Batgirl # 1 - Point of New Origin

is a comic book published by DC Comics & released on 10 / / 2009

User Rating - 28 votes, 3.8 avg.

Plot Summary

In the wake of "Batman R.I.P." and BATTLE FOR THE COWL, a new heroine has emerged in Gotham City, and as she begins her nocturnal crusade to take back the night, she will truly learn what it means to wear the mantle of the Bat. But who is this young woman, and why has she donned the cape and cowl?

Creators

Add a creator credit to this issue
  •  

  • Cully Hamner
    cover


  • Guy Major
    colorer

  •  
    John J. Hill
    letterer

  • Lee Garbett
    penciler


  •  

  • Phil Noto
    cover


  •  
    Trevor Scott
    inker


  • Characters


    Teams

    Add a team credit to this issue

    Locations

    Add a location credit to this issue

    Concepts

    Add a concept credit to this issue
    We don't have any concepts attached to this issue. Help us fill it in!

    Objects

    Add an object credit to this issue
    We don't have any objects attached to this issue. Help us fill it in!

    Story Arc

    Add a story arc credit to this issue

    User Reviews
    Here's to the loss of racial diversity
    Reviewed by Woerlan on Aug. 20, 2009.
    Woerlan has written 7 reviews. His/her last review was for Point of New Origin.
    1 out of 1 users recommend his reviews.

    1 out of 1 user found this review helpful.
    Spoiler warning. 
     
    And not the kind that you think. This is the issue where, after months of teasing, the new Batgirl is revealed to be Stephanie Brown. 
     
    Personally, I have mixed feelings about this issue, and none of them stem from the writing. The book does well in depicting Steph's struggles with maintaining a normal life as a college freshman, versus taking up the heavy mantle of the Batgirl. And it's a struggle where she expectedly makes errors in her effort to the role that fell into her hands.
     
    All well and good. It will be interesting to see how far her commitment to the cowl takes her, especially with the suggested tutelage of Barbara Gordon forthcoming. I have great hopes for her, believing as I still do that she would have made a great Robin.
     
    The issue I have about the book is likely shared by many fans. See, I'm a Cassandra Cain fan. It's difficult not to be a fan if you've read her story all the way back from No Man's Land till right before DC editorial violated her in One Year Later. Cass grew into the role wonderfully, rising as she did from one of the worst backgrounds imaginable. It appealed to me that she was antithetical to the rest of the Bat family in so many ways. She was taught to be an assassin, not a hero. Unlike Bruce, Dick and Tim, both her natural parents are alive, but both are villainous. While the rest of the Bat family struggle to keep from descending into darkness, Cass would struggle to emerge from darkness into light. It also appealed to me that she was distinctly Asian. I liked how an iconic role like Batgirl could be given to a person who wasn't blonde, blue-eyed and white.
     
    While the way she made her exit in this book in no way matched the horrors of her OYL story arc, it still left a sour taste in my mouth, and an unfulfilled longing to know what would happen to her. It was so unexpected, and too mysterious, as if the writer or DC editors had not yet decided what to do with her. Never mind that her reason for leaving went against what she said was her motivation in her original series. (FYI, she served the symbol and the crusade behind it, NOT the Batman). Never mind that the best way to honor the man who would have been her new father would be to fight on as Batgirl. At the very least, the fans of this badly-treated character deserve to know that their heroine will stay such, and will remain in the realm of the Bat.



    Nice Try
    Reviewed by ENGLENTINE on Sept. 17, 2009.
    ENGLENTINE has written 583 reviews. His/her last review was for SUICIDE KINGS,” PART 3: DEAD MAN'S HAND .
    16 out of 17 users recommend his reviews.

      I wanted to like this book a bit more than I did.  While there was not much hereto keep me coming back, there were some things good enough to mention. My favorite thing would have to be the way Stephanie deals wth the dual lives. I could actually get into the book more if that continues to be the focus of the story. 
     Unfortunately, as it happens with all books that start that way, I have no faith it will stay that way. The rest of the book was just ... void. There were words and pictures, but it really did nothing for me. Here is hoping that issue two picks up. I just don't know if i want tostick around and find out myself.




    I'm kinds sick of DC and Marvel writing so many female characters obsessed with the way they look. I'm betting that the writer of this book Bryan Miller hasn't spent a whole lot of time with the opposite sex, because "Batgirl" is something strait out of a stereo-type textbook.
    Batgirl's story and dialogue seem kinda shallow. Theres not really anything to like in this book aside from the name and the costume. And those two things can never carry a book on their own. 



    See all issues Next Issue »
    Url:
    HTML:
    BBCode:
    Added by: Exile-616
    Date Added: Aug. 18, 2009
    Url:
    HTML:
    BBCode:
    Added by: Exile-616
    Date Added: Aug. 19, 2009


    Exile-616
    50 points

    jloneblackheart
    21 points

    XION66578
    2 points

    comicvine
    1 point

    Psychotime
    1 point


    You are in Edit Mode. Make sure to save your work at the end!!
    • Submissions can take 24 hours to be moderated.
    • Please leave a comment to explain why you're making this change.
    Save Changes Cancel