quintus_knightfall's Batgirl #3 - Point of New Origin: Part 3 review

Batgirl #3 Is this Buffy or Batgirl?

So I picked up Batgirl #3 today despite being one of the biggest Stephine Brown haters on this site. At this point I'm only reading it in hopes of catching a guest appearance by Cassandra Cain. From the start of the series it was easy to see what direction  Bryan Q Miller would be taking the book and to be honest, its the exact same thing the t.v. series Buffy the Vampire Slayer did. A teenage girl dealing with the pressures of school, home, and family, while at the same time secretly fighting crime and hoping not to get caught by mother. Maybe I'm just to old for the new direction Batgirl has taken. Frat parties, secret crushes, getting grounded, and crying about an ex boyfriend are things I'd expect to see in a Spiderman comic, not my Batgirl comics. Now remember, this is just my point of view. I'm sure lots of readers can easily relate to the vulnerability of Steph. She's constantly searching for her place and it gives the reader a glimpse at a hero who doesn't always have the answers and lacks the self confidence of an established crime fighter. Her insecurities make her more human then the other characters we usually see wearing the Bat suits.
 

 Cassandra's belt
Right at the start of the issue we see Steph getting ready to infiltrate "Devil's Square" after members of Scarecrows crew attacked Steph's first campus party (again with the collage thing. We get it, you're in school) using a new drug cocktail named "Thrill." We also get to see part of the reason why Steph has such low self-esteem. Barbra Gordon still seems reluctant to acknowledge Steph as Batgirl even going so far as to refer to Steph's utility belt as Cassandra's (I loved that part). Now even though I hate on Steph, this issue does provide us with the first real fight Steph has with a legitimate Rogue of Batman's. How does she fair? Well I wont give it all away but I did have to smile a couple times.
 Ouch

 
 
I will admit Steph is a fighter. Not so much skill wise but emotionally. She refuses to quit or be told she's not good enough which is admirable. The only problem is, sometimes when people tell you you're not good enough........they're right. But it seems in this case Steph has won over at least one person. By the end of the issue we see where, and by whom, the new Batgirl suit comes from. Which is good for Steph as she no longer has to run around in Cassandra's hand me downs. She's got her own look now and one of the greatest minds in the DCU backing her up. Time will tell if she'll be able to replace the last two Batgirls.
 New suit
 

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
This is just my own theory here, but I think Calculator's daughter, Wendy Harris,  will end up being Batgirl at some point. She keeps showing up with the most random appearances not to have an important role to play. Keep an eye on her.
 
 Interesting
4 Comments
Posted by Quaid Kirchner

I hope Stephanie's fighting skills improve, because she has a lot of work to do and I hope Cassandra reappears again.
 
Thanks for the great review I just red my copy!

Posted by SilverZeo

Is her secret identity ruin, or is it still a secret do to the "Glasses" rule of DC?

Posted by kimi74

I agree with pretty much everything you have written. While not knowing a lot about Stephanie Brown's character I have never warmed to any storyline I've read with her in it. Most of the storylines I've read make her out to be a 'wannabe' and not a real contender. I've read the first 3 issues and want this to work so much but I can't see myself sticking with this for much longer. I'll keep going for a few more but I really hope the character develops a lot more, and in unexpected ways.  
 
A lot of potential...
Posted by Journey Into Chaos

cool story @Gambler

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.