johnkmccubbin91's All Star Superman #1 - All-Star Superman review

How to Kill a Superman

After watching Man of Steel a few weeks ago I have been in a huge Superman mood going through some of my favourite stories of the Man of Tomorrow as well as trying some that I haven't already read. This however is probably my favourite Superman story of all time, as I always enjoy reading it.

Plot

After saving Leo Quintum and his crew whilst on a mission to explore the sun, Superman is exposed to too much radiation, giving him new powers, whilst also slowly killing him. Superman then goes on the quest to put the Earth in a position where it can survive without him.

Review

This was simply a phenomenal story, and easily one of the best Superman stories of all time, and my personal favourite. Grant Morrison has done such a great job of telling this wonderful story, that shows Superman at his most weakest point, knowing that he's going to die. This itself is risky, as to have the reader know from the first issue that the main character is going to die isn't easy to follow on from, especially when you have a further eleven issues to go, but Morrison does a good job of this. Besides this Morrison takes some of the most well known Superman tales, and concepts, making them his own by telling some fabulous mini-stories, whilst ultimately developing towards the conclusion of the main story. Morrison also handled the emotion perfectly, as well as the characters, the action, and the relationships, especially the relationship between Lois Lane, and Superman.

This story had the amazing Frank Quitely doing the artwork, which was truly outstanding. Now Quitely's art isn't for everyone, and I initially wasn't a fan, but have since grown to love his quirky, unique style. His art in this story's simply amazing, and is superbly detailed, with next to no imperfections. The layout of Quitely's art is also brilliant, adding a lot more depth to the story, as well as adding some more drama as well. What I loved most about Quitely's art however was how he drew Clark, and Superman so different, with Clark looking out of shape, as well as his usual clumsy self, which made his guise seem more believable. Quitely also did a great job of showing the character's emotions with it being easy to tell what the character's feeling, as well as explosive action, which was very exciting and dramatic. The inking, and colouring from Jamie Grant was also amazing, making the art feel whole.

This story would feature a group named P.R.O.J.E.C.T. run by it's director, Leo Quintum which experiment to find new discoveries, ultimately hoping to create a replacement for Superman. I found this an interesting addition to the story, as with a group that's goal is to find a replacement for Superman, it's appropriate for a story where he's dying. I also loved how Leo interacted with Superman, and how he wasn't afraid to go into dangerous positions. I also found his assistant Agatha to be very interesting, and the entire concept was brilliant, and worked perfectly in this story.

I already mentioned the fact that this story showed the relationship between Lois, and Superman, showing it more developed now that Superman knows of his upcoming demise. It also would show Superman give her a fabulous birthday present in a story that would also feature both Samson, and Atlas. Now I don't know much about either of these character's besides their mythological background, but I loved seeing them both fight over Lois along with Superman. The story itself was also very fun, and interesting, with some exciting, and explosive sequences. It was also nice to see Superman involved in a bit of fun leading up to his death.

The Superman Squad, a collection of Supermen from the future who send messages to others in the past. Now this wasn't the best part of this story, but there was a issue that dealt with Clark's earlier life, and his relationship with his father, Jonathan Kent. Now I won't go into any details as to avoid spoilers, but this was a very entertaining, and emotional issue, and I loved seeing the inexperienced Clark, along with his fateful dog, Krypto stand up to these future Supermen. To be honest the addition of Krypto was enough for me to enjoy that issue, as I love that dog.

Now I come to one of my favourite parts of this entire story, the issue set in Bizarro World. This was simply an amazing mini-story, and Morrison handled it perfectly. I especially loved the fact that there was a smart Bizarro in the form of Zibarro, who showed a lot of emotion, being an outcast in this world, much like Superman felt like on Earth. The Bizarro JLA were also very amusing, and I loved seeing them in their backward form. I also felt that Morrison handled Superman's actions during this perfectly, as they were very clever, and appropriate.

Now it's hard to forget the most used villain in Superman history, Lex Luthor, and Morrison doesn't do so here. Now Luthor may be over used, but I have to give props when he's used to the advantage of a story, and that's what he was in this. The interaction between both Luthor, and Superman, as well as Luthor, and Clark was brilliant, and exactly as I'd imagine they'd be. Luthor was also very conniving, and resourceful, and the fight between him and Superman at the end of this story was phenomenal, and truly a great last fight for this fabulous story.

Final Verdict

This is considered as one of the all time greatest Superman story ever, with a lot of people classing it as the best story ever, me included. Morrison gives a very emotional, and symbolic story, that shows Superman in his final days. It also had some fun, and interesting mini-stories, which fit perfectly into the main story. The action was also perfect, being exciting, and explosive, with great art from Quitely Due to all this I'd highly recommend this story to anyone, whether you're a Superman fan or not, and if you are a Superman fan and haven't read this, then you certainly need to, as it is definitely amongst the best Superman stories ever.

Rating: 5/5

20 Comments
Posted by flazam

Another Great Review

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@flazam: Thanks very much, much appreciated.

Edited by SmashBrawler

Great review, as always. I would've been worried if this hadn't been a 5/5 :P

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@smashbrawler: Thanks very much. This story is Morrison at his best, and although I prefer Morrison's Batman work as a whole, this has to be the best story he's written so far.

Posted by broo1232

Awesome review might review this myself at some point. I loved Lex Luthor in this just so clever and well written, and the gospel according to Lex Luthor is probably my favourite Superman comic ever (I haven't read much Superman but I loved it so much) agree that Bizarro was great always liked him a lot.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@broo1232: Thanks very much. I usually complain about Luthor being over used, but when it's as good as this I can forget that, it's just that mostly it isn't, though gladly it was in this. I'd love to read a review done by you as well : )

Posted by broo1232

@johnkmccubbin91: No problem. I agree Luthor's overused, but I haven't read a lot of him (this was my first read) and then I read other stuff as well, but this still remains my favourite appearance. When I have time I'll do it.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91
Edited by Raw_Material

Another outstanding 5 star review.

Nice work!

Edited by johnkmccubbin91
Posted by Lvenger

An awesome review as always that showcases why this is the best Superman story of all time :)

Edited by johnkmccubbin91

@lvenger: Thanks very much, and it certainly is. (This has been edited as I initially spoke about another series not realising)

Posted by Lvenger

@johnkmccubbin91: Heck your review got me to order the complete edition of All Star Superman on Amazon. I've been meaning to do it for some time but reading this review was what made me do it. It is my favourite Superman story of all time so it's only right I have it in my collection.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@lvenger: Yeah I went to get that but got them in separate volumes for less but this was a good few months ago.

Posted by thanosrules

Awesome job!

I recently watched the movie version of this story on Netflix... I then went to read it, and noticed that it was almost identical! Again, great review. Loved this story. Still thinking about it long after...

Posted by TheAcidSkull

I still haven't read this

FOR SHAME!

(great Review, man)

Posted by Cyclops4President

A great review. What a beautiful cover. I'll put this on my queque.

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@thanosrules: Thanks very much. The film was also brilliant, though I prefer this greatly, and was disappointed that it dropped Bizarro World. It did also have nice additives of it's own, but overall I'll also remember this story for years to come.

@theacidskull: Thanks, and you won't be disappointed if you do get round to reading it.

@cyclops4president: Thanks very much. It is a nice cover, and the art inside is even better, and I'd highly recommend the story to anyone.

Posted by TheAcidSkull

@johnkmccubbin91: I'm sure i won't :P, Grant morrison man, thats all i need to know :P

Posted by johnkmccubbin91

@theacidskull: Yeah he's an amazing writer (my second favourite).

Other reviews for All Star Superman #1 - All-Star Superman

    ME AM NO GREATEST SUPERMAN STORY EVER!!! 0

    This is my 150th review, end of story.I love this book I wasn’t a Superman fan before I read this book, but afterwards I really like the character and its half the reason I read Superman Unchained now, but this still remains a favourite story of mine, and I’ve re-read this loads of time.PlotSuperman travels to the sun to help a science team from falling into it, but Lex luthor has poisoned Superman due to him being to near to the Sun and Superman begins to die, but his powers have been increase...

    6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.