Off THEIR Minds: Should Batman be Allowed to Have Another Robin?

  • 120 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Posted by G-Man (29415 posts) - - Show Bio

Batman and Robin. The Dynamic Duo. The Caped Crusaders. You can easily have Batman without Robin. The two just go together so well.

We've seen after Jason Todd [originally] died that Batman needed a Robin. Having a Robin is what keeps him in check. Over the years we've seen the notion of Robin grow into something bigger. The role of Robin wasn't just to be a comedic sidekick but was now seen as a partner for Batman.

With the recent events and the dangers the role has caused in the past, the question is, should Batman be allowed to haver a Robin? We could debate this but we decided to ask creators this question at Emerald City Comicon. Check out what Joshua Hale Fialkov, Kyle Higgins, Brian Buccellato, James Robinson, Peter Nguyen, James Tynion IV, Matt Fraction, Josh Williamson, Jim McCann and Sam Humphries think about this topic.

Batman should have a Robin but are the risks too great? Is it a matter of child endangerment? Does Batman have the right to encourage kids to take on a dangerous role?

Staff
#1 Edited by Cyborg6971 (166 posts) - - Show Bio

No, if social services has there say in it. Maybe Bats should post the position up online, take applications, and do interviews. Brooding would be a prerequisite.

Maybe Harper Row will take up the mantel.

#2 Posted by daredevil21134 (9093 posts) - - Show Bio

@Cyborg6971 said:

No, if social services has there say in it.

lol

#3 Posted by Trodorne (2569 posts) - - Show Bio

Where is the police in this matter?

Parents lock your kids, cause the Batman will take your child and make them his sidekick. Child Endangerment anyone?

#4 Posted by Dark_Vengeance_ (13866 posts) - - Show Bio

Should he? No.

Will he? I hope not.

Should Damian stay dead? Yes, I don't want another pointless death.

#5 Posted by ectoborge (198 posts) - - Show Bio

Joker should be the new Robin

#6 Posted by evilvegeta74 (4517 posts) - - Show Bio

No, Damian is not replaceble.Personally I don't wanna see anyone as a Robin other than Damian. I wonder if this will be addressed by the Justice League, do they know? How should they treat Batman?

#7 Posted by Rumble Man (11119 posts) - - Show Bio

Batpedo wants ur kiddies

lock up the doors

#9 Posted by ccraft (3962 posts) - - Show Bio

I don't think he should have another robin, let him be solo for awhile. I wouldn't care if he got a partner.

#10 Posted by Lonestar9 (28 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes, absolutely. I would prefer an older Robin, minimum 16+, but other than that, he needs someone who can back him up, trust, etc. Jason died, but if he's alive again, how does that count? I wouldn't be surprised at all to see Damian return someday, but I doubt it'll be anytime soon. So I'm curious to see how this all plays out.

#11 Posted by Mighty Thorion (797 posts) - - Show Bio

"Should he be allowed" LOL - Who is going to stop him?

#12 Posted by X9 (746 posts) - - Show Bio

I believe (and I'm holding on that hope) that Damian will come back and will be Robin again.

However, in the meanwhile, a few issues after his death, I wouldn't object to see Batman with a new sidekick. It could even be a female one, as he's traumatized with boys.

Even though if I were Bruce I'd think twice before bringing someone to that life again...

#13 Posted by judasnixon (5441 posts) - - Show Bio

What kind of an A-Hole takes a child out to fight serial killers pass curfew? 

#14 Posted by KnightRise (4753 posts) - - Show Bio

@Trodorne said:

Where is the police in this matter?

Parents lock your kids, cause the Batman will take your child and make them his sidekick. Child Endangerment anyone?

Best. Kidnapping. EVER!!!

#15 Edited by shackle (215 posts) - - Show Bio

We're going to continually rehash this for the next 2 or 3 months, aren't we?

The answer is the same as it was the last time this was brought up--no. Bruce Wayne cannot justify continuing to put his charges in mortal danger; his track record hasn't exactly been too impressive. In truth, Bruce Wayne, at the very least, is guilty of child endangerment, probably outright child abuse. Bruce Wayne SHOULD be charged with manslaughter and locked up. But he will throw another sidekick into the meat grinder anyway, because the comic reading masses want a Robin, no matter how dumb and indefensible that decision is.

And this will be the same answer the next time it's asked in another week or less.

#16 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (7220 posts) - - Show Bio

Whens Alfred gonna become Robin...

#17 Posted by BlueLantern1995 (2448 posts) - - Show Bio

Should he? No

Will he? Maybe though he probably won't.

Should Damian come back? Heck Yes but not immediately and first as a villain(have Red Hood be very important in the title...would be interesting)

#18 Posted by The Average Bear (2049 posts) - - Show Bio

I think we need to see a solo Batman for a while. But I think it would be cool if Nightwing or a new character made regular appearances with him

#19 Posted by The_Tree (6404 posts) - - Show Bio

He shouldn't, but he will.

#20 Posted by HoodlumNoHavoc (23 posts) - - Show Bio

Fraction creeping on Sam just made my day! lol

#21 Edited by kid Apollo (697 posts) - - Show Bio

Harper Row better not become the next Robin or im gona slap someone sooooo hard

although she does kinda fit the m.o.- black hair, troubled past, has one skill thats more pronounced then most others

#22 Posted by Mutant God (2998 posts) - - Show Bio

What if the next Robin is not human, what if Batman built a robotic child to be the next Robin

#23 Posted by The Cyan Lantern (240 posts) - - Show Bio

Good ol' Fraction

#24 Posted by Dark_Guyver (2059 posts) - - Show Bio

I just never could by into the caped crusader having a kid for a sidekick. Lets get the original duo back together. Batman and Nightwing!

#25 Posted by TDK_1997 (13684 posts) - - Show Bio

Right now no but in the future I want another Robin.It may even be one of the old ones.

#26 Posted by Mucklefluga (2431 posts) - - Show Bio

Matt behind was Sam was so scary ahaaaaaa ;D

#27 Posted by I_Stay_Puft (58 posts) - - Show Bio

HE probably shouldn't, he's 2/5 now in terms of Robin survivability.

#28 Posted by leokearon (1707 posts) - - Show Bio

@TheCheeseStabber said:

Whens Alfred gonna become Robin...

Why would he be Robin when he's The Eagle!

#29 Posted by Nightwing4 (348 posts) - - Show Bio

2 Robin deaths in over 70 years of comics. "They die a lot." "They're dropping like flies."

#30 Posted by darkwingdan (179 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nightwing4: I agree. Although the two have occurred in the last 25 year years. That's still pretty good. Sure, in the video Tony makes the point "2 in 5 years," but the comic book world is not the real world. There are leaps in logic and crazy stuff happening all the time. There's an entire universe where "mutants" face persecution, while other superpowered beings are not. We had Superboy-Prime punch reality to resurrect Jason Todd (sidebar: I love the reality punch because it is the type of crazy, insane stuff we only get in comics). Maybe in our world, it wouldn't make sense for Batman to get another Robin, but not in the world of comics.

#31 Posted by darkwingdan (179 posts) - - Show Bio

@TDK_1997: maybe get Tim back?

#32 Posted by Grey56 (681 posts) - - Show Bio

Look, sir - are you simply trying to be provocative? I'm trying to ascertain what your goal is - to answer whether there is legal maneuver to enlist a minor for crime fighting acting outside any law enforcement agency or if there is metaphysical conceit to justify a fictional character recruiting another fictional character for Quixotic crusades.

I'm assuming broadly that you are asking about the latter. However, you are using the word 'should' which carries some implicit moral weight. Any litany of things can be written into comics without the sticky legalities that encumber us day to day - to include the enlistment of children for extra-legal martial enforcement.

The better question is; Is Batman right to have Robin fight alongside him. Is it right for Bruce to knowingly take in someone, regardless as to circumstance - and expose them to the horrors which face people seeking to protect civil society from serial killers and worse? Do the legalities of socio-norms matter when one is compelled by a calling for Kantian justice - those are some questions.

#33 Posted by EdBlank (396 posts) - - Show Bio

One does not simply "allow" the GD Batman to do things..

#34 Posted by TDK_1997 (13684 posts) - - Show Bio

@darkwingdan: Yep.Or we can get Stephanie Brown as his sidekick.

#35 Posted by bsavelli (57 posts) - - Show Bio

I agree with James Tynion IV when he says that Robin is an important part of the Batman mythos, but I don't know if Batman should have another person to wear the mantle, and that's for the simple reason that Damian was not just his Robin, he was his son. To just choose someone else to take his place wouldn't be easy to him. Now, I'm not the greatest fan of characters' resurrections on comic books, but yeah, maybe it would be a good idea to bring him back.

#36 Posted by Trevel8182 (742 posts) - - Show Bio

@Nightwing4: Does no one remember Stephanie brown

#37 Posted by Mezmero (858 posts) - - Show Bio

He should be allowed another Robin but not a kid. Instead he should hire an actual robin to be a Robin. The bird could have telepathy to communicate and maybe ice powers for good measure. If Batman can prove that he's responsible enough to take care of a little telepathic ice bird then he can try training kids again. It doesn't have to be a real bird, maybe a mechanical bird automaton that is networked to the batcomputer. I honestly wouldn't mind seeing Titus or Alfred the cat as Robins.

I think he just shouldn't be allowed to have anymore clones as Robins or clones period. Damian got killed because he was artificial, not meant to be. If Bruce wants a kid he'll do it the old fashioned way and not the creepy love potion number 9 way. Jason's death was an accident if you consider underestimatng the Joker an accident. Love this video! Want more soon!

#38 Posted by wessaari (613 posts) - - Show Bio

@Trevel8182 said:

@Nightwing4: Does no one remember Stephanie brown

this, and

Jim Mccan totally gave a Spoiler shoutout!!!!!

#39 Posted by DocFishstick (216 posts) - - Show Bio

Yes i think he should have a Robin. I say they should give the job to Helena Wayne. She was Robin on Earth 2 and she was Batman's daughter. So we have a Robin with Wayne's blood in her. I would love to see this.

#40 Posted by zanevittorio (6 posts) - - Show Bio

No way! I don't even like the idea of him having a kid to be honest.

#41 Posted by moondogy42 (48 posts) - - Show Bio

Robin serves as a buffer,instead of bats dying robin acts as his scapegoat

win freaking win

#42 Posted by millennium (177 posts) - - Show Bio

yes batman should have a robin and im hoping for a female one come on stephanie brown or harper row

#43 Posted by TheCheeseStabber (7220 posts) - - Show Bio

@leokearon: Think with that Power he should've been able to fight off Joker in Death of The Family

>.>

#44 Posted by Zeeguy91 (1075 posts) - - Show Bio

I have to say that Josh Fialkov and Matt Fraction's responses were my favorites. Matt is especially hilarious. Anyway, I don't think Batman should have a new Robin right now and probably not for a few years. Maybe when issue #56 of Batman rolls around (i.e. three years from now), they could have another Robin come in and fill Damian's shoes. I think Harper Row would actually make a great Robin. In fact, I think that is what Snyder is building her up to be.

#45 Posted by hyperman (135 posts) - - Show Bio

Of course he should, it's like Superman and Lois lane, sherlock holmes and dr watson, Cleopatra and marc Anthony, Adam and Eve, Bonnie and Clyde and so forth, It's iconic!!! And I want so badly Dick Grayson to be back as Robin!

#46 Posted by Darkmount1 (1261 posts) - - Show Bio
#47 Posted by AskaniSon295 (422 posts) - - Show Bio

he should make a Robot Robin.

#48 Posted by thenexusrebound (227 posts) - - Show Bio

I love the idea that they keep saying Robins die all the time. Only two have died and one has come back as a mega badass. I agree with Fraction though, that is why I hope Harper becomes the new Robin or maybe she takes up the title Red Bird who knows!

#49 Posted by StMichalofWilson (3403 posts) - - Show Bio

@The_Tree said:

He shouldn't, but he will.

This

#50 Posted by LifePool (135 posts) - - Show Bio

I like this robot idea a few people have circulated around.

Never really thought of it: it would serve the purpose of a Robin (providing Batman with support) without putting anymore children in danger.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.