jakob187's Batman and Robin #13 - Batman And Robin Must Die! Part 1: The Garden of Death review

Batman & Robin #13 - The jakob187 Review

Two things ran through my mind for the month and a half that it took for Batman & Robin #13 to finally grace the shelves:  how crazy are things about to get, and is Frazier Irving's artwork going to kill the next three issues for me?  To answer those:  things get pretty crazy indeed, and Irving's artwork actually works for this issue in a way that (surprisingly) I don't think any other artist could've done justice in nearly the same tone.
 
Now that the cat is out of the bag, issue #13 sees the return of the Joker, who tries to convince Dick and Damian that he is trying to help stop the madness that is about to ensue rather than cause it.  Over the course of the issue, we see the Joker only intermittently as Dick gets down to some nitty-gritty detective work.  It's good to see Dick really showing off his capabilities, and in all honesty, he felt more natural as Batman in this issue than any previous issues of this or the core series.  For a second, it almost sounded like Bruce. 
 
And THAT is where this issue really captured me:  the fact that everyone seems to know that this Batman is not the same as the last Batman.  Joker offers a bit of exposition early in the issue where he states that he needs to help so he can get HIS Batman back.  He goes on to say that without HIS Batman, he can't do anything right...that he's not a "Clown Prince" or anything.  Jim Gordon goes on about mid-way in the issue after some dialogue IN THE BATMOBILE on the way TO THE BAT BUNKER about how this Batman doesn't sound like the old Batman...and even goes so far as to say that the police officers PREFER this Batman. 
 
The one odd thing is that Joker makes some very specific references to Batman and Robin suggesting that he knows their identities.  If this is true, then it makes the story all that more intriguing.  The way that this tone mixes with Morrison's writing and Irving's artwork is a great meld, even if Irving's Joker leaves something to be desired (where's the bullet hole?!) and his proportions aren't always good eye-candy.  However, the general lighting and feeling of Irving's art gives this an almost macabre and noir tone that fits well with the story.  Morrison's writing is some of his best on the series, especially with the way he offers back-and-forth dialogue between all the characters.  A few small things seem to come up abruptly and then get dropped, but as it is with anything that Morrison writes, those things will surely play out in later issues. 
 
The beginning of the issue itself starts with a small piece about Doctor Hurt, specifically playing it out that Hurt is actually Thomas Wayne (much like we heard and saw in R.I.P. but turned out to be a lie...I think...Morrison isn't very clear).  The sequence feels dream-like in a way, but also seems to be telling of the future for Dick Grayson, which needless to say, that future ain't so bright. 
 
Overall, this issue was well worth the wait for its release.  If you are feeling sketchy about picking it up, I would tell you it's a must-read for any R.I.P. fans as well as those interested in Bruce's return.

0 Comments

Other reviews for Batman and Robin #13 - Batman And Robin Must Die! Part 1: The Garden of Death

    Awesome 0

    This story is brilliant. The writing sounds... INSANE and the opening showing Thomas Wayne is creepy and awesome. The art is creepy too. If I were to describe this in one word, I would say "Creepy".  A lot of people have been saying that this arc is very hard for people to pick up and follow but I found it rather new reader friendly. I never read Batman R.I.P. or The Return of Bruce Wayne but I still found this issue easy to read and easy to follow. Maybe there are lots of clues I'm not picking ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Damian Vs. The Joker? 0

         It's odd to see a monthly book that depends on an artist so much. As great as Grant Morrison's writing can be, "Batman and Robin" and reception to each issue seems to depend heavily on who is drawing the arc. That doesn't change as Frazer Irving joins Grant for "Batman and Robin Must Die!"     Off the bat, Grant Morrison is not new reader friendly. He works in so much history - both from old runs and his own past runs - that really pays off for a keen reader. I imagine Grant writing with gl...

    8 out of 8 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.