mtharman's Arkham Asylum: Madness #1 - Arkham Asylum: Madness review

    Avatar image for mtharman
    • Score:
    • mtharman wrote this review on .
    • 3 out of 3 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • mtharman has written a total of 100 reviews. The last one was for Knife Trick
    • This review received 2 comments

    How much horror can one person take?


    To celebrate one of my most favorite months, I decided to review one of the most dark, and craziest comics that i've found within my collection, and I decided to review a book that tried its very best to show an audience the meaning and visuals of pure insanity.   

     
     
    Sam Kieth would introduce Arkham Asylum: Madness 
     
    But was Sam able to give us a story that would have the children suffering at night with the most horrible nightmares of DC's beloved Joker and a selected cast of Arkham Inmates, or was this a project that was too much for Sam to handle as a writer and an artist? 
    Well, despite the cartoonish artwork that many modern day fans are probably not used too, Sam Keith would introduce new forms of art and skills as he tries to define what insanity is and also focus on something much more worse when involving some humanity into this mangled masterpiece of a story.  
    But as much as Sam tried to design and create the best of his worst, this was probably the most difficult and fustrating storyline that he probably ever did, almost to the point where he ended up losing his sanity.
     
    So lets take a look inside Sam Kieths Arkham Asylum: Madness and see if all the effort he put into this paid off and had me scared crapless or go on the verge of  !! Madness !! 
     
       
     
     
     Well, I can say that my first impression about this book was the artwork, I honestly dislike this artwork because of how messed up it really looks, but if you actually give the artwork a chance like I did and try to make your moneys worth, then like myself you would be shocked on how much the artwork really fits within the storyline.  
    Sam Kieth would use the combination of pencil drawings, water coloring, and digital manipulation to really define the moments and the meaning of what we would see as sanity and insanity. As an example, this story would start of with the main character, Sabine, who's a day shift nurse for the Asylum and is on her way to be dropped off at work, it's the moment when you see her leave her son to start the days work you begin to feel a little bit uncomfortable, right at the first moment you see signs of Sabine disliking her job as she first steps into the building, and it would be the artwork that would help this storyline be so convincing, to where you wouldn't want Sabine stepping through the doors of Arkham, but to turn back and go home, to quit............................... and yet, thats just the beginning of the book. 
    So with Sam mastering his cartoonish blended masterpiece to have his audience blend into the storyline, the story does an outstanding job with the main character Sabine, who managed to meet the Sam Kieths goal. 
     
    To show the audience how much can one person go through and endure. To show that quitting can be much more of a horror than the Joker himself, (which is shown within this storyline)
     
     
     
     
    Seriously, any normal person would instantly quit this job as a day-shift nurse where every single day is hell or possibly become a victim for an inmate outbreak or something much worse, but for Sabine there is a real reason, a motive to support her son and family, and as an audience we will see her go through the most difficult challenge of her life as we go along with her and wonder if she would take that step and finally quit. 
     
    and thats the rewarding answer, does she quit, or not? and yes, there is an answer to that question. 
     
     
     
    But, sadly there are some upset moments within this book. Even though Sam said he had a hard time with the Joker, that he couldn't get his character right, I honestly thought Joker did pretty well with this storyline. My problem is both Two-Face and Harley Quinn, really out of character for those two. With Two-Face doing the heavy set thug routine and Harley doing the punk rocker chick thing, im glad that these two didn't get more spotlight. Yet there is no interaction with Joker and Harley at all, but more character interaction with Poison Ivy. 
    Some characters really creeped me out with their short appearances like Killer Croc who I couldn't tell if he was dead or not, and Man-Bat who found a way to cure headaches, I felt that Sam really hit the spot with these two monsters and the Joker.
     
    Despite the two character misshaps, my opinion is that Sam Kieth really hit a home run with this comic. I liked how he had me convinced and on the edge of my seat wondering how the main character Sabine would survive through the day and night within the walls of Arkham. With Sam Kieth trying to make a horror story with the main character going through the most painful steps to get home and see her son, I would find myself convinced that every dollar was worth it for this comic. 
    So if your picky about artwork, I highly advise leaving this issue alone so that you don't have to be an asshole to shame this madness masterpiece that damn near sent Sam to the nuthouse. I also highly advise to give this storyline a try, with the expectations of being creeped out, seeing suspense, and thrills, you probably find yourself worshipping this comic. 
     
    Im That Badguy saying thankyou for reading, have a nice Halloween, and make sure that you dont turn into some jibbering nutjob if you do decide to read this comic.

    Other reviews for Arkham Asylum: Madness #1 - Arkham Asylum: Madness

      A symbolic chaos of "Madness" 0

      Welcome to Arkham Asylum and Sam Kieth is the master of madness.  Sam Kieth might be most famous for being the guy who walked away from Neil Gaiman's Sandman, but a lot of his fans love him for the odd ball superhero series The Maxx.  For those who don't know what The Maxx is, it was a adapted to an MTV animation which starred a huge purple crime fighter who is trapped between this mystical Outback and the real world.  Sam is no stranger to Madness, The Maxx was a series of pure imagination...

      2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

      A Good Grim Tale 0

      I randomly read this at my leisure not really knowing what to expect.  This book kind of goes hand and hand with Arkham Asylum: A Serious House on a Serious Earth, the tale follows a nurse Salene Robbins, through a 24hr shift at Arkham, and the events that take place within. This story is rather enjoyable, so Im not going to tell much about the actual things that transpire, but I will tell you that it's worth picking this book up if you like unconventional Batman tales.  Sam Keith does a great j...

      2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.