Manbat Incorporated! 0

    i'll admit that i don't understand batman at a deep level, but i will however still review this issue since i believe it too be amazing. after thinking about this issue for a while, i can safely say that this is the very few titles that is worth reading in the new 52. burnham's art isn't something i've fond of, i think it is a bit rough around the edges, however this isn't all that bad, because some of the arts strengths actually lies in this specific problem of mine. because of the rough edges,...

    9 out of 9 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.