jonesdeini's All-Star Western #1 - No Rest for the Wicked review

Urban Cowboy

Jonah Hex is brought into to Gotham to help bring a serial killer to justice. Pretty simple concept, but then again nothing's ever done the easy way when Hex is involved.

The Good

Man oh man, where to start here, because I could go on for days, folk. How about the cover? Holy crap, how about that cover?! Moritat draws the holy hell out of this comic from cover to cover. And his pencils and Bautista's colors go together like biscuits and gravy! (Hey, I'm from South Carolina)

I really can't compliment the art in this book enough. It's one of the best looking titles in the new 52 and considering that it's up against Batwoman that's no small feat. The opening shot of Gotham is absolutely majestic and perfectly captures the essence of the city. Scott Snyder is often noted for making Gotham a character in his stories but Gray and Palmiotti do a damned good job of it themselves from the jump. The amount of detail that Moritat packs into this page is mind blowing! And the way Bautista mutes and fades the colors of objects and characters in the background really gives the book a unique look.

I really loved that Amadeus Arkham is featured prominently in this story. His monologue perfectly sets a tone for this story and serves as a great way for readers to get to know Hex through Arkham's psychological analysis of Jonah. And as a psychology major I must say I got a kick out of how he was written this issue. Anybody familiar with Freud will surely get a kick out of this depiction of Arkham. And the way that that chief Cromwell reacts to Arkham's presence based upon his job as a "head shrinker" was a great bit of historical realism. Having he and Hex team up to hunt down the Gotham Butcher made for some great character interaction and humor.

This issue has a huge amount of action and Moritat perfectly depicts every panel of it and Gray and Palmiotti do a great job of balancing it out with Arkham's dialogue.

If it's one thing that this creative team knows how to do it's Jonah Hex! From the moment he steps on the scene we get Hex being Hex. Here's all you need to know about Hex as a new reader. Jonah's a tough frontier man, trouble tends to follow his arrival, he ain't lookin' for it but if you bring it his way you'll regret it, and he's one hell of shot with those six shooters. The scene with the would be muggers excellently establishes these facts and "Bandit's Roost" was a nice nod to "Crime Alley"

When I heard that this story would be taking place in Gotham I was a bit concerned, I was worried how Hex being in the big city would work. And honestly it works like a charm! Hex's no stranger to fish out of water tales, but nothing about this one feels redundant and much like in Gates of Gotham (which there are some nice references too) the late 1800's Gotham provides quite an interesting playground. Hex's brash, rough and tumble style provides a great contrast to the "civilized" more's of Gotham. And seeing him cut loose in classic Hex fashion during the bar fight was a real treat.

I love how Gotham never really changes throughout time. You can build new buildings, add new characters, but that dark heart remains at the core. Gray and Palmiotti get Gotham and do a fine job of depicting the classic elements of it that persist through the ages. The city is a hungry living, beast that devours the innocent and weak. The police are no help and the governments riddled with corruption. And the affluent are actively depraved or appallingly indifferent to it all.

One of the biggest strengths of Gray and Palmiotti's writing is their ability to write genuinely humorous character interaction and dialogue. Hex crashing Mayor Cobblepot's ritzy party was truly a collection of pages that made me smile and laugh out loud.

The end of this issue definitely ratchets up the tension and raises the stakes. I can't wait to see how this plays out as the story progresses.

The Bad

Some may be put off by the old Jack the Ripper inspired story.

The Verdict

All Star Western is without a doubt 28 pages of excellence at it's highest echelon! I'd honestly forgot how thick a $4 book could and should be. And not a single page in this issue is fluff, this book's truly flawless from front to back. I must admit my love of Jonah Hex began as a kid when I saw him on Batman: TAS and I always enjoyed his appearances in other DCAU properties like JLU or Batman: Brave and the Bold. I'd never read a monthly Hex comic til today, but had seen him in other titles over the years. Well, I can definitely say that with this creative team on this book All Star Western will be a book I'll be reading for years to come!

5 Comments
Posted by Silkcuts

I didn't bother mentioning the Ripper inspired story.
But I like how when the hoe was crucified, there was no eyes and blood from the mouth.  I can hope we can assume it is a homage to the wise monkey's of see, hear and say no evil.

Posted by JonesDeini

@Silkcuts said:

I didn't bother mentioning the Ripper inspired story. But I like how when the hoe was crucified, there was no eyes and blood from the mouth. I can hope we can assume it is a homage to the wise monkey's of see, hear and say no evil.

Interesting observation. Wonder if we'll get another look at her corpse to see if the ears were mutilated as well.

Posted by Silkcuts
@JonesDeini: the observation was only because I saw Dexter Season 5 recently.  The comparison to the classic Ripper story is a good one, especially factoring From Hell from Moore suggest secret society.
Posted by JonesDeini

@Silkcuts said:

@JonesDeini: the observation was only because I saw Dexter Season 5 recently. The comparison to the classic Ripper story is a good one, especially factoring From Hell from Moore suggest secret society.

Yeah the theory of The Ripper being a prominent Mason is a popular one.

Posted by mattiebatslayer

I was gonna write a review but you basically said it all and probably better. Wonderful review, thank you. 

Other reviews for All-Star Western #1 - No Rest for the Wicked

    Brilliant is nearly every way. This is one great book. 0

    Coming off of an amazing run on "Jonah Hex", Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray are back with "All-Star Western" #1, the only book of it's kind in DC's New 52 and hands down one of the most satisfying reading experiences of the entire relaunch. Everything that made Palmiotti and Gray's Hex run great can be found in the first issue. It features a wonderful period feel and some great character work. But in other ways this book is quite different. While Jonah is the same snarling, tough-as-nails guy ...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    It's Still Jonah Hex. What Else Do You Want? 0

    All-Star Western lives up to people's expectations as Jonah Hex teams up with Amadeus Arkham to track a Jack the Ripper-style killer in old Gotham City. It is a different way of starting off a book like this, setting a western in the east, but it pays off.Rather than Jonah Hex, the story is told through the perspective and narration of Amadeus Arkham. This works really well for introducing Hex, though. Arkham spends a great deal of time trying to understand Hex, making himself a good vehicle for...

    3 out of 3 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.