the_mighty_monarch's Animal Man Annual #1 - Endless Rot review

Storytime With Socks

So, this cover isn't too stellar. Oh sure the art is great and all, but the whole thing is just WAY too stiff. There's no sense of movement or dynamism.

But the interior art has no such problem! I'm torn on whether I think Timothy Green II should've replaced Travel Foreman on interiors instead of Steve Pugh. Green certainly has a style closer to Foreman than Pugh does. His minimal use of shading really works wonders for the similarities. Sure he draws Maxine's head a little too big, but other than that he had a lot of the same excellent energy. Well, stuff was less creepy and disturbing, a little more cartoony, but only a sliver. His art was excellent for this.

The nature of this as an Annual leaves me with mixed feelings. Any current Animal Man readers NEEDS to get this, it's got the same excellent character focused writing, and really expands on the mythos Animal Man and Swamp Thing are building. What the past's Swamp Thing tells the past's Animal Man is something that will definitely shock some readers, though the amount of sense it makes means you might see it coming, but in a good way. Plus it sets up a possible far future crossover again between the two with its inception of the idea that The Red or The Green could become villains just as easily as The Rot has. My money would be on The Green considering how The Parliament of Trees keeps telling Alec that The Red sucks and The Totems keep telling Buddy that he needs to seek out Swamp Thing.

But its greatest strength is also its greatest weakness. Are most comic readers willing to shell out $5 for this side story? It's certainly good enough, though it feels almost the length of a normal issue. It's probably a story that would've taken up two issues normally, and by the end I was completely satisfied, didn't feel like the story was too short; but I kind of forgot it was an Annual considering how long it FELT. But do I regret my purchase? HELL NO! But it's key to the mythos.

In Conclusion: 4.5/5

The whole scene with Buddy Baker didn't make a lot of sense, and the fact that the old Animal Man also called his daughter 'Little Wing' seemed pretty forced; but overall this was another excellent Animal Man story by Jeff Lemire. It lacked the full usual 'zazz' that this series normally has, but overall it was extremely solid, great from start to finish. Can Socks have his own ongoing please? I'm really starting to love the little guy XD

2 Comments
Posted by JonesDeini

I just was not feeling this art, I'm actually relieved that it was Pugh and Not green doing the interiors. I'm holding off on purchasing both annuals due to price point but from my quick perusal of both in store I can say that I'll definitely be checking them out sooner than later. They felt a bit thin though. Any info on the overall page count?

Posted by The Mighty Monarch

@JonesDeini: Animal Man is 38 pages of story. I just counted. Haven't gotten to Batman yet.

Other reviews for Animal Man Annual #1 - Endless Rot

    Rot from the Past 0

    THE GOOD: The art in this issue is decent. Timothy Green II does a great job at copying Travel Foreman's style from the beginning of the series. He also adds the amazing paneling from the current Swamp Thing series. I also really like how he is very good at making sure things are where they were the next time you see them. The story is amazing. Jeff Lemire manages to introduce you to new characters in a different time, with a similar situation. The results are an amazing story with a lot of emot...

    2 out of 3 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.