kidhero999's Batman #24 - Zero Year: Dark City, Part One review


Longer take:
Year One is superior, and clearly is the template from which Snyder is working. I think he's been given an impossible task (though one can argue he didn't need to accept it) in navigating the treacherous waters of remaining respectful of Miller's origin and translating it to the reality of the New 52 rebooted DCU. He's obviously charting a middle-course which leaves the story imperfect and, with some few new characters (as you noted, Uncle Phillip Kane, along with a visual nod to Col. Jacob and his two twin daughters Katherine and Beth in a portrait in his office) largely devoid of originality. The trappings, such as modern/futuristic, sci-fi technology is incorporated to evoke a modern setting. Nevertheless, in attempting to ground Batman's "first mission" in a grandiose plot by masked criminals, the "realism" (as it were) of Miller's origin is undermined. The mob bosses like Falcone are paid passing mention and lip-service, but they are seemingly being treated as backdrop material for this new origin. Even Lieutenant Jim Gordon's role has been greatly reduced. Batman's "identity" has gone from urban myth, to an open, quasi-public figure as depicted in #24.
Stylistically, the story thus far is LADEN with homages -- from the costume (purple gloves, wide, pointy ears on the cowl) to imagery (the original Detective Comics #27 cover double-page spread with the Red Hood gang) to ritual ("Yes, father...").
In any event, as Rikdad notes, Snyder is a capable writer, and this story is not bad. It simply lacks the simplicity and "realism" (theres that word again) of Year One. In fact, though they came later and were questionable in terms of their placement in "canon," Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale's The Long Halloween and Dark Victory serve as spiritual sequels to Year One insofar as they continue the story of Batman's early battles against the crime family's of Gotham. (I've always thought of them as unofficial "Years Two and Three, respectively, even if Dark Victory suffers by comparison to it's predecessor, and both incorporate a year-long running serial-killer mystery gimmick.) As for The Joker, The Killing Joke is obviously the quintessential modern "origin" tale, insofar as The Joker has one. (Ironically, it's literal relation to canon was recently called into question with regard to its ending, wherein Grant Morrison claimed in a recent interview that "the killing joke" is quite literal, as Batman actually kills The Joker at the end of the story. Speculate and debate as you like.) Finally, Ed Brubaker's 2005 quasi-sequel to Year One picks up where the original leaves off -- telling the story of The Joker's first attempt at terrorizing Gotham and poisoning the reservoir (a long-running Joker plot that has been recycled in numerous iterations, including in the The Red Hood Gang's recent attempt at "poisoning" the city using Wayne Industries technology to build bio bombs of some sort.) All of these stories were integral to both Batman Begins and The Dark Knight in various respects as source material. It would seem DC is blatantly and unequivocally closing the door on the post-crisis representations of its heroes, least of all Batman. Reply


Other reviews for Batman #24 - Zero Year: Dark City, Part One

    Final Showdown with the Red Hood Gang 0

    This review was originally posted on my website Imagination Centre (here).This has been a series that I've enjoying since it first started, and this Zero Year storyline has been simply amazing so far. I have enjoyed how it's managed to give an unique origin for the Dark Knight, also giving exciting and entertaining events along the way.PlotAfter Bruce Wayne reveals himself to still be alive, Batman faces off against the Red Hood Gang once again.ReviewThis was an amazing issue, and quite possibly...

    9 out of 9 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.