johnkmccubbin91's Batman and Robin #23.4 - Blood in the Water review

If You Go Down to the Sewers Today, You're Sure of a Big Surprise

I wasn't too sure whether or not I was going to get this issue, as although I'm a big fan of Killer Croc I'm not overly familiar with the creative team. Added to this I also decided to get all the Batman related issues in Villains Month bar the Batman: The Dark Knight titles.


A team of crocked cops head down into the sewer to look for a dead body they chucked into it, but they soon find that this isn't an easy job with Killer Croc going around.


This was an amazing issue and I was pleasantly surprised by how good it was. Tim Seeley did an outstanding job of showing this vicious villain that is Killer Croc, though he also managed to show that there is more to old Croc than we initially see. Seeley also did a great job of balancing the flashbacks with the current events of this story, as some Villains Month issues haven't done this, with some feeling too forced. I also loved the amount of emotion that Seeley managed to add, as although this was still a very gritty story, it managed to show different sides to Croc, showing that he wasn't always a cold blooded killer, which I really enjoyed and I'd gladly read more from Seeley after reading this.

The artwork in this issue was also very good, as although it wasn't anything spectacular Francis Portela managed to show Killer Croc perfectly. The detail in Portela's art was also very impressive, being very consistent throughout the entire issue. I also loved how Portela was able to show all the different tones of this story throughout his artwork, as with it changing from a very gritty story, to a more emotional it was nice to see the change in Portela's approach to his artwork. I also really enjoyed Portela's layouts, especially in the more explosive sequences, as they managed to add so much more tension and atmosphere to the issue, as well as the action itself adding lots of excitement.

This issue would start with a bunch off cops searching the sewers for a dead body that they threw down there, with this being the main focus of the present part of this story. I really enjoyed this part of the story, and felt that it was probably the most suspenseful. I also loved the attitude of these characters, as well as having the constant thought of, "Croc's going to get you." I also enjoyed seeing the fear in their faces throughout as it's always nice to see misery in a thriller, especially when the characters deserve it.

We'd also get a look at Croc's origin in this issue, as although it wasn't heavily focused on how he became what he is, it showed bits of his past to show readers how he became this monster. It started with him as a child, and I rather enjoyed this sequence as it gave a completely different perspective on Croc, showing how he wasn't always a monster, just a mistreated boy who had some skin problems. I also enjoyed the interaction he had with his aunt during this sequence, and how he desperately wanted to change, but felt that his aunts method was too painful.

The rest of the flashbacks would show how Croc went from a freak show act to the full on villain that he's best known as. Now though some people may have wanted this expanded on I was rather glad that it was summarised as I already know Croc's origin, and preferred the more symbolic background work that we got in the other flashback parts. I did however enjoy seeing it, and the interaction that Robin (Jason Todd) had with Croc was brilliant. I also really enjoyed the freak show sequence as it too was rather depp, and dramatic, also having dark and light tones at certain points.

Final Verdict

This was an outstanding issue, and one of the best Villains Month issues that I've read this week. It showed Killer Croc perfectly, also showing a different side to him. The story itself was also very diverse, having different tones throughout, and although I wasn't overly familiar with either Seeley or Portela prior to this issue, I'd gladly read more of their work. Due to this I'd highly recommend this issue to anyone, as although it wasn't phenomenal it was brilliant.

Rating: 9/10

This review was originally posted on my website Imagination Centre (here).

Edited by TheAcidSkull

4/5 stars? NUUUUUU! :P

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

If you notice at the bottom I rated it 9/10 though as you can't get the equivalent of that on here I put 4 as I didn't think it was as good as the likes of Zod or Riddler (my two favourites of the month).

Edited by broo1232

Title is genius :)

Posted by HellionVulcan

I need to read this as Killer Croc is one of my favorite Dc characters .

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Thanks very much I thought it was rather amusing myself, just had that in my head as I started reading the issue for some reason.

@hellionvulcan: It's a brilliant issue and does the character justice (unlike what some Villains Month issues have).

Posted by broo1232
Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Thanks again. It was a nice surprise as I didn't expect it to be this good as although I've heard good things about Seeley's Hack/Slash series having never read it myself I didn't know what to expect.

Edited by broo1232
Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Posted by broo1232

Having read this now I thought it was really good and one of the best of villains month and I never expected something on Croc to be this good, but it really sold me on him and I hope Tim Seely does more Killer Croc work as he does very well with him (hoping for in Batman Eternal)

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Yeah it really surprised me and I hope that Seeley manages to do a full length story involving Croc.

Posted by broo1232

@johnkmccubbin91: I do too and I want more of this underground criminal empire as well as that is very interesting as well.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

Other reviews for Batman and Robin #23.4 - Blood in the Water

    Atavism 0

    When i heard Tim Seeley was writing Croc for the villain month issue, i was extremely excited and happy, Tim seeley is a great writer who has worked on one of my personal favorite series called hack/slash. But now here is the thing, Image comics are vastly different in Genre and style when it is compared to Marvel comics, and Hack/Slash is am immature yet brilliantly written series. So i was slightly skeptical and worried when i contemplated on the subject for a while. Plus, while the villain Mo...

    7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.