pathtales's Batgirl #17 - Endure the Flame review

    Avatar image for pathtales

    No rest from the wicked

    What went down

    There is never any rest for the wicked thus leaving no time for the heroes to rest either. Running on "coffee and will power," Barbra refuses to rest until this mess by the Joker and her brother are cleaned up. Commentary done from the point of view from her brother reveals she's been taking 20 minute power naps in-between going through the police data base and looking for all of the Joker's followers and alerting the police of who they are. We then see a side of her we rarely see; her out and just taking a break. Seeing the human side of her after the intense story arc and seeing her interact with normal people, well as normal as they get in Gotham, as simply Barbra. However the light fluff can not last as we see her mother, who in Batgirl #16 was kidnapped by the Joker who cut her finger off. Her son, James, then shows up dressed as a doctor, who is very cryptic about his plan. Then the comic flips to the police station where they are trying to track down the Joker's followers and Commissioner Grodon's son. Then the action starts where Barbra is trying to track him down as well, but in the process a new villain Firebug shows up.

    The Good

    The aftermath of Death of the Family and how this has affected the characters is nice to see. It gives it a nice clean wrap up while also setting up the next story. Excellent writing, artwork, line art, coloring, all very well done. I liked seeing the dynamics of the Gordon family while also getting a glimpse of the next story arc for Batgirl.

    The Bad

    The comic itself was a bit rushed. Also the introduction of Firebug felt a bit unnatural and forced. Other than that, not much negative about this part.

    The Ugly (Conclusion)

    Over all I'm rather excited to see what James is planning, even if I'm not so pumped by this fight with Firebug. Gotham really needs a break.

    Other reviews for Batgirl #17 - Endure the Flame

      Brothers and Sisters 0

      This is a series I've really been enjoying as of late and like a lot of people I was upset to hear that series writer Gail Simone had been fired from the series. Luckily it was announced that DC had given her job back, but this has effected the series leaving it with a different writer for this issue, and the next, with Simone returning on issue 19.PlotThis issue sees Batgirl (Barbara Gordon) dealing with life after her encounter with the Joker in Death of the Family, whilst she has family probl...

      10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

      Batgirl #17 0

      Endure the FlameI'm surprised to find that after building up his appearance for approximately forever, Gail Simone handed off Barbara's confrontation with James Jr. to Ray Fawkes. I know that there was the whole firing/rehiring thing, but if Simone could get herself unfired, surely she could secure the story about James Jr., so this strikes me as odd. Also, James Jr. had a rather odd role in Death of the Family. I could buy into the idea that perhaps James had been keeping tabs on his mom and th...

      7 out of 7 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.