Comic Vine News

150 Comments

Do Politics In Comics Alienate Readers?

Is there a place for politics in comic books, or is it a subject that should not be discussed?

I can't recall when I first heard it, perhaps because it made so much sense or because I first heard it so long ago; but I remember hearing that if you want to prevent an argument with someone, you should stay away from three subjects: religion, politics and sex. Unfortunately, these are the three most interesting things to discuss! Joking aside though, there is a lot of truth to that wise little phrase.

No Caption Provided

While the idea of "sex" in comics isn't "new" by any stretch of the imagination, politics and religion are by far, the touchier subjects of the three. While sex can serve to shock audiences, I would venture to say that it (as a subject) may not necessarily alienate reader; at least not in the way politics might. We see sex in comics a lot (just look at all the discussions we've been having recently) but religious and political discussions and commentary are subjects that comic book readers are exposed to a lot less frequently when they read comics, so when they do happen to take place, they can come across as incredibly shocking. Politics in comics is a very, very touchy subject, and that could be because it can be interpreted in so many different ways -- but is it a subject that should be "off limits" to writers, or is it something that writers can use to draw in readers and entertain their audiences? Do politics in comics alienate readers?

== TEASER ==
No Caption Provided

The most recent example of a political reference in a comic book was when a direct reference to the Tea Party (an actual conservative group) appeared in Captain America #602. The Tea Party, which is a real political movement in the United States became offended and the conservative community retaliated. Fox News claimed that labeling the protestors as "Tea Party" "[made] patriotic Americans into your newest super villains." Whether this is true or not is based on your perception of the issue. However, the uproar forced Marvel's former Chief Editor to apologize on behalf of the error, and promise to strip it from all future reprints of the story.

No Caption Provided

Many would see the appearance of the Tea Party in this particular issue as a way of acknowledging the current state of the American political system. It was as if to say yes, the conservative Tea Party exists and they are important to the current state of American politics -- that doesn't necessarily make it a criticism of conservatives or the Tea Party movement. In fact, this wouldn't be the first time that current American politics have crossed into a Captain America story.

During World War II, Captain America fought the Nazis, during the Cold War he fought the Russians, and etc. Politics have always heavily influenced Captain America stories because the whole premise of his character revolves around it. Many of the first Captain America appearances were a way for the creators to provide commentary on the current state of the country and the socio-political atmosphere. Does this mean that Captain America comics should steer clear of any influence of our current political atmosphere, because it might alienate readers?

Most of us who have read it would agree that V for Vendetta, written by Alan Moore, was a truly great story -- and it was extremely politically charged. However, unless you know anything about Alan Moore, you might not guess that V for Vendetta wasn't only a story about a masked revolutionary who stands up to a totalitarian regime; it's also Moore's commentary on what he truly believes is the best form of government: anarchism. Now, you can choose to read this classic graphic novel two different ways: one, can you read it for what it is, a great story; or you can read it with the thought that Moore very seriously believes that anarchism is the solution to all of our political problems.

"Anarchy is a romance. It's clearly the best way and the only morally sensible way to run the world. Everyone should be the masters of their own destinies. Everyone should be their own leader."
No Caption Provided

Even if you don't necessarily agree with Moore's ideas and political philosophy, that doesn't mean you can't enjoy a great story, right? Some of the best stories have been birthed from political concepts like V For Vendetta, for example, which deals tells the story of an anarchist (V) who is trying to overthrow a totalitarian government. Moore, we should mention, is a self proclaimed anarchist.

Another example of stories that use political concepts and integrate them into their plot-lines are Judge Dredd comics. Judge Dredd is set in a dystopian future where what is left of the world is being patrolled by an oppressive political system. Several Judge Dredd story lines like Robot Wars (Progs 10-17) and The Devil You Know (Progs 750-756) are extremely politically charged; so much so that the entire premise of these stories is based on revolution and the overthrow of a political system.

Does that mean that we should take these books seriously, or should we simply view them as socio-political commentary? Superman Red Son is another example of the influence politics can have on a comic book. What would Superman be like had he been raised in Communist U.S.S.R.?

When creators inject their personal political beliefs directly, it can become a problem; but Alan Moore did this exact thing in V For Vendetta, and he gave us a great story. So is it possible to for politics to exist in comics without causing such a stir? What do you think? Do you want politics in your comics, or would you rather leave them out of it?

150 Comments

Avatar image for larkin1388
Larkin1388

1826

Forum Posts

101

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By Larkin1388

I dont think so. It be same as watching a movie with political views

Avatar image for mrzero1982pt2
mrzero1982pt2

423

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By mrzero1982pt2

many books have super snide political views, babs, you have a good point!

Avatar image for b_heart
B_Heart

152

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By B_Heart

@Larkin1388 said:

I dont think so. It be same as watching a movie with political views

Agreed. Same thing with music, I like Lupe Fiasco even though he has some political lyrics in his songs. It's all about the beats.

Avatar image for lordtaronji101
LordTaronji101

332

Forum Posts

5555

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 9

User Lists: 6

Edited By LordTaronji101

i think politcal points in comics brings a sort of involvement and intellegence to comics..alan moore seems to do this really well

Avatar image for daveyo520
Daveyo520

2469

Forum Posts

8

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Daveyo520

If they are politics you don't agree with, yes.

Avatar image for gethere
gethere

165

Forum Posts

5

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By gethere

No, we honestly hear politics all the time everywhere we go. So it just about impossible to avoid it, but I do wish that writers try not to mix politics with comics. They tend to just ruin the story if not written right.

Avatar image for theblackhood
TheBlackHood

594

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By TheBlackHood

I tend to think that politics do alienate SOME readers because the majority of comic creators seem to hail from one particular political outlook. I suspect that the majority of comic fans are also pretty liberal leaning which means including this type of political outlook in a book panders to your target audience. On the other hand, I tend to be somewhat conservative on a number of subjects, so I do tend to get the short end of the stick when it comes to my politics being shown in a positive.

I mentioned before how I was shocked during the first part of the new "Mister Terrific" because they had Terrific working with a conservative Senator. My surprise quickly became a feeling of "I should have known that was coming" when Terrific flips out at the end of the issue and accuses the Republican of being a demon incarnate.

Personally I find that politics are best left to comics LIKE: V for Vendetta where it is the subject matter. Of course there are certain characters that I am fine with addressing politics because they where their affiliation on their sleeve as part of their character:

Green Arrow = Massive Liberal

Punisher = Eye for an Eye Conservative

The problem is that since most comic writers are fairly liberal, they tend to make their protagonists match their own affiliation and the antagonists match what they disagree with. What happens is that Conservatives are often cast as evil when they simply have different ideals.

Avatar image for decept_o
Decept-O

8097

Forum Posts

33607

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 31

User Lists: 6

Edited By Decept-O

Many stories, whether in comic book form or not, are often thinly veiled comments and opinions about politics. If I want to delve into politics, I will do so in other areas. Personally I don't care for discussing it in entertainment. That doesn't make me narrow minded nor a simpleton; it is my opinion and I don't like it. I want to cross into the world of escapism and to me that means leaving a lot of things that are in real life behind.

Avatar image for theblackhood
TheBlackHood

594

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By TheBlackHood

@B_Heart said:

@Larkin1388 said:

I dont think so. It be same as watching a movie with political views

Agreed. Same thing with music, I like Lupe Fiasco even though he has some political lyrics in his songs. It's all about the beats.

I think the problem is that the politics in comics are usually all skewed toward a liberal point of view, which can be alienating if you are conservative. Writers tend to skew things toward their own leanings and I prefer political commentary left to books like V for Vendetta or Green Arrow where I know going in that it will be addressed because it is the focus of the book.

Avatar image for superguy0009e
Superguy0009e

2404

Forum Posts

2663

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Edited By Superguy0009e

i will say this, like in real life, politics, religion, morality, tough issues, whatever, is annoying in everyday stuff...

If used well, it can be a very important story telling tool

ex Savage Dragon.....great comic, politics in it kindof ruin it for me

@TheBlackHood: as a conservative, i can tell you reading liberal hero after liberal hero can get kind of annoying......especially with religous superheroes like daredevil or nightcrawler...and to a point spiderman

Avatar image for fenixrevolution
fenixREVOLUTION

921

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By fenixREVOLUTION

I don't mind politics in comics, it doesn't bother me, because to be fictional, sometimes they aren't as extreme as the stuff we hear about in reality, especially the last few years. I also can't recall encountering politics too many times. The last one I recall was Superman denouncing his citizenship and the media going bonkers over it and both felt wrong, the story itself felt unnecessary and the media flipping out about it was ridiculous and uncalled for as well. I think the most prominent one in books I read and love is when Bill Willingham made the Fabletown to Israel comparison. A lot of people seemed to be upset by this, some said they were going to drop the title, but I could've cared less. It's not like that one line added or retracted any enjoyment I was getting from the book and I continue to enjoy it. I think seeing some politics is inevitable, but people should be a bit more open minded, especially if it's a small thing and not something smacking you in the face every panel. So, no, I don't believe it does alienate people, it just gives the internet more fodder to fight over.

Avatar image for ensabahnurx
EnSabahNurX

2321

Forum Posts

248

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By EnSabahNurX

@TheBlackHood said:

I tend to think that politics do alienate SOME readers because the majority of comic creators seem to hail from one particular political outlook. I suspect that the majority of comic fans are also pretty liberal leaning which means including this type of political outlook in a book panders to your target audience. On the other hand, I tend to be somewhat conservative on a number of subjects, so I do tend to get the short end of the stick when it comes to my politics being shown in a positive.

I mentioned before how I was shocked during the first part of the new "Mister Terrific" because they had Terrific working with a conservative Senator. My surprise quickly became a feeling of "I should have known that was coming" when Terrific flips out at the end of the issue and accuses the Republican of being a demon incarnate.

Personally I find that politics are best left to comics LIKE: V for Vendetta where it is the subject matter. Of course there are certain characters that I am fine with addressing politics because they where their affiliation on their sleeve as part of their character:

Green Arrow = Massive Liberal

Punisher = Eye for an Eye Conservative

The problem is that since most comic writers are fairly liberal, they tend to make their protagonists match their own affiliation and the antagonists match what they disagree with. What happens is that Conservatives are often cast as evil when they simply have different ideals.

Can i say you're awesome and I completely agree ^___^

Avatar image for hitechlolife
hitechlolife

194

Forum Posts

8

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By hitechlolife

I'm interested in broader political topics being discussed in comics but it's hard not to cringe when a writer tries to do their take on the given charged, political talking point of the day. For example a recent Nick Spencer penned Secret Avengers had the Avengers take down an apparent wikileaks analogy ( Cap punches it in the face.).

Avatar image for thecheesestabber
TheCheeseStabber

8212

Forum Posts

331

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 2

Edited By TheCheeseStabber

Superman Red Son is one of my all time favorite reads because of the action yes but there ideas an the spread of communism an if used right how it could help people it acually helped mold my political ideas

Avatar image for josedriveratcr7
JoseDRiveraTCR7

1020

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Edited By JoseDRiveraTCR7

I think for the major superhero books there shouldn't be anything political of controversial in it. If someone wants to do it in lesser known books or creator own books then that's fine.

Avatar image for alexdm
AlexDM

42

Forum Posts

122

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 16

User Lists: 0

Edited By AlexDM

That panel is a flattering picture of Tea Partiers. Photos I've seen show poorer sign-making and English Language skills. Also, that cowardice from Marvel has alienated me.

I'm going to guess any racists, homophobes, and fascists who read V For Vendetta felt alienated by it. Complete hatred of an ideology you hold is more alienating than praise of one you don't. Especially as Moore's view has a lot in common with mainstream politics in the West; the basic idea that "everyone should be the masters of their own destinies" is something most of us can agree on.

Avatar image for rudyftw
Rudyftw

995

Forum Posts

37

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 1

Edited By Rudyftw

HAHAHAHAHAHAAHA!

It's funny because he said Teabag.

Avatar image for punisher131313
punisher131313

8

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By punisher131313

@EnSabahNurX said:

@TheBlackHood said:

I tend to think that politics do alienate SOME readers because the majority of comic creators seem to hail from one particular political outlook. I suspect that the majority of comic fans are also pretty liberal leaning which means including this type of political outlook in a book panders to your target audience. On the other hand, I tend to be somewhat conservative on a number of subjects, so I do tend to get the short end of the stick when it comes to my politics being shown in a positive.

I mentioned before how I was shocked during the first part of the new "Mister Terrific" because they had Terrific working with a conservative Senator. My surprise quickly became a feeling of "I should have known that was coming" when Terrific flips out at the end of the issue and accuses the Republican of being a demon incarnate.

Personally I find that politics are best left to comics LIKE: V for Vendetta where it is the subject matter. Of course there are certain characters that I am fine with addressing politics because they where their affiliation on their sleeve as part of their character:

Green Arrow = Massive Liberal

Punisher = Eye for an Eye Conservative

The problem is that since most comic writers are fairly liberal, they tend to make their protagonists match their own affiliation and the antagonists match what they disagree with. What happens is that Conservatives are often cast as evil when they simply have different ideals.

Can i say you're awesome and I completely agree ^___^

I also agree!

Avatar image for gravesp
GraveSp

335

Forum Posts

266

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 15

User Lists: 0

Edited By GraveSp

Green Lantern Green Arrow, very political book and a great story. Although I may only think that because my ideals aligned fairly well with the ideas being championed in the book. Although that may be because there is a difference between a political book and a social book. DC Universe Decides was a book about the politics in the DC universe, I thought that it was interesting read and good story, but not great.

Avatar image for tonis
tonis

6562

Forum Posts

12336

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By tonis

excellent article Sara, and yes indeed a touchy subject to deal with in any form of storytelling without stepping on somebodies toes.

If the story has politically relevant themes and is handled intelligently without too much obvious bias or campaigning I don't mind it. If it starts looking like a piece of propaganda I tend to put that stuff down and ignore it.

Writers and publishers should be smart enough to use caution in using real names of things if they even consider the possibility it might be taken in a bad light. Just like when a tv show uses a fake product like 'choco-puffs' to represent a real product comics have their own, 'Roxxon' clearly represents a big oil entity, and 'Bialya' is just an anagram of Libya.

It isn't hard to represent a 'flavor' in a story without using a specific term or branded name. Then if anyone complains their argument is just that much weaker.

Avatar image for deactivated-5a98cd905fc97
deactivated-5a98cd905fc97

433

Forum Posts

115

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

I don't mind it now and then. "V for Vendetta", "X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills", "Superman Red Son", and other books were more enjoyable because they were willing to include normally taboo subject matter.

As long as the writer isn't insulting in how they present an idea. All they have to do is promote their idea, without putting down the other side too much, and package it with a really thoughtful, and compelling story. Let the readers decide if they agree or disagree.

Avatar image for artisticneedham
ArtisticNeedham

2731

Forum Posts

5732

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By ArtisticNeedham
In front of gangsters
In front of gangsters

I heard in "the World of Steve Ditko" that Steve Ditko, who from what I read was a follower of Ayn Rand and Objectivism, got full control over Spider-Man and began changing Peter Parker into an Objectivist Ayn Rand type. Not sure if its true but the book mentions things like Parker not liking protestors and the villains becoming more and more regular, no super villain, gangsters because that was more real, and showing how J Jonah Jameson was actually a good guy who put food on people's tables with his large company. the book said that he left Spider-man and Stan Lee was put back in charge more with artist Romita taking over the art.

But it makes me wonder, if this is true, what woud Spider-Man have become if Ditko didn't leave?

Avatar image for cyberninja
cyberninja

10669

Forum Posts

16362

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 11

Edited By cyberninja

If anything politics bring depth to comics. 

Avatar image for damswedon
damswedon

545

Forum Posts

6001

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 3

Edited By damswedon

They shouldn't because a good writer shouldn't push an idea as the only correct one. Like Alan Moore says in that video the doing that is an insult to reader. In V he doesn't make everyone in the government to be cartoonish villains, he also doesn't make V come across like a saint (like the film), we are allowed to think about the characters themselves and decide if they are truly good or evil. Sadly most writers can not do this and end up writing absolute tripe.

Avatar image for iaconpoint
iaconpoint

1491

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By iaconpoint

Funny that this article is from Sara Lima, who re-posts a bunch of inaccurate, left-leaning rhetoric on her facebook, such as who in Congress is spending what, but when she posts her own actual views, such as her belief that people on welfare should be drug tested (which I totally agree with), it's all more right-leaning points of view.

I think it depends on the actual story telling. If you're gonna tell a story like, say Morrison's new Superman who goes after actual bad guys in a way that might depict them as the "greedy banker" type, cool!. If you are gonna write a story where the hero feels the eye of "big brother government" must be stopped, I'm down with that too. However, if you are gonna blatantly bash someone's point of view, be they small government Tea Partier (teabagger) or big government liberal (pinko commie hippie), then no. A good writer should be able to interject any political points of view he or she has without making it so blatant as to name-call the other side. OR! Even do away with them all together and just tell a freaking great story.

Avatar image for no_name_
No_Name_

16193

Forum Posts

2734

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 55

User Lists: 2

Edited By No_Name_

@iaconpoint said:

Funny that this article is from Sara Lima, who re-posts a bunch of inaccurate, left-leaning rhetoric on her facebook, such as who in Congress is spending what, but when she posts her own actual views, such as her belief that people on welfare should be drug tested (which I totally agree with), it's all more right-leaning points of view.

I think it depends on the actual story telling. If you're gonna tell a story like, say Morrison's new Superman who goes after actual bad guys in a way that might depict them as the "greedy banker" type, cool!. If you are gonna write a story where the hero feels the eye of "big brother government" must be stopped, I'm down with that too. However, if you are gonna blatantly bash someone's point of view, be they small government Tea Partier (teabagger) or big government liberal (pinko commie hippie), then no. A good writer should be able to interject any political points of view he or she has without making it so blatant as to name-call the other side. OR! Even do away with them all together and just tell a freaking great story.

I don't know what my facebook has to do with this article. I didn't really think I integrated my political views up there ^^

Avatar image for iaconpoint
iaconpoint

1491

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By iaconpoint

@Babs: I'm not bashing you. Really. Or judging. I was just making an observation. Damn you're quick.

Avatar image for crimsontempest
CrimsonTempest

340

Forum Posts

409

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 30

User Lists: 0

Edited By CrimsonTempest
@AlexDM said:

That panel is a flattering picture of Tea Partiers. Photos I've seen show poorer sign-making and English Language skills. Also, that cowardice from Marvel has alienated me.

I'm going to guess any racists, homophobes, and fascists who read V For Vendetta felt alienated by it. Complete hatred of an ideology you hold is more alienating than praise of one you don't. Especially as Moore's view has a lot in common with mainstream politics in the West; the basic idea that "everyone should be the masters of their own destinies" is something most of us can agree on.

I wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment. On all points.
Avatar image for zzax
zzax

50

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By zzax

I think perhaps politics can alienate readers. There are examples where I know my enjoyment has been negatively influenced by the politics underlying the story.

However, I am not sure this is a horrible thing. You know what else alienates readers? Boring lifeless storytelling. While politically influenced comics do not necessarily constitute exciting or substantive, I would much rather a comic try to have a message that might alienate me than have no message at all. While I am not sure I want all my comics to become political commentary, I think there is room in the industry for a balance between pure entertainment and social commentary.

Avatar image for illituracy
iLLituracy

13600

Forum Posts

1161

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By iLLituracy

Politics and comics go hand in hand. Superheroes and politics go hand in hand. They've been there since the beginning. Seigel and Shuster's Superman was a socialist, Denny O'Neil's Green Lantern/Green Arrow comics were liberal, you can probably find some right wing stuff in other mainstream stuff. 
 
Comics mirror real life, they're veiled, sometimes thinly, to fit into a fantasy setting but politics are there in our comic books and usually these characters are used as mouth pieces to reflect the author's feelings on a certain issue. 
 
Grant Morrison did it on Animal Man and JLA, Alan Moore did it on most of his works, and the list goes on and on.  
 
Does it turn people off? I don't think so. Because even if you disagree with, say, the political views of a character, you can appreciate it because that's what their character is. I don't believe in lethal means in dealing with criminals, but the Punisher does, I don't exactly hate his comics, though. There are some people who think lethal means as to dealing with criminals is okay and share this view with the Punisher, I don't think they're exactly put off by his actions.

Avatar image for fodigg
fodigg

6244

Forum Posts

2603

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 7

Edited By fodigg
Avatar image for tadthuggish
TadThuggish

73

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By TadThuggish

Only when it's done poorly.

Avatar image for innervenom123
InnerVenom123

29886

Forum Posts

1786

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 11

User Lists: 1

Edited By InnerVenom123

I could care less. If it's handled well, it's handled well. If there's a book like V For Vendetta (which is obviously a political statement/full of politics (if one of those expressions is wrong, forgive it, I hope you realize what I mean), and you don't like politics, then don't read it. Now, if something like Spider-man takes the occasional jab, that's fine too.(I remember in "American Son" where Wolverine and Spidey fistbumped after a particularly hilarious diss at George W. Bush). Like I said, handled well, handled well.

Avatar image for gothamred
GothamRed

2619

Forum Posts

3474

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 23

Edited By GothamRed

It depends on how up to date the reader is on politics and current events

Avatar image for jekylhyde14
Jekylhyde14

907

Forum Posts

5322

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 28

User Lists: 10

Edited By Jekylhyde14

I think you'll find that it's hard to divorce politics from anything since it's connected to everything. You'll find most writers sneak in their political values in subtle ways from plot to plot without doing anything to raise a commotion. Only every now and then do you hear a complaint, but, really, grow up. Politics are so important to people that I can't imagine anyone separating themselves from it completely enough not to put it into their work. It's like religion. Take the Chronicles of Narnia. You can read it as a fun, fantasy series without worrying about the Judeo-Christian messages and values but they are definitely there. so lighten up. I'm as far left as left can be and when I read Liberality for All I just laughed and laughed. What a ridiculous Conservative nightmare...

Avatar image for riddlinggambit
RiddlingGambit

205

Forum Posts

484

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By RiddlingGambit

that's a great interview w/ Alan Moore. I like political stuff in comics just fine, though I often prefer it to be subtle and not too trivial. I don't want to feel the writer is forcing his views on the reader because I could see someone on the opposite side of the proverbial fence making a big deal about it. Comic books aren't exactly a political medium though it certainly can have a potent political effect such as V for Vendetta has. Sometimes it's political propaganda/persuasion, like how the first Batman serial of the 1940s during WWII had an evil Japanese dictator as the villain. Something like that isn't acceptable nowadays as apparent with the whole controversy when Frank Miller wanted to make a Batman book where he fights Al Qaeda - Yet the whole Republican vs. Liberal angle is overdone, widely permissible nowadays in comics because that is far less alienating, but it's hard to tell if the political impact of comics is mostly positive or negative. I think it is likely it causes more (trollish) debates than inspire someone to get involved in something meaningful.

Avatar image for slapz88
slapz88

63

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

Edited By slapz88

I don't believe comics should ever think of not using something like politics in the book. These are fictional books and if an author wants to write about something then he should be able to without drawbacks and as long as he writes within the rating system.

Avatar image for pikahyper
pikahyper

19027

Forum Posts

37057995

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 581

Edited By pikahyper  Moderator

I think politics are ok to an extent, most of it isn't very in your face but there have been a few instances that annoyed me like the mayoral debates in Spider-Man and DC Universe: Decisions a while back.

Avatar image for multiverse
multiverse

317

Forum Posts

209

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 14

Edited By multiverse

I think there is a difference between including opinions on specific issues or people in comic books and politics in comics. Obviously, writers can avoid talking about specific people or issues in comic books. However, even the most escapist fantasy story is political just by virtue of who is featured as the hero or villain, how the heroes/villains relate to the world around them, and even in a writers choice to write an escapist story.

Avatar image for mbecks14
Mbecks14

2114

Forum Posts

4160

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 15

Edited By Mbecks14

I don't care about real politics, so i definitely don't care about comic book politics.

Avatar image for apatheticavenger
ApatheticAvenger

1726

Forum Posts

58560

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: -3

Edited By ApatheticAvenger

I don't find things that interest me alienating. Of course, the things that interest me happen to be sex, drugs, politics, science, violence, and atheism, in no particular order. ^_^

If including political content into a story makes it more compelling (V for Vendetta or God Loves, Man Kills), then why the hell not? I personally found the jab at the tea party in Captain America quite entertaining. :P

Avatar image for zur_en_arrh
Zur_En_Arrh

64

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

Edited By Zur_En_Arrh
Funny that this article is from Sara Lima, who re-posts a bunch of inaccurate, left-leaning rhetoric on her facebook, such as who in Congress is spending what, but when she posts her own actual views, such as her belief that people on welfare should be drug tested (which I totally agree with), it's all more right-leaning points of view.
I think it depends on the actual story telling. If you're gonna tell a story like, say Morrison's new Superman who goes after actual bad guys in a way that might depict them as the "greedy banker" type, cool!. If you are gonna write a story where the hero feels the eye of "big brother government" must be stopped, I'm down with that too. However, if you are gonna blatantly bash someone's point of view, be they small government Tea Partier (teabagger) or big government liberal (pinko commie hippie), then no. A good writer should be able to interject any political points of view he or she has without making it so blatant as to name-call the other side. OR! Even do away with them all together and just tell a freaking great story.

Well said. and it pretty much sums up my point of view on politics in comics. Political commentary is one thing, being small minded and heavy handed with politics, as well as sex and religion for that matter, is just irresponsibility plain and simple.

Avatar image for amp___seeker_of_lost_knowledge
AMP - Seeker of Lost Knowledge

1363

Forum Posts

48694

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 45

User Lists: 14

Only to those who are not aware of politics in high school and collage OR are above the age of 21.

Speaking of politics, here's something for propaganda on War on Terrorism and anti-Islamic terrorists: FRANK MILLER'S HOLY TERROR (now available in comic book stores and book stores).

.
.
Avatar image for redheadedatrocitus
RedheadedAtrocitus

6958

Forum Posts

8982

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 3

Well comics should be above politics but in truth it is not. In the end it has to be about how one construes the implicit or explicit sexual message that is being given. Sure, one can see the obvious communistic connotations in Superman: Red Son or the overt criticism of the Tea Party in Avengers #602 (tea baggers); but it is up to the reader to either be offended or acknowledging of those messages. If people are offended by those kind of issues then it is something that is with the reader, not an issue of the reading material. The fact that such messages exist does not degenerate the quality of the reading material in comics. If anything they enhance it and make the story more realistic to us as readers.

Avatar image for dewboy01
dewboy01

2362

Forum Posts

6147

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 17

User Lists: 17

Edited By dewboy01

can't we just be social, instead being racial?

Avatar image for marshal_victory
Marshal Victory

692

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Marshal Victory
@AMP - Seeker of Lost Knowledge said:

Only to those who are not aware of politics in high school and collage OR are above the age of 21.

Speaking of politics, here's something for propaganda on War on Terrorism and anti-Islamic terrorists: FRANK MILLER'S HOLY TERROR (now available in comic book stores and book stores).

.
.

Heh i was just gona bring this up. plan on buying my copy this month.Just because of the whines of the posters on amazon . 
 
"Stay away from three subjects: religion, politics and sex"Was my rules in high school. Some 22 years later i still have same small core group of friends.But by using those rules for while we all figured out who fit our group an who didnt.Id say its safe to say 3/4th of us lean right. 
 
Tho um who said "conservative Tea Party "? Most tea party member are middle to right  sure.But its a bit of a streach to say its a conservative group.. Scot Brown doesnt fit as a conservative an they helped elect him.Tho seems this time around they will not. 
 
V for vendetta is a great example of what the author ment . an what your read. an years later what it can mean. same for the film actualy.What the author ment, what time changed an what you read are all not the same thing. 
 
Many a conservatives do like the movie, as well as the books .Even tho Alan Moore ment it as a slam against Regan an Thatcher years later to some its a tale of big goverment gone mad. 
 
Comics with out politics  would just be about religion, and sex.Or lack their of.
Avatar image for theblackhood
TheBlackHood

594

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By TheBlackHood

@AlexDM said:

That panel is a flattering picture of Tea Partiers. Photos I've seen show poorer sign-making and English Language skills. Also, that cowardice from Marvel has alienated me.

I'm going to guess any racists, homophobes, and fascists who read V For Vendetta felt alienated by it. Complete hatred of an ideology you hold is more alienating than praise of one you don't. Especially as Moore's view has a lot in common with mainstream politics in the West; the basic idea that "everyone should be the masters of their own destinies" is something most of us can agree on.

Of course you've never seen or heard anything ignorant or stupid from the liberal left right, Alex? I don't suppose you remember the woman claiming that President Obama would pay her mortgage or put gas in her car? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P36x8rTb3jI

I've always found it interesting how the tolerant left are often the most intolerant to anyone who has an opposing view.

Avatar image for pauldro952
Pauldro952

214

Forum Posts

1960

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 54

User Lists: 1

Edited By Pauldro952

I believe some comics are meant for political topics such as Green Arrow and X-men (and many others). But, I prefer non-political stuff because it become a battleground on who's right and who's wrong. If comics take a political stance they can alienate some readers, and that's not what the comic industry needs right now. I think they should touch on the subject but not take a stance in it. Grant Morrison once said

"politics date comics, we want to make comics timeless as we can. " I can't deal with political fads or fancies, I'd rather deal with universal ideas which everyone can agree with so everyone can read it.
Avatar image for alexdm
AlexDM

42

Forum Posts

122

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 16

User Lists: 0

Edited By AlexDM

@TheBlackHood: I'm sorry, what does that have to do with signs? And where did you get "intolerant" from?

Avatar image for shrat
Shrat

1

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Shrat

Please keep politics out of my comics. I see enough of it in the real world, I don't need it shoved down my throat when I'm trying to escape for a bit.