xenatorres's All-New X-Men #30 review

    Avatar image for xenatorres
    • Score:
    • xenatorres wrote this review on .
    • 2 out of 2 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
    • This review received 1 comments

    Can't write X-23 to save their lives

    Ugh. While I love the other characters in this series, I am royally unhappy with the writing of X-23. The writers need to sit down and read some Kyle and Yost issues, or at the very least her origin 6 issues comics and learn about this character.

    X-23 is WAAAAAAAAAY too chatty in All New X-Men for one thing, and doesn't talk at all like her. X-23 tends to talk in short sentences, without contractions. All New X-Men also writes her with far too much self awareness - which is something she really lacks. While it would be nice to see her beginning to be able to do this - to just jump in with it makes it completely out of character. X-23 would also not immediately be out dancing on the dance floor - she likely wouldn't even understand the point. The writers seem to forget that she has very little experience with living, so she needs to be introduced to new experiences.

    And what's with her falling for every guy in 2 point 5 seconds? And now casual sex? Um...cause the last time X-23 had sex was when she was a prostitute because she didn't know how to be a person and just took orders from the first person who gave them to her. This casual la-dee-da they went about in this issue was yet another completely out of character moment for her - especially when she was into Cyclops, what, days earlier (which in itself was not believable in that short period and considering how she left the X-Men). Speaking of how she left the X-Men - so she's cool being around Miss Frost all of a sudden? While they haven't interacted at all, X-23 did threaten to kill Miss Frost if she saw her again - so that's just meh, whatever?

    But then, no one except her wonderful creators seem able to write X-23. Come save X-23 from bad writer, Kyle and Yost!!!

    Other reviews for All-New X-Men #30

      Summer Lovin' 0

      I'm sure Wolverine will have no problem with Angel boning his clone daughter... We have all been there. If you are thinking to yourself... isn't that a little racy for comics? Then you haven't been reading X-Men for the past 50 years. When the X-Men are not out fighting villains, they just chill out, and get into trouble at home! It's funny to see Angel in a club pissing people off because they keep bumping into his wings. X-Men has always had a formula in comics with superhero action, young lov...

      1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

      This is Ridiculous 0

      Personally I don't know what Bendis is thinking about with this at all. I find that this sort of relationship with X/23 and Past Angel to be... not good one. I mean sure it was nice of him to take her out to un-wind her mind from what she's been through but this... does it really need to happen and go that far?I personally just don't know what to think anymore about this series after Bendis had this group move in with Cyclops. I also don't particularly am satisfied that he took Laura and change...

      1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.