batwatch's Batman #18 - Resolve review

Batman #18

Resolve

Snyder (former writer for Detective Comics and current writer of Batman, Talon, American Vampire, and Swamp Thing) promises an issue focused on Harper Row, the girl without any apparent role in the DC Universe. Apparently, she will somehow discover Batman's loss of Robin or at bare minimum witness the fallout from the event. Harper appeared to be taking an unhealthy fascination with Batman in Batman #12, so perhaps she has spent all her time since then obsessing over The Dark Knight and she will discover Bruce's identity and need for a Robin in the same fashion as Tim Drake did in A Lonely Place of Dying. Harper has long been rumored to be the new Girl Wonder, so could this be the beginning of the road that leads to Harper donning the yellow cape and domino mask? Only time will tell, but for the moment, another question is at hand. Does Batman #18 deliver a poignant tale of loss for the caped crusader and character development for the mysterious Harper,or is this a forced crossover that fits poorly into Snyder's regular storytelling?

To see this review with images, Click Here.

In this issue, Harper stalks Batman and watches as he becomes increasingly aggressive and self-destructive.

Harper Row Is Officially the New Tim Drake

Why does Tim Drake not act like Tim Drake? Because Harper has stolen his role in the DC Universe.

I am pretty sure I would have loved this issue if I had never read “A Lonely Place of Dying,” the plotline that introduced Tim Drake to the world back in 1989. There is nothing wrong with this story; in fact, it is quite well told with great art, excellent dialogue, and a good flow, but I'll be darned if every single page did not feel exactly like the classic eighties story. There are certainly differences between Tim's origin and Harper's origin, but the similarities just left a bad taste in my mouth.

Harper has not discovered Bruce's identity as of yet, but she most definitely has the same fanboy type admiration for him which made Tim such an easy character of love. Like Tim, Harper has natural computer and technical knowhow. Also like Tim, she has been physically training herself for battle. She approaches Bruce right after he lost a beloved if rebellious son/Robin. She instinctually realizes that Batman needs someone to bring light to his darkness. It is all so very familiar.

This typifies one of my largest complaints about the entire New 52; nothing is really new. DC claims that they are ditching all their old history in an attempt to move forward and tell new and exciting stories unrestrained by past continuity, yet when left to write these “new” stories, writers inevitably end up rehashing the same old plot lines from past years with slight variations. This is not new but redux.

I'm Cool with Harper

Harper will clearly have some role as a protege of the Bat, and though Harper's origin feels completely derivative, I think Harper as a character has a lot of potential. I know many people took issue with Harper-centric issue #12, but I find her to be a very likable character who hits a niche not really being filled by other characters. Like Jason, she has the rough upbringing aspect. Like Harold, she has tech savvy. (her wireless release for her rope is ingenious) Like Stephanie, she has a criminal father. I could go on, but you get the idea. Harper has a mix of a lot of characteristics we have seen in various members of the Bat Family over the years, but it is a rather unique blend which is not really present in Bruce's life at the moment.

Perhaps the most unique aspect of her personality is the way she talks to Bruce. She has a mix of defiance, frankness, earnestness, and respect which I am not sure we have ever seen. She seems to have a way to get past Bruce's emotional walls, cut through his bullcrap intimidation techniques, and really talk to him, and if that is something she can pull of consistently, that would be a truly new take for a Bat protege. In the DCNU, Nightwing has demonstrated an attitude towards Bruce which is somewhat similar, but that came through years and years of being partners, yet Harper manages to bust through Bruce's bullcrap in a few conversations. That is quite a feat.

Requiem

Does this issue give a proper memorial to Damian? I suppose you could make a case either way. It all depends on what you want from the arc.

As promised, the story is from the eyes of Harper, so Damian is never really discussed or openly mourned in this issue. Do not expect any touching Damian flashbacks or tearful remembrances. However, Harper and Batman do eventually have a heart to heart, and in that conversation, Bruce's pain is very obvious. Similarly, Bruce's self-destructive actions make his heartache rather clear.

Speaking of Bruce's self-destruction, I did like the way that was handled. Yes, it was very, very reminiscent of A Lonely Place of Dying, but it also showed some character development. Whereas Bruce spent months in a rage over the loss of Jason, Bruce only spent a week truly going nuts after the death of Damian. Bruce did not completely shut people out even in the midst of his pain, and again, I think that indicates some growth on Batman's part.

It definitely appears that Harper will become the new Robin, and this issue sets up for her to be a future warrior of the Bat, so in that sense, I can see how some might feel that Harper is trampling all over Damian's grave, but I figure that most people who were big Damian fans want to know how the legacy of Robin will continue, so I do not think many who are buying this issue for the Requiem crossover will be disappointed.

Fill In Artists

Greg Capullo (former penciler for Image's Spawn and current cover artist for Batman) took this month off of Batman, so there were two fill in artists for this month. Andy Kubert (former artist for Batman and X-Men and current penciler for Batman and cover artist for Green Lantern Corps) did the first half and Alex Maleev (former artist for Daredevil and current artist of Batman) did the second, and both halves looked great. I do not really have any complaints about either artist. Kubert is a bit more exaggerated and has a smoother look to his work while Maleev's characters are a bit more realistic (except for a certain dog and owner who had an excuse to look unrealistic) and gritty, but if you put a gun to my head and made me choose, I would say Kubert is my preferred artist, but both of them bring a great look to the series.

Bat Droppings

1. All the covers for this issue look great.

2. I'm not sure what I think of this portrayal of Blackgate, but I am leaning towards liking it.

3. I have no doubt that we will be seeing Harper's dad again.

4. I would really like to know what is going on in the submarine scene. Is that a Bat mallet?

5. The short bit about the dog fights was really interesting, and I would like to see this expanded though I am not sure it would be substantive enough to sustain an arc.

6. Unless Harper gets a full face mask, (could she be the future Batwing perhaps?) she is going to be very easy to identify between her blue hair and noes ring.

7. I get that Harper's plan for sending a message to Batman was cool and lead to neat symbolism, but couldn't she have just passed him a note?

Conclusion 8/10

I hate to give this story such a low rating because it does not deserve it on its own merits, but I cannot help but feel that it is too derivative of “A Lonely Place of Dying,” and that really bugs me. If you are not attached to the old plot line, this is a definite purchase for any Batman fan, but for older fans like me, go in with more moderate expectations.

For more news, reviews, and commentary for the entire Bat Family, check out BatWatch.net.

More Recent Reviews:

Batman #18

Batman and Robin #18

Batwing #18

Legends of the Dark Knight #39-40

3 Comments
Posted by akbogert

I gave it a 9 (well, 4.5 out of 5) but I really quite appreciate how well we agree on this issue. Frankly, as a completely new Batman reader (the only pre-New 52 story I've read is The Killing Joke), without the déja vu, I was 100% on board with everything here. I think this is the ideal way of doing a reboot -- taking something that worked in the past and reskinning it, updating it a bit. Having an alternative girl instead of another guy, but keeping the feel of the new Robin story that worked so well before? Seems perfect; fans can appreciate the homage, and new readers won't know it's been done before.

I understand people being upset with what's happened to characters like Tim. And I also understand folks who loved Damian wanting a longer period between his death and his replacement's arrival (even though it's not like Harper was just introduced -- she's been in the wings for a very long time). I just don't like how nasty folks are being about Harper, as if she was to blame for any of this. If the best arguments against her are that her origin story is too similar to a (retconned via reboot) different character's great origin story, and that people liked another character who is dead, then I'd say she's doing pretty well. Few people (though some do exist) dislike Harper just because they dislike Harper.

Posted by BatWatch

I can't speak for old fans, but it did not feel like an homage so much as a theft and desecration for me. I am a huge pre-Flashpoint Tim Drake fan, so the way they used part of his story here while completely screwing him up in the DCNU was a double whammy of fanboy rage for me (grins) but whatever. I wish Snyder had found a way to give Harper an origin as original as her character. I guess, to be fair, it is not really her actions which are so similar. Rather, it is the themes which echo A Lonely Place of Dying nearly perfectly.

I agree on Harper getting a bum rap. People did not like her back in Batman #12 either, and I didn't understand it at that point any more than I do now. I think she is a very interesting character, and I look forward to seeing what Snyder does with her. By the way, Snyder has said she will not, or at least is not meant to be, the new Robin. You can find that article Here.

Posted by wessaari

I have never read a Lonely Place of Dying, but that arc has been mentioned whenever I hear Tim's name. I knew his backstory but never knew what it was called. It really does either pay homage to that or try to immitate the same grief and depression Bruce was in after Jason died. Alot of people are now saying that Damian is now the new Jason, the arrogant brash boy who was killed in the heat of battle. Now i find that completely ridiculous because their stories and histories stand for themselves but with this story I wouldnt blame anyone for trying to make that similarity. What I am really worried is that Harper will fill in Steph's shoes but I still feel she has a a chance in the new 52. You have made several strong points on your site, and I would agree to that if only DC weren't so hush hush on Brown's whereabouts. Personally, I would make a Red Robin title to introduce her in, slowly mysteriously but surely she would come back, but a writer's dream will sometimes remain a dream, :P

Other reviews for Batman #18 - Resolve

    Has Batman Snapped? 0

    This has been my favourite series in the New 52, and although it's not always been outstanding, it's always been good. With Batman being my favourite character I expect good stories from the main Batman title, and Scott Snyder's been doing that, and I'm looking forward to seeing what he can do now that Death of the Family is over, and Year Zero's about to begin.PlotHarper Row is worried about Batman, as he doesn't seem to be acting normally, so she tries to help him out.ReviewAlthough not as goo...

    13 out of 13 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.