johnkmccubbin91's Batman #23 - Zero Year: Secret City, Part Three; The Pit review

Becoming the Bat

This has been one of my favourite series, and with it featuring my favourite character it makes things even better. Besides that the current Zero Year story has also been very exciting, and unique, and it looks to be getting better, and better.

Plot

At the mercy of the Red Hood Gang, Bruce Wayne takes a horrible beating. Meanwhile Philip Kane, and Edward Nigma don't see eye to eye.

The Pit

Near Norway a 24 year old Bruce is involved in a death match to learn him that sometimes during war you have to kill.

Review

This was a brilliant issue, and the story keeps continuing to amaze me, but this issue wasn't quite as spectacular as the previous two. Scott Snyder does however do a brilliant job of developing this story, keeping the excitement, and drama at a high. Snyder also added plenty of suspense in this issue, as well as some brilliant emotion. I did however feel that there wasn't a lot happening in this issue, as although everything was so dramatic, it all happened rather fast. The dialogue during this issue was also brilliant, with the interactions being very intense, and exciting. I also loved the dark tone that Snyder added to this issue, as with it being an origin story for Batman it needs to have plenty of darkness about it.

The art was simply outstanding, and although when I was initially not a fan of Greg Capullo's art when this series started, it has really suited it, as although he's not the best Batman artist ever, he knows how to add the right tone to the series, whether dark, or light. The detail in Capullo's art is also spectacular, and it's very hard to find any imperfections in it. The layout of Capullo's art also adds plenty of depth, and drama to the issue, as although this isn't the most impressive layout he's done yet, it does it's purpose, adding brilliant tone to the issue. I also liked how he drew the beaten up Bruce, as although I was initially in two minds whether I liked it or not, I came to the conclusion that it was relatively realistic.

This issue would start with the Red Hood Gang beating Bruce to a pulp, with this continuing for about a third of the issue. This was a very exciting sequence, also adding a lot of tone, and suspense to the issue. With Bruce having little chance to do anything in this sequence, it was paramount to add a brilliant atmosphere, and Snyder did this perfectly, as the Red Hood Gang leader had a tremendous presence, with the dialogue that he'd say to Bruce adding a lot of depth, as well as more tone to this amazing sequence.

The other interesting sequence in this issue was a conversation between Philip Kane, and Edward Nigma. Now I won't go into too much detail about this sequence, as to avoid spoilers, but I will say my thoughts, as well as the fact that they had a disagreement. Now I've loved seeing Nigma, better known to Batman fans as the Riddler in this story, as with him being one of my favourite villains I'm happy to see him involved properly in a New 52 story. This sequence itself was however very dramatic, and suspenseful, with the dialogue once again being amazing, and I look forward to seeing how it's developed.

The back-up story would once again be written by Snyder, and James Tynion IV, and drawn by Rafael Albuquerque. This short story didn't really amaze me, as although I've been loving the concept of a younger Bruce in these back-up stories, with this having plenty of action, it didn't do much for me. I did however love Albuquerque's art, as although not quite as good as his previous two additions, it was very gritty, and dark, suiting this story perfectly.

Final Verdict

This was a tremendous issue, and although it's the worst in the story so far, it was still amazing, and shows just how good this story has been. The suspense, and drama throughout the story was outstanding, with exciting dialogue. The back-up story was however nothing special, and along with the fact that the everything happened so fast in the main story let the issue down a bit. I would however still highly recommend this issue, as well as the story so far, as it's been very unique, and interesting.

Rating: 4/5

4 Comments
Posted by broo1232

Funny I think this was my favourite issue of the series. I know it slowed down a bit which bugged me a bit, but the Riddler bit was awesome. Yet I think the big moment at the end was fantastic I just loved how it was the same scene, but cleverly done differently, and Capullo's art was just at it's best in that scene. Great review anyway, another fantastic review.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

To be honest most of it was excellent, and it felt like the best issue in the story so far, but it just had not quite enough happening in it, with everything seeming to happen very fast, which let it down a bit. I so desperately wanted to give it a 5, but couldn't quite (also felt that I was a bit generous with the previous two issues as well so wanted to make this one fair). I also loved the Riddler in this, and he's shaping up to be the villain he should be.

Posted by broo1232

@johnkmccubbin91: I would give it a 4, but I think it was the best written, but like you said not a lot happened, but what happened was really good, and I loved the Red Hood gang in this issue even though it was a little long winded, but I suppose it made you understand the motivation of the Red Hood leader. The Riddler bit was really interesting, but I think overall this issue had a lot going on until just about the end where it went into the Year one moment.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

Other reviews for Batman #23 - Zero Year: Secret City, Part Three; The Pit

    And so, Batman is born! 0

    Bruce is failing his city, but he might have found the motivation he needs to carry on the promise he made his parents. The GoodThe zero year story of Batman's beginnings has been interesting. Yes, we've seen Batman's story told over-and-over again hundreds of times in past years, but seeing Batman really begin is always a trip no matter what! We get new writers to work on Batman's beginning every time and they always bring there own touch of what might've happened during the change from Bruce W...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    Dip in an otherwise great run for the S&C duo. 0

    This story arc seems to moving a long very awkwardly and can't seem to find a steady pace. A lot of the intended big moments/reveals really do not satisfy or leave you think "that was awesome". As for the art, as a fan of Capullo, it is underwhelming and is not redeeming of the slow story. This arc has not been one of those ones where you feel you won't be able to wait till the following month to see what happens next, this issue in particular has been the weakest in the series. Still have Faith...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.