the_mighty_monarch's Avengers Arena #3 - Earth Girls Aren't Easy review

It's Cold Outside

The biggest complaint I see about this series is the trivilization of character death. Many people claim that characters are being killed off without creating emotional attachment for the sake of a brawl capitalizing on the recent success of The Hunger Games. But most of these people already have a fondness for the characters, these are a big group of fan favorites with dedicated fanbases. I am not part of any of those groups. I know absolutely zero about every single character save X-23 coming into this series, and my knowledge of her is still minimal. So I am very qualified to judge whether or not Dennis Hopeless is crafting emotional connections and making things significant. He is to an impressive degree.

The tone of this series is one more along the lines of tension and suspense instead of a bombastic 'battle royale.' These aren't a random group of youngsters, they're all established heroes in their own rights. Why would they fight each other without provocation? It's clear Arcade has a plan for that, and the growing tension is creating conflict; but it's about the TENSION not having the biggest fights. Each issue is giving us deep looks into each character one at a time, Mettle's death was truly tragic and I'd only known him for literally one issue. And the new Deathlocket.... you could make a drinking game out of the number of times she needs a big freaking hug. And now, Cammie.

The only complaint I have is that it appears there's a qualification to kill a character every issue, and with a cast of only 16..... that can't last too long. BUT, we don't yet know if the supposed death in this issue is confirmed or not.

Cammi definitely has my attention, she's an outsider, and a brilliant observer. She rigs her own fake camp and sleeps in the trees as she watches the rest of the players to find the one hunting the rest. She's extremely strategic with a stoic exterior, but there's a wounded outcast deep inside. We get to see a chunk of her backstory, though I'm not entirely sure what it's supposed to tell us. She has abilities only in space, or she's just trained only for lower gravity? It motivates her to improve her Earth self, though she seems to regret being stuck in her home planet. But her drive is intense and impressive.

In Conclusion: 4.5/5

I'm in love with Avengers Arena, and I have no history with the Runaways OR Avengers Academy. Hopeless is making me care deeply about everyone, and I'm really impressed with the intense emotional content of this series. The death is there, but the idea that it's a gimmick is only in people's heads. Marvel doesn't seem to be pushing the 'PEOPLE ARE GOING TO DIE' and Hopeless certainly isn't making the deaths flashy and insubstantial. He's taking great care to make them mean something, and the over hype focus on PEOPLE ARE GOING TO DIE seems to have been generated entirely by a disgruntled and possibly ignorant fanbase. Maybe I'm biased having no history; but let it be known that Hopeless is making me care so much about these characters; my desire to read Runaways and Avengers Academy is at an all time high.

1 Comments
Edited by wmwadeii

Your review resembles the response I got when I recommended the series to a few coworkers. I couldn't believe the negativity some single minded people were giving it. They picked up the first trade from my recommendation and like you didn't have much knowledge of the characters but are loving the series. I know some of the character mainly from Avengers Academy but still like the concept and where this series is heading so far.

Other reviews for Avengers Arena #3 - Earth Girls Aren't Easy

    Stupid.Weak.Slow 0

    After two weak issues, Hopelles finally nails down a good story, mostly because it focused more on the characters and not Arcade's evil plan or meaniest game he's ever played. Sure, the plot continues to be about a bunch of young heroes, trapped in a murder world, where only one of them can be left alive, meaning they have to kill one another. Despite the whole Hunger Games look alike (a copy), even an "homage" by Horn's cover, I really liked this issue because it was about a new character to me...

    5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.