the_mighty_monarch's Aquaman #9 - The Others, Chapter Three review

Soldier of Ocean

I feel like this cover is too 'scene specific' and it's really pretty close to being a boring 'standard action' image that could simply be a panel, but something about the invisible lines of focus from back where all the animals are coming from, the guns are pointing... there's like a sunburst on the edge, and it kind of works.

As nicely paced as the opening scene is, I have to laugh when Black Manta has to stab a gold rock into a sign that says "Psychiatrischer Krenkenhaus" in for it to say "Psychiatric Hospital." Really dude? You wouldn't have done the research and KNOWN WHAT YOU WERE LOOKING FOR BEFOREHAND? You had to stab it with a rock just for translation so that..... so that you would know you're in the right place? Except the place is in Germany so it would probably have been listed under the original German listing anyways? Was it for the benefit of the readers? We really couldn't figure out that it meant 'Psych Hospital?' The first work its really close to Psychiatric, and there could've been a translation box for us. But nope, Black Manta had to stab a sign with a gold rock for no damn reason.

And the... GOD such an incredible fight scene ensues. Black Manta is a serious threat, and a cold creepy badass. There's a lot of fantastic bits to this fight, and it makes the whole scene really engaging. And then Prisoner of War's powers are DEMONSTRATED instead of awkwardly explained. The two of them going at is an epic scuffle to behold. And there's also a nice bit of psychological exploration of PoW subtle slid in there.

I can't say the same of the following fight scene, the one represented on the cover. That one plays out very standardly, not actually 'bad,' but a weak follow-up to the glory that preceded it.

But then Johns makes up for it in the pages he has left. Dr. Shin's backstory is elaborated, and I feel a bit of sympathy for him. His obsessive dedication to science for the sake of itself isn't inherently evil, though it can easily lead to sadistic madness. (Cave Johnson anyone?)

And then that scene is interjected with the resuming of the fight, and the revelation in the end is masterful. I don't know how much of it was true before, but as someone relatively new to the wider Aquaman mythos (and certainly to true new readers) this issue's final page will leave you wide-eyed and desperate for more.

In Conclusion: 4.8/5

It's not QUITE perfect, but it's the closest this series has gotten. The Black Manta / Prisoner of War fight was AWESOME, and the following revelations set a dark and climactic tone for the rest of this arc, and the next issue. The only REAL problems were the lackluster second fight scene, and the utterly STUPID first page.

2 Comments
Posted by jinxuandi

I too thought the first page was silly. Really, Manta? How many signs did you go around poking before you found the right one?

Great issue though.

Posted by Mumbles

first page was kinda silly indeed. still one of the best new 52 books out there. loved the last page.

Other reviews for Aquaman #9 - The Others, Chapter Three

    No other choice 0

    There is maybe nothing extremely exceptional about this series on its service in such issues, but everything works together in such a polished and smooth way that the stories become near perfection.  One of the main factors in that for my (somewhat biased) outlook is that Johns excels at writing strong female characters, and now there is not only Mera but also Ya’wara here.  That there is so much going on in this issue is not detracting from the overall effect, in fact it adds to it as there is ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    Manta's sting. 0

    People have plenty of good reason to hate on Geoff Johns, but if there's one thing we all seem to be agreeing on is that his run on Aquaman is proving to us all that he's still got the chops to keep writing hard hitting and engaging stories.To begin with, Black Manta is an INCREDIBLE villain. John's does his best to make the character as threatening and as menacing as possible, and he succeeds at making it work. Rather than making him the sort of villain that just shows up and thrashes everyone ...

    4 out of 4 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.