I only saw the clip where they say "well yea so what we have a hulk!" or something like it

So on a scale of one to ten how was it (please no other details or spoilers)

1 =AHHHHH! It's horrible (tears out own eyes)

2 =Ahhhhhhh It's really bad (tears out directors producers actors hearts)

3 =O my God i want a apology & my money back right now,( I'd recommend it to some one i don't like)

4 =Pretty bad not worth watching really (I'd bring a date to it so we could make out instead)

5 = Meh not bothered one way or the other ( it's probably better when drunk)

6 = one or two good bits, not that bad a C +

7 = a few good bits could be better, characters could of done with better actors

8 = That was a good film good casting good script I'd recommend it to a friend

9 = A modern classic, it brought the characters to life REALLY BRILLIANT (gotta go watch it again immediately)

10 = WOW!!!!!!! i mean WOW!! that was just WOW!! that movie changed me I mean it was WOW! (Mind Explodes)

• easily a 9
• arguably a 10
• Best comic book movie so far

• easily a 9
• arguably a 10
• Best comic book movie so far

@cattlebattle said:

@spiderbat87 said:

@Greendevil said:

• easily a 9
• arguably a 10
• Best comic book movie so far

pretty much this

Just curious as to why people hold this much movie in such high regard. I mean, it was a great, entertaining movie, but I definitely wouldn't put it at "the best comic movie" standard. I have seen better I actually thought some of the movie was a bit corny

I agree with you. A 10 is the dark knight a 9 is Batman Begins, 8.5 would be an Iron Man and a 7 would be Captain America and Thor, imo. I gave this a 6, a bit cheesy, and uninspired at times but very entertaining.

@nandizzle said:

@cattlebattle said:

@spiderbat87 said:

@Greendevil said:

• easily a 9
• arguably a 10
• Best comic book movie so far

pretty much this

Just curious as to why people hold this much movie in such high regard. I mean, it was a great, entertaining movie, but I definitely wouldn't put it at "the best comic movie" standard. I have seen better I actually thought some of the movie was a bit corny

I agree with you. A 10 is the dark knight a 9 is Batman Begins, 8.5 would be an Iron Man and a 7 would be Captain America and Thor, imo. I gave this a 6, a bit cheesy, and uninspired at times but very entertaining.

The Batman movies where awesome. But in a different, darker way. Imo Avengers was much more entertaining. Having Stark, Banner, Rogers and Thor together was priceless for me. Loke was awesome. Imo this was 1-2 levels above Batman movies in every way......imo

@Hysteria said:

Is the movie any good? I'll let Daniel Bryan answer that (Wrestling reference)

Yes ! Yes ! Yes !

9

8/9 he did it, Joss Whedon did it. It's not a dark knight, thats a different type of movie. It is pretty damned good

@Greendevil: Basically if you love mindless action movies ala Transformers 3 than you'll love the avengers. If you appreciate great storytelling, filmography, etc... you'll like the bat movies.

@nandizzle:

Basically you sound like a 14 year old fan boy.....Also, i haven't seen Transformers 3.

The movies are to different to be compared Imo. Tony Starks lines in the Avengers > Bruce Wayne making his voice darker

Both are great movies, i just think Avengers was better.

@Greendevil: Shut up you little hotard, only little fan boys can appreciate something as storyless as the Avengers.

It was amazing, for that sort of film. In terms of a Marvel Studios movie, it's just about as good as you could possibly want.  
 
 
That said, it doesn't hold a candle to films like Batman Begins, the Dark Knight, Sin City or Watchmen. 

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

That said, it doesn't hold a candle to films like Batman Begins, the Dark Knight, Sin City or Watchmen.

I think I'm starting to see a trend in your posts........that said, you obviously haven't seen it in 3-D, so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

That said, it doesn't hold a candle to films like Batman Begins, the Dark Knight, Sin City or Watchmen.

I think I'm starting to see a trend in your posts........that said, you obviously haven't seen it in 3-D, so I'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

And 3-D is for simpletons.

And you are, who, to say this?

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

And 3-D is for simpletons.

And you are, who, to say this?

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

Someone who actually understands the film medium.

Because of what? You don't enjoy a visually appealing form of entertainment?

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

Someone who actually understands the film medium.

Because of what? You don't enjoy a visually appealing form of entertainment?

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

The movies I listed were better films than Avengers. Whether they were more enjoyable is up to the viewer, but they were better films.

That really depends on personal preference. Using that same rationale, it's like saying you're an idiot for choosing to read a comic book over a proper novel.

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

The movies I listed were better films than Avengers. Whether they were more enjoyable is up to the viewer, but they were better films.

That really depends on personal preference. Using that same rationale, it's like saying you're an idiot for choosing to read a comic book over a proper novel.

@FadeToBlackBolt said:

No it's not, because a novel can be just as terrible as a comic, and a comic can be just as great as a novel. They're an entirely different medium for one thing. By your "logic", you just compared film to radio.

They're not entirely different mediums......both comics and novels require you to read and make an interpretation for yourself, comics are just more blatant about what they're trying to convey because of the added bonus of artwork. So no, it's not like film and radio. What you stated on the other hand, was completely foolhardy. There isn't a standard criteria that everyone adheres to, in order to judge whether a film is better than another.

I'm going to write my feelings about the avengers movie in which i'm jealous of the avengers is getting more attention than the x-men.

It's a 9, for me personally.

@nandizzle said:

@Greendevil: Shut up you little hotard, only little fan boys can appreciate something as storyless as the Avengers.

I can't give it an accurate rating but maybe 9.