starkiller809's Batgirl #19 - A Blade From the Shadows review

Batgirl #19

The Good

Daniel Sampere's art is good. His style is very clear and it makes each panel very simple. The expressions are fairly strong and convey emotion like they should. Sampere also adds a lot of details into the background that really makes the world come alive.The use of shadow in some panels is well done and really shows how dark Gotham is, compared to the brightness of the apartment Babs shares with Alysia. This issue marks the return of Gail Simone, who was fired and unfired. She had to continue on the work that Ray Fawkes had started and she managed to end the story satisfyingly. We get a little bit into the motive of James Jr. and we get to see a little of Barbra and James time as children and it's nice to see then as children. The end of this issue also should affect Babs quite a bit. I'll just say that this is one of the comics where the cover, doesn't lie.

The Bad

Daniel Sampere's art is good, but it's not memorable. The panels just feel a little bland and overly simple. Gail Simone's return was very mixed. It wasn't the best issue of the series, and it wasn't the worst. The reveals in this issue weren't great and leaves the reader wanting more, and not in the good way. James Jr. motive was extremely weak and his plan, or lack of one, makes the character we were lead to believe was super smart (and portrayed that way in the brilliant Black Mirror) feel stupid. James Gordon also makes me mad in this issue and his appearance is a little cliche.

The Verdict: 3/5 (Okay)

Gail Simone did what she could and she defiantly got attention with the reveal of Alysia (Which was well done). If you are looking for a goo Batgirl story, come back next month were Simone will be able to start off a new story without have to be fired for no reason. This issue was good, but I don't think that it will hook any new readers. I suggest that you just wait for the next issue that will no doubt, be fantastic.


Other reviews for Batgirl #19 - A Blade From the Shadows

    As good as it could have been 0

    Pros: Gail Simone started a fascinating arc with a great villain, it had some bumpy parts but I think she did a nice job of ending it with tragedy and some mystery. We all know James Jr. wont stay gone, and that Barbara isn't a killer. However, the animosity between her father and her will be interesting to see how it is dealt with.Cons: Unfortunately with the two issues Gail was gone this story line stumbled, who knows where it was intended to go and for how long. I felt like it was wrapped...

    5 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.