Comic Vine News

66 Comments

Off My Mind: When Main Characters Disappear from their Comic Books

Readers want to read the adventures of the title character but how long can a series last when the character goes missing?

No Caption Provided

In comic books, characters often become absent. There's the typical stories where a character sacrifices their lives or is simply killed by another for some reason. When a series has an ensemble cast, one character biting the dust isn't that big of a deal. We've seen members of the X-Men, Avengers, Justice League and Fantastic Four die at some point (only to eventually return). Sometimes team members just want to take a vacation (like when Black Panther and Storm replaced Reed and Sue).

Team books don't really feel the impact of one of the main characters disappearing. When it's a solo book, it's a little different. There has been times when characters such as Batman, Superman or Spider-Man have gone missing in their own titles. These types of stories add a new twist and gives a distinct feel from the usual stories contained in the series. A great writer can make this happen and make it work wonderfully.

How long can the main character of a book not be featured? The star of the book is most likely the main reason why readers are picking up the title. Is there a limit on how many issues readers are willing to go with the main character being absent?

== TEASER ==
No Caption Provided

When it's a death issue, there are the stories of mourning and acceptance to deal with. Provided the character has a strong supporting cast, there are interesting angles that can be depicted with the friends, family and even enemies of the fallen hero. The Death of Superman resulted in four new characters filling the void. Captain America's death gave room for Bucky Barnes to step up and show how worthy a character he truly was. Batman's death allowed Dick Grayson to fill his boots and evolve even further than he already had over the years. The death of Ultimate Spider-Man is giving a new character, Miles Morales, the chance to grow into a beloved character.

These stories all lasted for a few issues. The hero's death didn't just last for a story arc. Time went by and fans kept reading. There was a story to be told and the fact that the title character wasn't in the book served to attract more attention to it.

No Caption Provided

It isn't always death that makes the main character go away. There's been a couple times when Spider-Man has been MIA. In one arc, Spider-Man was missing for about three issues. It turned out his costume was in tatters after a fight and he tried hitchhiking his way home from Virginia but got sidetracked in some wacky prison fiasco when picked up as a vagrant.

After the introduction of Ben Reilly and the Clone Saga, it appeared that Peter Parker and Mary Jane were going to sail off into the sunset. They actually moved to Oregon and Ben took over the Spider-Man titles. He even developed his own supporting cast and hangouts that gave the book a clear and distinct feel while still retaining the roots of who Spider-Man was supposed to be.

There was also when Tony Stark became too...unstable due to his alcohol intake. He couldn't quite handle running his company and be a superhero in the Iron Man armor. Eventually his friend, Rhodey, put on the armor and took his place while Tony dealt with his drinking problem.

No Caption Provided

What about the introduction of a new character? In the current SWAMP THING series, we've been reading about the return of Alec Holland. It turned out he died and his remains and essence were used for Swamp Thing before. Now we were reading about the human without any powers and it took seven issues for "Swamp Thing" to even appear. With the way the story took place, it was definitely worth the wait.

No Caption Provided

Finally there's THE WALKING DEAD. The focus has always been on the survivors of a zombie outbreak. We all know that Rick Grimes is the main character in the book. We've seen so many other big supporting characters die and some of us have speculated that Rick could possible die as well. The book could carry on without him despite the anger long time readers would have.

What it really comes down to is how the story is written. Some readers do follow the creative teams on titles. Most tend to focus on the characters. If you're reading a comic about Aquaman or Black Widow, you expect them to actually be in the comic.

A great writer can create a compelling story with the main character absent for a bit but eventually the readers will demand the character's presence in the comic. It's always interesting to see how long writers can keep the comic a success when trying to put out these types of stories. Mixing up the status quo and adding in mystery and suspense is a great thing to inject into a series but at the end of the day, we're all buying the book for the character whose name appears on the cover.

66 Comments

Avatar image for kidsupreme
KidSupreme

854

Forum Posts

227

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By KidSupreme

@SupremeHyperion said:

If it's written right I don't see why you couldn't make it last. I loved when they switched the Incredible Hulk book to Incredible Herc, but that might be a little different?

I agree

Avatar image for mewmdude77
mewmdude77

1054

Forum Posts

2254

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 13

Edited By mewmdude77

@Cosmic_Hobo said:

Whereas the return of ultimate Peter Parker would probably make me stop me reading the book.He was a great character, now he'd gone and Miles is a great character. The lack of death having any meaning is really ruing comics for me lately. I mean, I think EVERY Avenger that died during disassembled is back from the dead now? Meh. So as much as I love ultimate Parker, I hope he stays in the ground

I agree 100%. I don't know why people hate the new Ultimate Spider-man. I would really hate it if Peter came back to life, because in the Ultimate Universe, that's practically the one place in comics where people stay dead permantently. I wish the dead would stay dead in the main universes more often. Truthfully, the only people who stay dead in the regular comic universes are: Uncle Ben, Gwen Stacy, Captain Stacy, Bruce Wayne's parents, Bruce Banner's father, and maybe one or two more, but I wish it were more. It would make the deaths mean more. Like when Johnny gave his life, I wanted him to stay dead for a least a couple of years to make it meaningful, but he's back in less than a year. Kraven the Hunter's death in Kraven's Last Hunt was the best ending for that masterpiece story, but then they screwed it up by bringing him back in Grim Hunt, and not having him do anything since. Or when Bucky Barnes died a long time ago, and was thought he would never come back, but someone decided in the 2000's that it would be better to have him be alive, but as a Soviet sleeper agent?!?! stupid no deaths.

Avatar image for catpanexe
CATPANEXE

9505

Forum Posts

2901

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Edited By CATPANEXE

It's a horse a piece but ultimately a good move in the end. It's negative side obviously is that the " original/classic " being on hiatus creates a reader/fan backlash. I can cite Spider-man being replaced by Scarlet Spider taking the hardest hit there, noting that they quickly altered Ben's persona from Scarlet into Spider-man (though really I think the outrage came with the now retraced revelation that Peter Parker was not the real article, meaning the possibility was that he wouldn't return at some point.). Though with less prolific books it doesn't always generate that heat, like Savage Dragon for example. Why it ultimately works of course is that not only does the replacement character gain a larger readership themselves, but the celebrated return of the original of course which renews appreciation for the character, ei; we take what we have for granted until it's gone. It's an expansive move at the end of the day either way.

Avatar image for jnr6lil
Jnr6Lil

8701

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Jnr6Lil

@mewmdude77: Maybe because he's black

Avatar image for mewmdude77
mewmdude77

1054

Forum Posts

2254

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 13

Edited By mewmdude77

@Jnr6Lil said:

@mewmdude77: Maybe because he's black

He's half black, half Hispanic, and I thought I heard he's gay too. but it doesn't matter what he looks like,

Avatar image for jnr6lil
Jnr6Lil

8701

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Jnr6Lil

@mewmdude77: May be why hes hated

Avatar image for mewmdude77
mewmdude77

1054

Forum Posts

2254

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 13

Edited By mewmdude77

@Jnr6Lil said:

@mewmdude77: May be why hes hated

that's a dumb reason in my opinion

Avatar image for spideysense
SpideySense

43

Forum Posts

174

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By SpideySense

@SupremeHyperion said:

If it's written right I don't see why you couldn't make it last. I loved when they switched the Incredible Hulk book to Incredible Herc, but that might be a little different?

Avatar image for thegeekcritique
TheGeekCritique

28

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By TheGeekCritique

Shawn writes:

During Marvel's 25th anniversary I remember Spider-Man missing from a few comics only to appear as Peter Parker locked away in some prison. I think this was my first experience with a missing character in a story arc (aside from She-Hulk replacing Thing in The Fantastic Four) and I hated it. I didn't buy Spider-Man comics to read about other characters who weren't good enough for comics of their own. I wanted Spidey for his heroics and witty banter, but instead I got second-rate Silver Sable and the dry-as-toast Doctor Strange.

Anymore, DC and Marvel are spread so thin with multiverses, future/past characters and characters with siblings that missing characters and the death of characters has become irrelevant. Has a hero died or disappeared? Just replace him with a nephew, sibling or sidekick. Don't like the replacement? Read about the hero in Earth 2 or the Ultimate story arc. Still dissatisfied? Wait until the parallel universes converge or the hero is brought back to life.

Avatar image for wowlock
wowlock

907

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By wowlock

As long as there is a ''Natural'' progression in the story, like Dick becoming Batman after Bruce, I am fine with the absent main guys. It is hard for many of us to leave that character behind and move on to accept a new one, as with many things, but if a great story can pull that off, it can make things all the better.

Usual I enjoy the ''Main character absent'' periods from time to time because the focus in on the support cast and their developement...also the mystery of ''Where is the Main character ? ''....So if you can pull it off with a strong story, payoff would be great ( like Bruce's ''death'' after Final Crysis'' and Dick taking his place along with Damien ) but if you have a long term plan, try not to drag on too much. Some gambles work, some don't and you can't really blame people for wanting to see the chracter they bought the comic for.

Avatar image for jnr6lil
Jnr6Lil

8701

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Jnr6Lil

@mewmdude77 said:

@Jnr6Lil said:

@mewmdude77: May be why hes hated

that's a dumb reason in my opinion

Well, people are dumb

Avatar image for jokersglee
jokersglee

7

Forum Posts

9

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By jokersglee

It depends on the writing of how interesting they can keep the story going.
Avatar image for praetor_fenix
Praetor_fenix

227

Forum Posts

14

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 1

Edited By Praetor_fenix

That's kind like the New Coca Cola strategy, a fresh new take is pretty cool, but in the end back to basics is much much better.

Avatar image for donovan_montgomery
Donovan Montgomery

5751

Forum Posts

2822

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 17

The whole death storylines are one thing.  Dick as Batman was a natural evolvment cause he was supposed to take the mantle, Bucky as Cap would have worked better for me if he wasn't an established dead character for the last 40 years. 
Guess what I'm trying to say is   if the main character is missing for a reason, as long as the stories are intresting and you know why they are missing, it's mostly o.k.  
What got me (and what I thought this was about) is when for no reason  the  book is turned over to another character, Daredevil vol 2 #50-55 iirc where Echo had the spotlight comes to mind.

Avatar image for blacksuperman4eva
blacksuperman4eva

8

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

I think it depends on the book itself and how the fans will respond to it. Take for instance Bruce Wayne dying Batman fans knew he was gonna come back eventually since certian characters really do not die or stay dead. But the fans still bought Batman comics cuz we knew that (a) he would be back and (b) that some of us just love what he represents.

Avatar image for gothikknight
GothikKnight

60

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By GothikKnight

I've seen these in my course of reading over the years growing up :

Ironman (stark) to ironman (rhodes)

Ironman (stark) to Warmachine (rhodes)

Green Hulk to Gray Hulk to Merger Hulk to Green Hulk to Red Hulk

Thor (Odinson) to Thor (Eric Masterson) Which was great btw.

Captain America (rogers) to Captain America (usagent)

Spiderman (Peter) to Spiderman (Ben)

Green Lantern (Hal) to Green Lantern (Kyle)

Batman (Bruce) to Batman (azeral) to Batman (bruce) to Batman (dick)

Robin (dick) to Robin (tim), all three versions, really.

Flash (Barry) to Flash (Wally), etc...

Venom (Eddie) to Venom (Mac) to Venom (Flash). btw, Flash as Venom is great.

Captain Marvel (Mar-Vell) to Captain Marvel (energy woman) to Captain Marvel (Legacy) to captin Marvel (Pyrl) to ... Captain Marvel (Skrull) to ... maybe Captain Marvel (Hulkling) someday.

I COULD GO ON...but I wont. Geeze that is alot of times just off-hand the main character being replaced.

Sometimes the Stories are good or just different for a change of pace. Other times they are Great or better. Then again, other times the stories are horrible and the return cannot happen sooner than we hope.

  • 66 results
  • 1
  • 2