batwatch's Batman and Robin Annual #1 - Batman Impossible review

Batman and Robin Annaul 1

Batman Impossible

To see this review with images, Click Here.

Normally when I introduce a comic, I talk about what has been going on previously in the series, but since this is an annual, I really have no idea what to expect. Sure, I could cheat and read the solicits, but I like being surprised. We know this issue cannot be taking place chronologically with the regular series since the last time we saw Damian, he was being dragged God knows where by Joker, so unless this issue features forty pages of Robin waiting for Batman to show up so we can find out what is under the darn platter, I'm guessing this issue probably took place earlier. The cover is also interesting having Damian wearing his grown up Batman uniform even though he is still a child, and unless I am mistaken, this cover is an homage to an earlier future Damian story. Anyway, I'm prepped and ready for this issue. Does Batman and Robin Annual #1 deliver a win or a fail?

In this issue, Damian sends Bruce on a worldwide scavenger hunt down memory's lane where the world's greatest detective reconnects with some secrets from his parents' past. Meanwhile, Damian dons the cape and cowl to guard Gotham while Bruce is gone.

A Comedy Tonight!

This is by far the funniest comic I have read in a long, long time. That is including the recent Li'l Gotham comics. Tomasi, the writer, does an amazing job keeping the serious tone that the series had during the Nobody run and yet putting the characters in scenarios that lead to huge laughs. Sometimes when a writer tries to be funny, he or she sets up some ridiculous situation which might be humorous but ruins the serious nature of the comic, but here, the humor comes from the personalities of the individual characters, and that takes skill.

The dialogue really shines in this issue. Some people have pinged Tomasi in the past losing Bruce's voice and making him a little bit of a ham, but in this issue, he sounds just right. Furthermore, if you love those tender and funny moments between Alfred and Bruce, then you will love this issue because it is jam packed full of those moments. I am frustrated because I want to give examples of some funny lines, yet at the same time, they are often context specific, so I cannot really do them justice with little snippets, and besides that, I do not want to ruin them for you when you read them for the first time. Just take my word for it; this issue is hilarious.

Development for Everybody!

Seeing this story slow down a little and really focus on personal moments for all the characters rather than just the typical “Action, action, action!” found in many comics made me really wish we could get a longer format for more stories. I suppose that is not really possible due to artistic constraints, but at least Tomasi takes advantage of his the annual here and takes plenty of time to develop all three characters featured in this issue, Damian, Bruce, and Alfred. With Damian, we get to see him develop in terms of compassion and altruism, and the poor kid has finally learned how to open up and share. Similarly, we get to see Bruce struggle with how to be a good dad which is something that has strangely appeared very little since his discovery of Damian's existence. In addition to fathering woes, Bruce does get some very nice gifts from Damian which force him to reflect. We almost never see any development from Alfred which is one of the many reasons this issue is such a treat. Alfred decides to reconnect with his past acting buddies which leads him to consider what he might have missed while in service to the Wayne family.

The Art Corner

The art looked really good in this issue without a bad panel in the nearly forty pages. Ardian Syaf (previous penciler of Batgirl {2011}) handles the pencils, and he does a great job. Expressions are very important in this issue since so much of it deals with peoples reactions and interactions, and Syaf presents them well. The inking looks good, and the colors are quite striking and vivid as well, but I did feel like the colors did not always blend well from page to page. There were some instances where the art went from such a dark tone to so incredibly bright that I actually thought there might have been an artistic change in the middle of the issue, but apparently, colorist John Kalisz (former colorist for JSA and Detective Comcis {2011}) just likes to work like that. It's not bad in any way, but it did surprise me at times.

Nitpicks

I did have two little complaints on the issue. First, Batman mentions, “Taking a page from the Mr. Freeze handbook,” yet I did not see anything in his actions that explained what he meant by that. It seems like there might have been one other piece of dialogue somewhere in the issue I did not follow. (Spoiler) Second, it is never explained how Damian new of so many things from his grandparents past. There are certainly plausible explanations, but none were ever made.

Conclusion 10/10

This issue is hilarious and heartwarming. Plus, it has a little action. There is no reason not to love this issue, and I fully recommend you pick it up.

For more news, reviews, and commentary for the entire Bat Family, check out BatWatch.net.

Other Recent Reviews

Batman and Robin Annual #1

Teen Titans #16

The Dark Knight #16

Batman, Incorporated #7

Talon #4

Legends of the Dark Knight #35

8 Comments
Edited by Webjaker

When i first started this issue, i thought, what a snooze-fest of an Idea, boy was I wrong - Loved it!

Posted by mbembet

great review!
Tomasi>>>>scott snyder

Posted by BatWatch

@Webjaker said:

When i first started this issue, i thought, what a snooze-fest of an Idea, boy was I wrong - Loved it!

Oh yeah! Great issue. It is true that the first page was a bit typical though, but it was needed to set up for Damain to echo Bruce's actions later on in the story.

@mbembet said:

great review! Tomasi>>>>scott snyder

Thank you, sir! I'm not sure I agree with you about Tomasi being better than Snyder though. I'm not a Snyder fan boy. Some of his work has had some issues and I've rarely seen him write an issue as good as this one, but on the other hand, Snyder never wrote anything as awful as that horrible zombie plot line Tomasi wrote a few months back, so...I don't know.

Posted by Rixec

I think Damien knew because he had been looking it up. I'm sure he said that somewhere.

Posted by djetter0801

I just appreciate that we got to see Bruce Wayne so much in this comic. I could see where Bruce would have his memory of his parents frozen in time but Damian would want to know more about them. This is definitely something I could see Tim/Jason/Dick get away with.

Posted by BatWatch

@djetter0801 said:

I just appreciate that we got to see Bruce Wayne so much in this comic. I could see where Bruce would have his memory of his parents frozen in time but Damian would want to know more about them. This is definitely something I could see Tim/Jason/Dick get away with.

It is nice to see Bruce developed a little as a character. He is so stagnant in most comics, and it does make sense that Damian would want to know more about his past. Are you saying that the other boys would or would not get away with it because I think they probably would not get away with it.

Posted by djetter0801

@BatWatch: I could see them get away with not doing. They would probably think they took a step too far in their relationship with Bruce, where as Damian has a little more wiggle room for forgiveness in his relationship with Bruce to try and pull this off.

Posted by BatWatch

@djetter0801 said:

@BatWatch: I could see them get away with not doing. They would probably think they took a step too far in their relationship with Bruce, where as Damian has a little more wiggle room for forgiveness in his relationship with Bruce to try and pull this off.

I agree. Bruce is much more lenient with Damian that the other Robins, and Damian has an excuse since it is his family as well. I do not see Bruce appreciating this trick with Jason or Tim. Dick might get away with it.

Other reviews for Batman and Robin Annual #1 - Batman Impossible

    Batman and Robin Annual #1 Rating 0

    Cover & Solicit - 4/5Would I pick-up or buy the comic based on the solicit or cover alone?Are the alternate covers appealing?Does the solicit and cover portray what happens in the issue?Do I like the artist's style on the cover?Art, Colors & Inking - 4/5- Weighted DoubleDo I personally like this artist's style?Does the artist stay true to the characters appearance?If there are multiple artists do they blend well and not disturb the reading experience?Does the coloring/inking blend well w...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Earning Fathers Trust 0

    The Good : Loved the art in this and you will get plenty of 666 batman suit! PLENTY! Damian takes his father on a journey that Bruce will definitely not forget. If you want see tibits on how Bruces parents were this is a excellent issue for that. A lot of heart warming moments here. I took a long time for Peter Tomasi to get batman to trust his son , but the wait was really worth it. I really love this 666 suit. I also enjoyed Damain demeanor than previous issues written by Peter. If Alfred does...

    2 out of 3 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.