No, they shouldn't. Unfortunately, there is a board already set up for this specific topic.

that's idiotic I guess?

Why not?!?! It makes for an awesome story... That is if it's done right..

Why not?!?! It makes for an awesome story... That is if it's done right..

@Illuminatus said:

@Roddy010 said:

Why not?!?! It makes for an awesome story... That is if it's done right..

Umm..how does it make for an "awesome" story if two groups of heroes go to war with each other over the silliest of reasons?

I said "If it's done right"...Most people who read comics like to see heroes duke it out with each other...If you have a good enough writer, editor and illustrator on an issue the story will come out great...Also I wasn't talking about AvX specifically but comics in general...

Okay people. Match ups wise it's Wolvie vs. Cap. Who would win?

@Illuminatus said:

@Roddy010 said:

Why not?!?! It makes for an awesome story... That is if it's done right..

Umm..how does it make for an "awesome" story if two groups of heroes go to war with each other over the silliest of reasons?

Obviously it wouldn't be an awesome story if everyone is fighting for a stupid reason. It's got to be logical and believable. People have differences of opinion and fight for stupid things right through to really serious things all the time. Just because they fight doesn't mean one side has to be 'evil / 100% wrong' and the other 'good / 100%' right. For it to work in super hero stories I thing the divisive factor needs to be serious and the arguments on both sides valid to some sizeable degree. That's where the fun of reading a hero vs hero story comes from. Seeing both sides of the argument, the personal and moral dilemas, the fractured friendships, the drama and hope that they resolve things. Plus there's also the dumb fun of seeing two powerhouses duke it out!

@Daycrawler said:

@Illuminatus said:

@Roddy010 said:

Why not?!?! It makes for an awesome story... That is if it's done right..

Umm..how does it make for an "awesome" story if two groups of heroes go to war with each other over the silliest of reasons?

Obviously it wouldn't be an awesome story if everyone is fighting for a stupid reason. It's got to be logical and believable. People have differences of opinion and fight for stupid things right through to really serious things all the time. Just because they fight doesn't mean one side has to be 'evil / 100% wrong' and the other 'good / 100%' right. For it to work in super hero stories I thing the divisive factor needs to be serious and the arguments on both sides valid to some sizeable degree. That's where the fun of reading a hero vs hero story comes from. Seeing both sides of the argument, the personal and moral dilemas, the fractured friendships, the drama and hope that they resolve things. Plus there's also the dumb fun of seeing two powerhouses duke it out!

Exactly my point....