The season finale as come and gone, here's how it stacks up to the original comic.
We’ve come to the end of our journey. After the fifth episode cliffhanger, it should be no surprise that the season finale of The Walking Dead would shock both fans of the original comic, and newcomers alike. If you’d like to catch up on our previous comic-to-TV comparisons before diving into the new episode, here’s the first breaking down the first four episodes, and here’s the second analyzing the fifth episode.
Much like the previous two comparison analyzes, this breakdown of the season finale is heavy on spoilers. Read at your own discretion!
Episode 1.06 - “TS-19”
Shane to the Rescue
The opening of the season finale is a scene we never saw in the original comic. Shane went back to get Rick out of the hospital. See, he had good intentions in the beginning after all! We also see why there were so many bodies and bullet holes shot through the walls of the hospital. Surprisingly, the bullets weren’t just meant for the dead walking amongst the living. This scene also shows the origin of the gurney Rick tripped over when trying to leave his hospital room in Episode 1. That was a neat little call-back. == TEASER ==
Shane Confronts Lori
OK, maybe Shane took the wrong approach to getting his true feelings out there on the table. Confession of your love followed up by attempted rape is never the best route to take. But leave it to Shane to let his temper get the best of him when Lori rejects his confession.
TS-19 and the End of the World
The largest deviation the television series has taken from the original comic is the inclusion of Atlanta’s Center for Disease Control (CDC). Furthermore, this CDC sequence offers up a bare theory to the root cause of the zombie apocalypse. Nothing of this sort has happened in the comic, even to this day. And honestly, the comic series is better off for it. But for a television series, giving the audience a sense that the mystery will eventually be solved is a way to string them along into watching more. Now hopefully viewers of the television series will soon learn to stop caring about the why, and start caring only about the characters surviving. That’s what makes The Walking Dead unique in the first place.
It’s also interesting that the AMC series specifically says the rest of the world has fallen to the zombie plague. In the comics our cast of characters never know what’s around each corner, or if tomorrow they will stumble upon a true utopia to ride out the zombie apocalypse in. Within six episode of the AMC series they already know the rest of the world is in chaos.
CDC Goes Boom
The final moments of the season finale for AMC’s The Walking Dead were explosive, literally. The CDC is wiped out in a mass cleansing process and our group of survivors just barely make it out alive. This ending is in severe contrast to the climax of the first story-arc of the comic series, where a significant cast member is killed off (more on that in a second) and the tone is much darker and depressing.
Shane Lives?!
Here’s the biggest surprise of the season. Shane has survived the opening storyline. Without going into specific spoilers for those who have yet to read the comic series, let’s just say Shane doesn’t make it out alive. Obviously that has changed in the AMC retelling of events. It’s a strange move, for sure. On one hand, the constant interplay and leadership bickering between Rick and Shane makes for good drama, so why end that early? But on the other hand, this turn of events really slows down the pacing of the over-arching Walking Dead narrative. Seriously, major plot developments and character-arcs hinge on the fate of Shane. Maybe this is AMC’s way of telling us the TV series will be completely different than the original comic. If that’s the case, message received.
But you can bet that the CDC scientist, Edwin Jenner, whispered into Rick’s ear that he saw Shane’s “confession” to Lori on the security cameras. That knowledge is going to eat away at Rick throughout the second season.
Conclusion
Now it’s time to play the waiting game till next Halloween for the premiere of The Walking Dead Season 2. I think I speak for everyone when I say the wait is going to be excruciating. But for the next year we can think up crazy hypotheses as to where the series will go from here. And for those who still have a Walking Dead itch to scratch, check out our two articles highlighting the many ways you can experience The Walking Dead comics, and what other comic series you can read if you’ve enjoyed The Walking Dead.
Sound off in the comments below with your wild theories as to where they’re taking the show next!
Overall it was a good episode. They did have the haunting CDC center but I was relieved that there was no zombie conspiracy or bigger question surrounded by a ton of misleads a la Lost. The Walking Dead truly is it's own show and I think the mythology was strengthened by this episode.
However, I was a little disappointed by how they handled Jaqui. First of all, it looked a little bad that Dale didn't try to convince her to join them but being that he was pressed for time and had no interaction with her, I'll let it slide. Still, I feel like she was a dead woman walking (no pun intended) from the moment she was introduced which makes her death too easy...it should never be too easy. If we are to believe in the danger of this situation, it should always be someone whose death means something. That's not to say it needs to be melodramatic or time-consuming but it has to have some substance, I think. People dying is always an emotional thing, they're not soldiers, they're civilians who are trapped in this dire situation.
Also that actress was excellent, she did so much communicating with her face that brought real character to the role.
Overall, I like the show. It's a lot more..hardcore than most TV shows I'm only mildly familiar with the comics in this case, but aren't there supposed to be a set of twins around there somewhere? -Virus
How do we know what the doc whispered in his ear, also that seems like an awfully long time to wait for the second season, when the first was only six episodes. I liked the show I wouldn't say I'm in love with it, I liked the part where they explained how the zombies died and came back, thought that was cool, but I don't care for the "drama" parts. I don't know if anybody saw it but I liked the "Dead Set" much better.
I also first that that Rick was whispered to his ear that his wife is pregnant. Usually great news but not exactly an ideal thing to happen in that real bad situation. It could have been a look of great concern. Either way, I think both those theory's are the best bet.
i actually figured that Jenner told Rick that everybody was already infected with the Z germ. That would be a much bigger thing for Jenner to mention, especially in the context of the existential suicide bent he was on.
Why would Jenner really want to get involved with gossip about who Shane was molesting when he was contemplating humanity's extinction event?
Knowing that everybody is already infected just adds this extra level of weight and hopelessness on everything. Just the kind of thing that would be driving jenner to suicide in the first place.
I maybe one of the few but i have to say i did not like the episode at all and it was not the finale to end on and be gone for so long. Everything just felt so cheesy and over acted. I just hope they don't try to hard to move in it's own direction that it loses focus. But one bad episode is still pretty good and i will wait and see how it turns out.
The shows been really bugging me, i don't think the tv shane and comic shane are good matches. I haven't watched the final episode yet, i hope its good. I'm waiting can't wait for Michonne to enter into the show with her zombie friends and see how they do that.
The thing that bothered me the most in the series was the fact that they aged up Andrea. In the comics she's in her early 20s (or so it seems) while in the TV series she looks 40ish.
The only reason I can come up with to that is that they were afraid that a sexual relationship between an elderly man and a young woman might come off as "wrong" or "non-sexy" in the eyes of the average TV audience. This missed the whole point of this relationship in the comic, namely to show that in apocalyptic times such as these, some things are just more important than age when choosing a partner.
This indicates to me that the creators of the TV show are really afraid to take chances or breaking boundaries, and this what prevents this from being a truly great TV show. For me, this is OK, nothing more.
I just finished the last episode of the season one, and boy, oh boy, did I hate it. I'm sorry, if this sounds like flaming, but for me, that was one of the worst things I've seen on a TV in a long time. Kind of dropped my expectations totally for the upcoming season 2. All in all, I think the series have been going steadily downhill after the episode 2. I really hope, that the second season would hit me better than the first, but I don't keep my hopes high. :(
63 Comments