johnkmccubbin91's Batman #23.1 - Time to Monkey Shine review

The Jokes on Us

Villains Month is here, and everyone will have their favourite villain that they are looking forward to reading. Mine personally is this man, the Joker, and although I was sceptical about Andy Kubert becoming a writer, I had a lot of hope that he would do a good job. So did he?

Plot

Following his troubled childhood Joker takes a gorilla from a zoo, and helps it to become his sidekick, Jackanapes.

Review

This has to be one of the worst comic book issues that I have read in a long time, and it's such a shame as I was really hoping for something brilliant here. Andy Kubert doesn't do a terrible job of writing this issue, as to be honest it's a fun story, and I liked how he was going for a fun Joker story. I did however feel that it didn't suit the Joker, and the story in itself felt too silly, as although I was hoping for something much darker, this goes to far in the opposite direction. I did however get the feeling that Kubet understood Joker, but at the same time he didn't appear to be able to execute that into a brilliant story, and if this is a sign of what he'll be like as a writer he should stay as the amazing artist he is.

The best part about this issue was the art, and Andy Clarke did a phenomenal job. It would have been nice to see Kubert himself on art, as I love when artists who turn to writing do their own artwork. Clarke however is a much better artist, and I'm glad he worked on this issue, as it makes it almost worth the purchase. The detail in his artwork is simply outstanding, and I really enjoyed how he managed to show Joker's expressions throughout the issue, as although some of them aren't what I'd expect from the Joker, they had to follow the story, which needed this. I also loved the layout as it really helped give tone to this story. Blond's colours were also amazing, helping to add tone, and vibrancy to the issue.

Kubert took an extremely risky move at the start of this issue by showing Joker's childhood, and it didn't pay off. Now I understand that with Joker you can put him in nearly any kind of situation, as he's that unpredictable. There is also the fact that his origin is that mysterious that even if you told it there would be the question whether it's real or not, as although this comes from Joker himself, does Joker really remember? Besides this it didn't do much for me, as although it showed symbolism of his character, and how he's possibly been shaped, also helping lead into this story, it just didn't feel right for the Joker, and after this I'm happy that it's questionable about what's real or not with Joker's past.

This wasn't entirely centred around his childhood, as it'd quickly jump forward in time to Joker, and his gang at the zoo, with it apparently being the reason for the flashback. During this sequence I found Joker's expressions to be rather odd, as it didn't seem like the Joker, even if he was being serious. I did however find his gang interesting, as although they weren't spectacular, being far from a Harley Quinn, they added some humour to the issue. I especially loved seeing Max Roboto again, as given his limited history it was nice to see him added.

The main centre of this issue would be Joker bringing up a gorilla from a baby to an adult, calling it Jackanapes. Now those keen Batman fans will already have spotted that Jackanapes is already an existing character, being a foe of Damian Wayne during the possible future that was shown in Batman #666. Now the tie to this title is the only thing I liked about Jackanapes in this issue, as along with Max Roboto this shows that Kubert may be leaving some teasers for his upcoming Damian: Son of Batman limited series, which is set in that possible future.

Final Verdict

This may appeal to some people, but it certainly didn't to me, being too ridiculous. It also felt very rushed, and didn't have a lot of character interaction. It was however fun to a certain point, and showed that Andy Kubert understood the character, but at the same time also showed that he couldn't execute it into a decent story. Due to all this I wouldn't recommend this, as it's not worth the gamble to see if it's for you.

Rating: 1/5

18 Comments
Posted by DecoyElite

Good review, I think this issue could have worked if it had been even more silly overall and then played that for contrast with a darker ending.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@decoyelite: Thanks very much. Yeah that would have worked, as it's not that I don't like a silly Joker (he was silly in the 90's Animated series which was amazing). I just felt that Joker went to a totally different extreme than usual in this issue, and it made it appear that Joker had feelings, which wasn't right.

Edited by Battle_Forum_Junkie

@johnkmccubbin91: Very good review. I went into the comic shop planning not to pick it because I kept on hearing people put it down, but when I saw it on the shelf my bat-fanism got the better of me and I picked up. The cover was amazing, but sadly the contents didn't wow me as much the cover did. I enjoyed seeing the silly Joker back, but, like you said, I felt it wasn't executed properly. I don't regret picking it up because I know that I would regret not picking it up, just on the off chance that it wasn't as bad as people were saying.

But, it still could have been allot better.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@battle_forum_junkie: Thanks very much. Yeah I myself would have probably regretted not trying it myself being the huge Batman, and Joker fan that I am, but it didn't take away from how poor it was. Also if you enjoyed my review would you mind recommending it?

Posted by Battle_Forum_Junkie
Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Edited by sinestro_GL

I also hated this issue...but as you said, I also had a feeling that the writer did in fact understand the Joker, but man...did this comic backfire!

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@sinestro_gl: Thanks for recommending this review, and I couldn't agree more with you.

Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k

@johnkmccubbin91:

Kubert will get better, I`m sure.

Funny thing is...though you portrayed this negatively, I got interested...

Also, funny. Batman is tied down in every one (?) of his series issues this month.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: I have no doubt, as he showed that he has skill with this story, it's just that he didn't quite know how to execute it properly, trying to do a Joker story whilst teasing the upcoming Damian series (bit too much at once).

That's odd, but if you liked that I'm happy, I try to be as positive as possible, though sometimes it's not easy. I also try not to moan too much to keep people interested in the review.

I've noticed that, some people have mentioned it wondering if he's going to be in any. I think it's more for effect really.

Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k

@johnkmccubbin91:

I`ll probably check out the Bat-Damian-man series too, because I woulda liked to see an ongoing of him as the Batman.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: I'm getting it as I liked the character and was upset when he died. Also liked the future idea. This one however is only a four issue mini, but an ongoing would be interesting.

Posted by kfhrfdu_89_76k

@johnkmccubbin91:

I knows it`s a mini, sugah!

Uh...

Yeah, I became a black woman for a moment, there...

Posted by TheCannon

Good review. I hated this issue and find it one of the worst comics I've ever read.

Edited by Deranged Midget

I enjoyed the issue. I don't think it was noteworthy or anything but it wasn't exactly bad in my opinion.

Good review though!

Moderator
Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@kfhrfdu_89_76k: Lol, just making sure : )

@thecannon: Thanks. Yes it was really bad, though I did see signs of a good writer in Kubert, just a bit ambitious for his first attempt.

@deranged_midget: Thanks. I personally felt it was a little too silly, but that's just me.

Posted by flazam

Great Review

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@flazam: Thanks. Would you mind recommending the review?

Other reviews for Batman #23.1 - Time to Monkey Shine

    Monkey Business 0

    Just like we all have our favorite heroes, we have our favorite villains. Usually, what attracts us in a hero is what they stand for. What they do that goes above and beyond, the example they set. They make us want to not only be them, but they makes us want to be better people in our day to day lives. Villains, good villains, have the opposite effect. A good villain, you despise them. You enjoy seeing your hero overcome the tremendous obstacles that the villain puts in front of them, and...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.