Old Ghosts
Story-
-It's Halloween in the Fortress of Solitude, and one of the Phantom Zone's prisoners is Haunting Kal-El
Good-
-This is my favorite Superman comic of the new 52, the art is haunting and Grant Morrison's story-telling is still wonderful
-We see more "skeletons in the closet" of Jor-El, so to speak, which is cool, and it's not as past-oriented as Superman #0, and we learn more about the Phantom Zone, how it works and it's history, which only means Zod is right around the corner somewhere.
-A new villain called Xa-Du is introduced, i actually like him alot. I would like to know more why he was trapped in the Phantom Zone, and i felt kinda bad that he never had a parole hearing because of planetary detonation.
-People in the Phantom Zone basically being Ghosts in the real world is cool, and Halloweeny.
-We learn how Krypto survived the explosion of Krypton
-This story doesn't require a part 2, it tells a full story in on comic, which is what has been annoying me in Justice League comics. Sometimes readers don't want a 6 issue comic about a villain we don't care for.
-the Phantom Stranger Shows up, which is cool
Bad-
-The Phantom Stranger shows up, the complaint is actually more that P.S.has an origin and runnind series. I like him having guest appearances like in this comic, rather than a story about him
Verdict-
-This is a great comic, the haunting art is phanominal, and the one shot story is great. I'd recommend it, its a good read the first time and the seventh